Prison Mafia TOWN WIN !!

[Dunk90]

This is terrible......PIXAR HAS THE SHANK!!!!!!!! and 2 townies are shanked. I'm doing the math in my head. Not hard to figure out. But he couldn't have done both, could he? Who else could possible have one?

[Maxleod]

This is terrible......PIXAR HAS THE SHANK!!!!!!!! and 2 townies are shanked. I'm doing the math in my head. Not hard to figure out. But he couldn't have done both, could he? Who else could possible have one?

lol

[degaston]

No mafia kill again?!?

And lol at Dukes flip. I was really not expecting that.

Duke's flip? Did you just slip? woopsy

Duke flipped as 3rd party. I was not expecting that.

Whereas you were 99% sure that he would be town.
Was that because you're scum and knew that he would not be scum?

[Dunk90]

That is not good. Really had a good feeling about jmac. Lynch me away! Who shanked Pepe?

You didn't ?

[*Pixar*]

That is not good. Really had a good feeling about jmac. Lynch me away! Who shanked Pepe?

You didn't ?

I did Jmac. So Josh was handing out shanks right? Guessing he did Pepe?

[Maxleod]

No mafia kill again?!?

And lol at Dukes flip. I was really not expecting that.

Duke's flip? Did you just slip? woopsy

Duke flipped as 3rd party. I was not expecting that.

Whereas you were 99% sure that he would be town.
Was that because you're scum and knew that he would not be scum?

Nah. We were just both 100% wrong this time.
I've got one question for you though, are you really the one handing shanks like Ragian said?

[Dunk90]

This is an easy vote. Pixar killed a townie. That deserves a lynch. Unless can convince me otherwise. Although I still think the players with the highest post count, the talkers, deserve another look before final vote.

[degaston]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

[Dunk90]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

Ok, who did you give them to?

[degaston]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

Ok, who did you give them to?

Ragian, Josh and fusi

[Dunk90]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

That puts you on the chopping block as well

[Darin44]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

Ok, who did you give them to?

Ragian, Josh and fusi

Really going to have to thank about this

[joshzam]

SOME GUY: Hey, who wants to play 5-on-5 basketball tomorrow?
A BUNCH OF PEOPLE: We do! We love basketball!
SOME GUY: Great! Let's all meet tomorrow at the park at noon.
(The next day)
SOME GUY: Oh, two people never bothered to show up. Oh well, we can play 5-on-3 since I already made the teams. What could go wrong??
(The game starts)
SOME GUY: Hey, busy guy! Where are you going?
BUSY GUY: I'm gonna go talk on my phone while you all play. I'm kinda busy in real life.
SOME GUY: Fair enough. We'll just play 5-on-2.
(Half-time)
SOME GUY: Hey, noob. I noticed you weren't playing while I ran my ass off out there. I even passed you the ball and you just stood there.
NOOB: Yeah, I've never played basketball before so I thought I'd just watch for a while to learn how to play.
SOME GUY: Legit.

[degaston]

SOME GUY: Hey, who wants to play 5-on-5 basketball tomorrow?
A BUNCH OF PEOPLE: We do! We love basketball!
SOME GUY: Great! Let's all meet tomorrow at the park at noon.
(The next day)
SOME GUY: Oh, two people never bothered to show up. Oh well, we can play 5-on-3 since I already made the teams. What could go wrong??
(The game starts)
SOME GUY: Hey, busy guy! Where are you going?
BUSY GUY: I'm gonna go talk on my phone while you all play. I'm kinda busy in real life.
SOME GUY: Fair enough. We'll just play 5-on-2.
(Half-time)
SOME GUY: Hey, noob. I noticed you weren't playing while I ran my ass off out there. I even passed you the ball and you just stood there.
NOOB: Yeah, I've never played basketball before so I thought I'd just watch for a while to learn how to play.
SOME GUY: Legit.

What is this?
Did you try to kill Pixar?

[degaston]

Yes, I handed out the shanks. I gave then to people I thought were town. One was lost to Pixar. All 3 ended up being used to kill townies.

That puts you on the chopping block as well

Because... why?

Maybe I'm a poor judge of character, but that's not a criminal offense.

[degaston]

This is an easy vote. Pixar killed a townie. That deserves a lynch. Unless can convince me otherwise. Although I still think the players with the highest post count, the talkers, deserve another look before final vote.

He killed a townie that almost half the town wanted to lynch yesterday. You think that's worth a lynching?
Max was still voting for JMac at the end of the day. Should we lynch him too?

[joshzam]

SOME GUY: Hey, who wants to play 5-on-5 basketball tomorrow?
A BUNCH OF PEOPLE: We do! We love basketball!
SOME GUY: Great! Let's all meet tomorrow at the park at noon.
(The next day)
SOME GUY: Oh, two people never bothered to show up. Oh well, we can play 5-on-3 since I already made the teams. What could go wrong??
(The game starts)
SOME GUY: Hey, busy guy! Where are you going?
BUSY GUY: I'm gonna go talk on my phone while you all play. I'm kinda busy in real life.
SOME GUY: Fair enough. We'll just play 5-on-2.
(Half-time)
SOME GUY: Hey, noob. I noticed you weren't playing while I ran my ass off out there. I even passed you the ball and you just stood there.
NOOB: Yeah, I've never played basketball before so I thought I'd just watch for a while to learn how to play.
SOME GUY: Legit.

What is this?
Did you try to kill Pixar?

This is my frustration manifested in a creative writing assignment.

Yes, I tried to kill Pixar with a shank because I didn't believe anything he said. It was all too much. Ghost? Can't be night killed? Silences people who visit? Can send messages? It sounded like 5 different roles all lumped into one, and the description of the Ghost role on mafia.gg was absolutely different from what he was claiming. Plus he conveniently "didn't read" part of his role. And then the Mod messed up his abilities. That guy was an absolute liar in my book so I was gonna get rid of him. But my night kill failed and I ended up silenced with white hair because I guess I saw a Ghost. And since the actual role of Ghost is a known Town role, I'm reluctant to push a vote on him today. Maybe he really is Town and Raz invented some ridiculous made-up role that has never existed before because he thought it would be fun. I don't know. But I'm not gonna waste any more time thinking about Pix. When I got scared stiff, I apparently dropped my shank on the floor of Pix's cell, so he then had it, and then used it last night to kill JMac. If Pix's intentions were Town-oriented, I can't reeeeeally blame him since so many people were voting JMac, but I never saw any proof that JMac was scum and I never would have voted for him while other scummier options were out there, no matter how absent he was. And that guy was super absent. Like infuriatingly absent. But so were/are so many other people. It's really a shame.

[fusibaseball]

I knew DukeHazzard was 3rd Party. I knew it. Just look at his posts from Days 1, 2, and 3 from an inexperienced player's point of view with the assumption that Pixar's 3rd party.

I killed Pepe because every single thing he posted was contrarian and not going along with group logic.

These are the players who I am 100% voting with for Day 5:
1) Degaston -> Led the vote against a confirmed 3rd party player, and his role cannot be Mafia
2) Darin44 -> Actively follows group logic, his votes are timely, and he has a visitation role that has been corroborated and not refuted across multiple nights

These are the players who I have a strong inclination to be Town and would need overwhelming evidence to vote for Day 5:
3) Dunk90 -> Actively follows group logic, his votes are timely, and his role has been already mostly revealed and confirmed by I-andrei, another reputable player
4) I-Andrei -> Actively follows group logic, his votes are timely, and his role has been mostly revealed and is confirmed through Law's death Night 1 (i.e. his story makes sense)

These are players who I believed were Town prior to Day 5, but there must be at least 1 in this bunch lying through his teeth and I don't know who (unless Bax or Pepe was a Con Man and the Town role revealed is just Raz covering for the role):
5) pershy -> His posts make sense, his votes are timely, and his investigative role is useful though inconsistent (his story could be completely made up and who would know the difference)
6) Ragian -> His posts make sense, his votes are timely. I have no knowledge of this player's baseline night activities (excluding a shank kill) at all and we are at Day 5
7) joshzam -> This player is very believable and clearly intelligent, and I very much want to believe he's Town, but I have no concrete knowledge of his night activities and we are at Day 5. I must be the only one who's still very skeptical of this whole "leaving a shank by Pix's cell enough though I tried to kill him" thread. I had the option of either A) using my shank or B) passing it to another player. Why couldn't Josh have just passed it to Pix and they are 3rd players numbers 3 and 4 of the alliance?
8 ) Dukasaur -> Insufficient material in posts to get a sense of where he's at. Could be scum-buddy with Pershy and the whole brainwashing-narrative is nonsense.

I have been saying it for a long time now...this player is 100% 3rd party, and if we cannot come up with a reliable lynch on a Mafia player, it is my belief that the backup vote should be for him:
9) Pixar -> His posts don't make sense. Most of what he says is straight lies. For instance starting at the top of Day 5, how does he already have knowledge that Pepe was killed via shank and was not the regular Mafia kill for Night 5?

This player I do not have a good grasp on his allegiance:
10) Maxleod -> His posts for the most part do not make sense. How does he know he was targeted Night 3? Why was he dead-set on voting for JMac when there was clearly more evidence for DukeHazzard? What are his baseline night activities?

I propose we go around 1 by 1 and all just full reveal our roles and night activities. Most of the people at the top of my list have already given plenty of evidence and won't have much new info to share. We can line up everyone's stories with what's been shared thus far and see whose stories are bullish*t.

[Ragian]

Agreed. (Also, I liked your little play and thought that ckyrias⁩ deserved the role of busy irl guy in the phone). Though I do feel that more than one player is actively trying to play

Why is Max on about Dega slipping up? What's he up to now?

No mafia kill is good stuff! However, we're a bodyguard down (Pepe) from a shank, too. That's odd unless Fusi did the shanking. Otherwise, the numbers don't add up with three handed out. Let's hear it, Fusi.

Lol. FP'ed by Fusi.

[fusibaseball]

You know what? I'll go first since I have a feeling people will be bashful. Nothing to hide over here.

This is my role: Jack

This is what my role does, copied verbatim from mafia.gg and Raz: Each night, may visit a player and perform one of three actions

1) May protect them from a night kill
2) May investigate them and receive a report the following day detailing whether the player is sided with the Mafia
3) May kill them

Each action can only be used once

And this is what I've done each night:
Night 1 -> Killed Loose Cannon
Night 2 -> No action
Night 3 -> No action
Night 4 -> Killed Pepe with shank. Saved Josh with save ability because I wanted to hear from him post-silence. I believe I saved him from the Mafia kill given Raz's wording.
Night 5 -> I will be receiving a report from a player I find suspicious. So Mafia if you find that threatening, better kill me fast.

Great. Who's next?

[Ragian]

Thank you for your run-down of the players. I think Max was on about how he was visited N3, which is his reason for saying that he was the reason for no mafia kill. It has not been corroborated, but it's not opposed or debunked either.

Fusi, you're suggesting a mass claim, which is useful towards the end of the game. If it is to happen, though, we need to organise it. I'd suggest that we vote on the chronology in order for scummies not to sit it out and wait for all townies to claim and then fit theirs in. It needs to be a majority decision, however.

[fusibaseball]

That works. We can go from the bottom up, so Max and Pixar can share first, that way they can't just fit their stories in. Seems smart to me

[Ragian]

No, Fusi! I don't think you're at the top of anyone's scum list. Let's arrange this before we just plunge into it.

[Ragian]

Also, I feel like our posts don't lign up. I'm always a post behind you

[pershy]

I knew DukeHazzard was 3rd Party. I knew it. Just look at his posts from Days 1, 2, and 3 from an inexperienced player's point of view with the assumption that Pixar's 3rd party.

I killed Pepe because every single thing he posted was contrarian and not going along with group logic.

These are the players who I am 100% voting with for Day 5:
1) Degaston -> Led the vote against a confirmed 3rd party player, and his role cannot be Mafia
2) Darin44 -> Actively follows group logic, his votes are timely, and he has a visitation role that has been corroborated and not refuted across multiple nights

well I agree with a lot of your assesment but I think Degaston seems genuinely investigative so I don't agree with that.
Now we see that even though you were sure Pepe was scum - you were wrong about that as were a lot of people.