Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[mookiemcgee]

I think you zombies should go invade the newb game....

[charm]

Anyone got a question for me? I'm bored.
What did you do with my body anyway. Oh look, an earthworm. Fascinating how an earthworm looks the same in both scotland and canada. Have you ever wondered how a dead smells like? Smell my finger.

Sure Sirius...are we correct in stating that DB4 and Tuffy are your mafia scum brothers?

I think you zombies should go invade the newb game....

Totally agree...come over cause some trouble in the Noobville game...it's getting boring.

[legionnare]

Well we don't have full consensus yet, not everyone has come in to speak since DB4 was at L1, I will postpone until I am back from work (10 hours) I agree with Kill that Tuffy is our next target though.

[TuffyLess]

Why so much hate for me

Ive been called many things in life but thug has never been one of them.
Nobody is sticking up for me when Ive had many of your backs.

[legionnare]

Why so much hate for me

Ive been called many things in life but thug has never been one of them.
Nobody is sticking up for me when Ive had many of your backs.

Nothing to say in DB4's defense though?

[crasp]

with 8 in it takes 5 to lynch. Daytime ends Saturday 19th April'


Vote Count
DB4- charm, Mookie, kinged ,Joak,
Legionaire- DB4, Tuffy
Tuffy- Kill.

DB4 is L-1

[DB4Christ]

All of you are being dooped by scum posing as townie, one of which has showed up innocent to KE3! I have always tried to way the options based on the tells and character play/ploys. I sided with Gab and thought that Moo was lying.. and he was.....for that I am being railroaded! The scum are hiding in the early Kil voting party people!! Wake up and smell the coffee, or the scum will take this game. LOOK AT THE VOTING fellow townies, the evidence is in there. Moo knows how people think, and how to manipulate them. I am sure he knew that when he proclaimed I was scum.....you would react exactly the way you have. I have tried to tell you what's going on before.....that's why he said what he did about me, he wants me lynched because I figured it out! Your all being manipulated by him from the grave..... even now. You want them to win...go ahead and continue walking head-long and blindfolded into their trap! Unreal people.....ask Kil, I think he see's the same things I do, and was almost lynched for it. Gab wasn't just taken out because he was the doctor, he figured it out too. That's why they took him out over KE3!!!

[Killuminati19]

I am not dropping the hammer on DB4. I wish those of you who have your votes on him would reconsider. The most evidence points to Tuffy. I haven't heard a compelling reason to vote DB4.

[mookiemcgee]

All of you are being dooped by scum posing as townie, one of which has showed up innocent to KE3! I have always tried to way the options based on the tells and character play/ploys. I sided with Gab and thought that Moo was lying.. and he was.....for that I am being railroaded! The scum are hiding in the early Kil voting party people!! Wake up and smell the coffee, or the scum will take this game. LOOK AT THE VOTING fellow townies, the evidence is in there. Moo knows how people think, and how to manipulate them. I am sure he knew that when he proclaimed I was scum.....you would react exactly the way you have. I have tried to tell you what's going on before.....that's why he said what he did about me, he wants me lynched because I figured it out! Your all being manipulated by him from the grave..... even now. You want them to win...go ahead and continue walking head-long and blindfolded into their trap! Unreal people.....ask Kil, I think he see's the same things I do, and was almost lynched for it. Gab wasn't just taken out because he was the doctor, he figured it out too. That's why they took him out over KE3!!!

Come on.... Gabs voted for Kill all the way, the only reason the Mafia killed him is because he was stupid enough(no offence Gabs) to out himself as the doctor even though only one person had voted for him. He wasn't killed because he "figured it all out", he had it all wrong with Worm King(Formerly known as MOO).

@ Kill I am willing to reconsider Tuffy. But I think DB4 and he ARE the two remaining Mafia. I'm still out of town till tomorrow eve so I havent been able to post much but if you all can get a majority on Tuffy instead i'm fine with that. With this in mind I'll Unvote for 36 hours

[DB4Christ]

Mook, getting rid of Gab was a tactical move on their part...make no mistake about it. They could have killed the cop KE3...a more damaging power role.... but they didn't! ASK YOURSELF WHY??!!

[Killuminati19]

In Mook's defense, seems to me all Gabs had figured out was that I was mafia. I think Tuffy is iron clad mafia. We have more to figure out with DB4, Legion, and possibly Charm.

[legionnare]

Mook, getting rid of Gab was a tactical move on their part...make no mistake about it. They could have killed the cop KE3...a more damaging power role.... but they didn't! ASK YOURSELF WHY??!!

Gabs took his vote off Sirius and then kept it on Kill all the way, why would he do that if he had "figured it all out"?

[mookiemcgee]

Mook, getting rid of Gab was a tactical move on their part...make no mistake about it. They could have killed the cop KE3...a more damaging power role.... but they didn't! ASK YOURSELF WHY??!!

Gabs took his vote off Sirius and then kept it on Kill all the way, why would he do that if he had "figured it all out"?

I have asked myself why and the reasons seem fairly straightforward...because he was the doctor and he would have used his power to save the cop! The mafia knew this when he outed himself, so they killed him instead of wasting a night on the cop who would have been protected. Db4 if you are not mafia you are doing a really really bad job of convincing me otherwise... I've withdrawn my vote to give others a chance to cast without being the hammer so we can get a sense of where every single person stands.

My gut as of now still says
mafia:
Db4
Tuffy
possibly mafia:
charm
maybe legion but I think he was really just fooled yesterday by sirius I think he is town....

I play alot of poker and I've learned to trust my gut, so I'm sorry this doesnt come with more "reasoning" in this particular post

Are we assuming too much in our belief that there are only 2 mafia left? Is there a chance there is a third person who is mafia, or some weird third party?

[DB4Christ]

Gab thought Kil was the missing mafia link....not the only mafia. I think he knew as some of you do, who the other mafia is. I think he thought Kil had Moo's role of hit man....the doc wouldn't of been able to save the cop from the hitman. As to another third party role....yes...I think there is one left.

[mookiemcgee]

The doc can only save one person, and the obvious choice was the only remaining power role (even if there was a chance he would not have been saved. Also the doc would not have to choose who to save until after he saw the results of the lynch, plus the mafia already knew Sirius was the hitman, so they would plan to kill the doc regardless. Its what I would have done if I was mafia... Sorry DB4 but I'm (still) not buying this.

[DB4Christ]

Yeah...but Gab didn't know Moo was the hit man until after the lynch (hence his Kil vote..all be it wrong). I am just saying what I think Gab was thinking based on his comments and vote.
Your certainly entitled to your conjecture my friend. I am sticking with my conclusions of Gab, and Moos throw on me....its working just like he knew it would!! You don't give him enough credit....the guy almost talked himself into another day....I helped to hang him...that's me getting rid of scum based on my conclusions!

[charm]

I think we have this game nailed. I think remaining mafia is DB4 and Tuffy!

I don't see either of them making a good case and no one is going to their defense. I may be just a fool for a noob, but my instinct is telling me we are right on!

I have no problem repeating over and over that I am just a vanilla town girl. Although, I prefer pistachio ice cream. What is going on at McD's anyways? Is someone going to die by big mac? drown in a milkshake? or maybe boil to death in the fryer?

[crasp]

I think we have this game nailed. I think remaining mafia is DB4 and Tuffy!

I don't see either of them making a good case and no one is going to their defense. I may be just a fool for a noob, but my instinct is telling me we are right on!

I have no problem repeating over and over that I am just a vanilla town girl. Although, I prefer pistachio ice cream. What is going on at McD's anyways? Is someone going to die by big mac? drown in a milkshake? or maybe boil to death in the fryer?

It was going to get burned to the ground with one of you lot in it. Then you went and spoiled it by accidentally lynching the Serial Killer.

[Killuminati19]

I don't agree on this Gabs business. However, there was a point when it was neck and neck between myself and Sirius. I asked DB4, Jaok, and Charm to come forward and give their opinion. DB4 was the first to do so and he voted Sirius. I understand what you are saying on your gut instinct Mookie, I am just not convinced on DB4. Is there any real reason why DB4 is in the cross hairs now as opposed to Tuffy. It seems to me that you all acknowledge Tuffy as likely scum. To me he is the clear choice for a day 4 lynch. And once again, he is nowhere to be found.

[DB4Christ]

Charm, you talk like somebody who knows something without a shadow of a doubt....care to put forth some evidence with that smack??

[legionnare]

Your certainly entitled to your conjecture my friend. I am sticking with my conclusions of Gab, and Moos throw on me....its working just like he knew it would!! You don't give him enough credit....the guy almost talked himself into another day....I helped to hang him...that's me getting rid of scum based on my conclusions!

I am giving Moo enough credit...as the opposite is also true. Sirius throws suspicion on you, you vote Sirius, Sirius gets hanged, anyone who voted on him or that he put suspicion on get's an indirect vouch of being town (as I said before who would think that mafia would out one of their own). There is no doubt that Moo is experienced enough and has the ability to pull it off, as you said he almost talked himself into another day.

Mafia have the ability to talk to each other during the night, would I be wrong in my assumption that the conversation on N2 went along these lines? -

"Sirius has been outed and will be lynched unless he comes up a revive, so he needs a plausible excuse - roleblocker. Chances are high that Sirius will be lynched so he needs to convince the rest of players that 1 of the remaining mafia is town by throwing suspicion on them."

[legionnare]

Yeah...but Gab didn't know Moo was the hit man until after the lynch (hence his Kil vote..all be it wrong). I am just saying what I think Gab was thinking based on his comments and vote.
Your certainly entitled to your conjecture my friend. I am sticking with my conclusions of Gab, and Moos throw on me....its working just like he knew it would!! You don't give him enough credit....the guy almost talked himself into another day....I helped to hang him...that's me getting rid of scum based on my conclusions!

Are you trying to throw suspicion onto Kill? He's claimed Vengeful Townie, I admit we only have his word on it but there has not been any counter to it.

[legionnare]

It seems to me that you all acknowledge Tuffy as likely scum. To me he is the clear choice for a day 4 lynch. And once again, he is nowhere to be found.

I agree, Tuffy is no. 2 on my list. You have pursued him most of the game, if we lynch him and he turns out to be Town you would come under a lot of pressure, are you that sure of it?

[legionnare]

Just a thought, we have not had a claim out of you DB4, you were at L1 for a while.

[joak]

Db4 is making a reasonable defence while tuffy is not in my opinion sounvote til I am a little more sure which of the two are guilty if not both