Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

[aage]

I dislike how Commander and Safari suddenly are in absolute agreement on not lynching Victor. I agree with them, but the way they posted several times in sequence, doing nothing really but nodding their heads.


But there's still bigger fish... I'm looking through the thread and I'm checking out some of Tailgunner's posts.

Bump.

vote the person with the most votes. Is that scummy?

This is pretty scummy, and hilarious. Although it doesn't really count, I'm sure, but it still illustrates your scumminess.

unvote vote victor

-Tails

unvote to avoid suspicion. Is that scummy?

Si Señor.

-Tails

We need one more vote for a claim from Victor. Anyone gonna do it or are we going to sit here with our thumbs up our collective asses?

Oh and a vote count would be nice.

I did my part. Although methinks:

Lol, I had to focus all my seriousness in that game. I'm ready to kick back and just screw around

he isn't really gonna give us anything.

-Tails

Ah, and the two quotes above were your part?

Yes I read too the wiki and Uncle's page had nothing about doc skills (except for tending animals). However he could possibly be the only in practice vig role. So I guess I'll unvote for now.

I've got to go to work now, but I'll try and dig some scum up/input more on this game later on tonight.

-Tails

Ah, yes, you're going to give input. Let's check it out:

Still waiting for "others"...
seriously, people, find that "post reply" button and abuse that keyboard.

btw, tailgunner, there's a mistake in your sig. If one joins the mafia it'd not be wise to "lynch some scum".

Yeah I would like to hear more from other people. Idk this game is crawling, but I don't want it to because I like the setup.

Thanks aaage. I fixed the sig. Does it pass muster now?

-Tails

More complaining about the lack of activity. So what are you doing anyway? :s

XD

Sorry, but I seriously lol'd.

Perhaps because you two are aligned? And it almost worked too?

Or perhaps I'm just being paranoid? And making no sense... and just being Herk

Grasping much? And too many smilies:

vote Commander

-Tails

Ah, of course, distracting the attention of a bandwagon towards the mayor through the misinterpretation of a joke vote. Very "inputty".

I'll shift my vote to vote tailgunner.

[Jace22]

confirm, I'll reread the thread and see if I find anything out of place

[Victor Sullivan]

It's a damn ballsy wifom sort of claim if that's what we're basing on lynching or not. On the other hand,with 8 people, it's only going to be a couple of days before it becomes a really powerful role. If he targets scum, they're dead, and the odds that he targets one of say 2-3 remaining townies correctly would be much higher than say 4-5. I hesitate to lynch right away considering the mechanics.

Not necessarily, IMO. If the player is good, he could be used as a vig and could be highly useful as long as he doesn't go on a killing spree - he could be the only killing role the town has. However, the part where you've pointed out that CPR doctor shouldn't have been around back then is a very good point. Victor, any responses to this?

Commander, I already did:

My character's name is just "Uncle", I guess. I didn't really get a name... Never played Red Dead before, so I'm not familiar with the characters.

Basically, I think my guy is clumsy or incapable or something, because he basically said that "if someone's in need of your small knowledge of medicine, you can help them, but if they were okay in the first place, you'll probably screw up and kill them". Obviously those aren't the exact words from the PM (as that would be cheating), but I think my paraphrase covered it.

-Uncle Sully

My character, "Uncle", doesn't literally have those CPR paddles or whatever you want to call them. He's just a clumsy oaf, from what I can tell.

-Professor Oaf

[edocsil]

I dislike how Commander and Safari suddenly are in absolute agreement on not lynching Victor. I agree with them, but the way they posted several times in sequence, doing nothing really but nodding their heads.


But there's still bigger fish... I'm looking through the thread and I'm checking out some of Tailgunner's posts.

~Snip~

I'll shift my vote to vote tailgunner.

Were all those in chronological order or were they flipped around a bit? Would like to hear from TG.

[aage]

I dislike how Commander and Safari suddenly are in absolute agreement on not lynching Victor. I agree with them, but the way they posted several times in sequence, doing nothing really but nodding their heads.


But there's still bigger fish... I'm looking through the thread and I'm checking out some of Tailgunner's posts.

~Snip~

I'll shift my vote to vote tailgunner.

Were all those in chronological order or were they flipped around a bit? Would like to hear from TG.

Chronological order, exactly as I found them in the thread. The last one is near the bottom of page 7.

[Jace22]

oh I forgot to unvote stefunny's vote

[edocsil]

I dislike how Commander and Safari suddenly are in absolute agreement on not lynching Victor. I agree with them, but the way they posted several times in sequence, doing nothing really but nodding their heads.


But there's still bigger fish... I'm looking through the thread and I'm checking out some of Tailgunner's posts.

~Snip~

I'll shift my vote to vote tailgunner.

Were all those in chronological order or were they flipped around a bit? Would like to hear from TG.

Chronological order, exactly as I found them in the thread. The last one is near the bottom of page 7.

Nothing damning, but makes him a better candidate then victor IMO. Vote TG

[Commander9]

As I've pointed out before, TG does seem to be scummaring. Basically, it does look it's between Victor/Tails at the moment - both haven't contributed anything, but Victor did claim and ,IMO, rather convincingly (although I'm using recruitment thread a lot when considering his claim), so I'm also leaning towards tails.

However, again, we've still got a bit more than a day, so plenty of time to hear it from him.

[aage]

As I've pointed out before, TG does seem to be scummaring. Basically, it does look it's between Victor/Tails at the moment - both haven't contributed anything, but Victor did claim and ,IMO, rather convincingly (although I'm using recruitment thread a lot when considering his claim), so I'm also leaning towards tails.

However, again, we've still got a bit more than a day, so plenty of time to hear it from him.

Yes, you may want to watch out with your double vote but I honestly don't think a bit of pressure is out of place.

Either way, yes, let's hear him...

[Commander9]

Yes, you may want to watch out with your double vote but I honestly don't think a bit of pressure is out of place.

Either way, yes, let's hear him...

Don't worry - not planning to abuse any of my powers

Yeah, that's pretty much what I've been suggested.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

So your case against me is that I don't contribute enough? I'm sorry but not much has happened in this game for me to jump on anything. I like to gather evidence before I just throw out accusations. None of you have really posted anything of much import, with the exception of Sully acting like a tard. That's why this game hasn't moved quickly. The only conversation thus far has been, "keep Vic as a vig or lynch him because he's endangering town with his behavior?" If you've got something else against me, let me know.

-Tails

[aage]

So your case against me is that I don't contribute enough? I'm sorry but not much has happened in this game for me to jump on anything. I like to gather evidence before I just throw out accusations. None of you have really posted anything of much import, with the exception of Sully acting like a tard. That's why this game hasn't moved quickly. The only conversation thus far has been, "keep Vic as a vig or lynch him because he's endangering town with his behavior?" If you've got something else against me, let me know.

-Tails

It's not like you try. You just complain over the deadness of the thread and that's it.

[safariguy5]

You bring up a good topic, what's your view on Victor? That's a legitimate question. You're just reinforcing the accusation of scumarining.

unvote vote Tails

[edocsil]

So your case against me is that I don't contribute enough? I'm sorry but not much has happened in this game for me to jump on anything. I like to gather evidence before I just throw out accusations. None of you have really posted anything of much import, with the exception of Sully acting like a tard. That's why this game hasn't moved quickly. The only conversation thus far has been, "keep Vic as a vig or lynch him because he's endangering town with his behavior?" If you've got something else against me, let me know.

-Tails

Yes, it is terrible but we are running out of time, so I would suggest a claim. If it is a real important claim our only option will be victor. As it is if the day ends you will be lynched, so hopefully you can give us some information to save yourself.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I think that makes me L-2, right? With Commander that's a hammer if he votes, so...

I'm Nigel West Dickens, Town Politician. It is probably vital that I stay alive. If Commander is scum, then I can negate his double vote.

It's not like you try. You just complain over the deadness of the thread and that's it.

Sorry, I can't spin straw into gold. I'm just not that good. Would if I could.

-Tails

[Commander9]

I think that makes me L-2, right? With Commander that's a hammer if he votes, so...

I'm Nigel West Dickens, Town Politician. It is probably vital that I stay alive. If Commander is scum, then I can negate his double vote.

It's not like you try. You just complain over the deadness of the thread and that's it.

Sorry, I can't spin straw into gold. I'm just not that good. Would if I could.

-Tails

According to the wiki of Red Dead Redemption, he's no politician, he's a salesman - if anything, he's role would be of doctor's due to him making the elixirs. Frankly, I don't buy this at all, but won't hammer to see what others think.

[safariguy5]

He's a con man, which may make him a politician.

[edocsil]

He's a con man, which may make him a politician.

My thoughts exactly....

I wonder if we could test this. How exactly does your vote stopping powers work? how are they targeted/activated.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I target a player at night and "buy" their vote. They lose their vote, I get 2 for the next day. I guess Commander would lose his mayor status tomorrow, so really my role only blocks someone if they are elected to mayor. But if I target mafia, I can prevent them from causing any trouble for lynches.

-Tails

[aage]

I target a player at night and "buy" their vote. They lose their vote, I get 2 for the next day. I guess Commander would lose his mayor status tomorrow, so really my role only blocks someone if they are elected to mayor. But if I target mafia, I can prevent them from causing any trouble for lynches.

-Tails

So you steal one vote? And if you targeted someone who becomes the mayor, do you get that extra vote as well? (making it 3 votes you're casting)
Can you put your votes on multiple people?
And what do you mean with the last line?

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I steal one vote. I can target one person a night. I'm not sure about the mayor one, but that sounds logical, at least that's what I figured.

I don't know about the multiple people. I would assume that my vote would count for 2, just like Commander for today. (Haha I wonder if Saf is a fan of Newton's Third Law )

I meant that I can hobble the mafia, if I correctly target them. With this many players, I'm estimating 2 scum. Maybe one SK. That leaves 5-6 town. I can prevent any unnecessary or scummy hammers.

-Tails

[edocsil]

Never heard of a scum politician, so unvote.

[Jace22]

No he would not gain the mayor vote as that is something we change everyday

[naxus]

Vote Count (lynch 1)
Com9(1)-Tails
Victor(1)-Haggis
Tails(2)-aage, safariguy

8 alive 5 to lynch. Deadline is still set

[Victor Sullivan]

Hmm... Interesting about Tails' claim, though I still don't fully understand it after reading (and rereading) it, but whatever, doesn't seem like scum to me by any means. Damn good fake claim if he is, though lol. So, what now? And Tails, are you gonna take your vote off of Commander? I'd rather not him be inadvertently lynched when the deadline comes. At the risk of being completely scrutinized, I'm going to unvote vote Edoc'sil. He's been playing cleverly so far, and I don't like the way he's been leading things, for the most part.

-Uncle Sully