-----------------------------------------

[firth4eva]

unvote vote fircoal

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Dwight you are a paranoid or insane cop. Lynch me if you want, but you are not a "good cop". In regards to announcing you're a cop this early, it is quite dumb to do as we already lost the doc and I KNOW you're either a paranoid or insane cop.

I also have some reason to believe that Fircoal is innocent, but I also believe that there are multiple cops in the game and at least one of them will be paranoid or insane(Dwight). It is also possible one could be naive.

[pancakemix]

Dwight, did you not pay attention in Pokemon mafia AT ALL!? There was something like 30 pages added to Day 2 with me arguing with spin about him being insane and guess what? They lynched me and I was town!

[ga7]

Disregarding the investigations, what I just read from Day 1 makes LSU AND Fircoal look so scummy it's laughable. I'll dig up their posts in a moment.
Vote LSU

[pancakemix]

*cough cough* I have some reasons to believe dwight is NOT a cop.*cough cough* Fircoal is mafia.

If Fircoal is mafia why aren't you voting him?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Since it looks like I'll be lynched b/c of a paranoid or insane cop please take into account the ones that vote me so that the true cop can find out which of those are scum as they will be the ones most likely to vote for me courtesy of a paranoid cop as there are mutliple cops in this game with varying sanities and paranoia factors.

FOS GA for listenign to a paranoid or insane cop or else a scum pretendign to be a cop.
FOS Dwight as he is a paranoid or insane cop or else scum trying to save jake.

[Chad22342]

*cough cough* I have some reasons to believe dwight is NOT a cop.*cough cough* Fircoal is mafia.

If Fircoal is mafia why aren't you voting him?

That wasn't my point my point was that I doubted the sane ness of dwight now i will vote Fircoal

[pancakemix]

*cough cough* I have some reasons to believe dwight is NOT a cop.*cough cough* Fircoal is mafia.

If Fircoal is mafia why aren't you voting him?

That wasn't my point my point was that I doubted the sane ness of dwight now i will vote Fircoal

But if you knew he was mafia, why didn't you vote him? I think we should lynch you first, then if you come up scum, lynch Fircoal.

[Chad22342]

*cough cough* I have some reasons to believe dwight is NOT a cop.*cough cough* Fircoal is mafia.

If Fircoal is mafia why aren't you voting him?

That wasn't my point my point was that I doubted the sane ness of dwight now i will vote Fircoal

But if you knew he was mafia, why didn't you vote him? I think we should lynch you first, then if you come up scum, lynch Fircoal.

I'm not so sure that would make any sense seeing that I appear to be the only cop here making sense(from what i've read).

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Actually pancake I'm thinking Fircoal might be the best target right now as I believe Chad hinted that he was told he was cop and I also was. We got differing results on Fircoal so it would reveal to us which of us is the sane cop and hopefully the backup doc will protect the one of us that is sane. Unvote Vote Fircoal

[pancakemix]

*cough cough* I have some reasons to believe dwight is NOT a cop.*cough cough* Fircoal is mafia.

If Fircoal is mafia why aren't you voting him?

That wasn't my point my point was that I doubted the sane ness of dwight now i will vote Fircoal

But if you knew he was mafia, why didn't you vote him? I think we should lynch you first, then if you come up scum, lynch Fircoal.

I'm not so sure that would make any sense seeing that I appear to be the only cop here making sense(from what i've read).

But isn't it just as likely that you're not sane either?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Actually pancake I'm thinking Fircoal might be the best target right now as I believe Chad hinted that he was told he was cop and I also was. We got differing results on Fircoal so it would reveal to us which of us is the sane cop and hopefully the backup doc will protect the one of us that is sane. Unvote Vote Fircoal

Since I fastposted Pancake.

[Chad22342]

But isn't it just as likely that you're not sane either?

It is but why should we lynch me if I am. If I'm correct an insane cop gets the opposite results from everyone so if someone comes up town then they will end up mafia yes. Instead of killing your own cops why not let them do their job for a bit until they get killed by the mafia?

[0ojakeo0]

i think that right now chad looks the sanest sounvote vote fircoal

[LSU Tiger Josh]

think that right now chad looks the sanest

Probably because he doesn't believe you're scum like I do although the only evidence I have at this point is your actions that you did yesterday which made me vote for you to begin with.

[pancakemix]

Actually pancake I'm thinking Fircoal might be the best target right now as I believe Chad hinted that he was told he was cop and I also was. We got differing results on Fircoal so it would reveal to us which of us is the sane cop and hopefully the backup doc will protect the one of us that is sane. Unvote Vote Fircoal

Since I fastposted Pancake.

No, I saw that, but he may NOT be a cop, but in fact a lyncher trying to waltz his way to victory or scum trying to lynch his scummate to win our trust. Keep in mind LSU, you've been investigated and come up scum. You're not exactly clear.

[ga7]

Ok here's my day1 review:

Random vote 0ojakeo0

Unvote Vote Chad for the obvious unrandom vote of joining a bandwagon.

Here it was the first post of Chad putting a 2nd vote on Jake. LSU jumped at his throat and felt the need to unvote Chad and vote again, for emphasis I assume.

Unvote Vote Gimpy since deadline si coming up.

Spin had just posted the deadline was in one day, yet he bandwagons (I must say the whole thing on Gimpy didn't hold much water in my eyes)

STOP HAMMER TIME!

Unvote
Vote: Gimpy

Just to hammer.

(At that point there was 22 hours left from the deadline)
Now, why the hell would you hammer someone so quickly when you're in a non-vanilla game, without letting him have the chance to defend himself?
If you're scum, that's why.

Vote Jake. On Day 1 he had he had 3 posts. 1st a random vote on Gimpy that he never explained why he was voting on other then it being random, 2nd post a random comment about bbq, and his 3rd post was simply "lol". No posts of substance there and it should be noted that one of the two deaths that occured on night 1 came from a person who voted for Jake on the final go round.

There is so many wrong things with this post.
Jake's first post was on the first page, did you ever see a real reason for a vote there?
From the first day postcount he is far from being the only one having barely posted and nothing relevant. You could find more suspicious when non-noob players do that, but I suppose it's easier to start a bandwagon on a noob neh?
On the last part, at the end of the day Jake had 2 votes on him. I don't believe he would have felt so threatened as to kill one of his random accusers under pressure.

Now, Dwight might be a paranoid cop, a real one, or a scum, I don't know. But I'm pretty sure we can rule out the possibility he's insane.
I think Fircoal is scum, but I'm tired and it's a weaker case

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Yea but i also know that I am cop and that tells me that Dwight is either paranoid or else insane cop. I know I investigated Fircoal last night b/c of his hammer granted the deadline was a few hours away so when I got innocent on him I was goign to just let it pass and try for another investigation or two to try to figure out my sanity instead of painting a target on my back right away by claiming cop. I figure we have at least 1 paranoid cop, 1 naive cop, and 1 sane cop although there could also be an insane cop mixed in. If it's only the first 3 then Chad would be right since all my investigations would turn up as innocent.

[spinwizard]

Vote count- 6 to lynch
LSU Tiger Josh----dwightschrute, ga7----2
Fircoal----firth4eva, Chad22342, LSU Tiger Josh, 0ojakeo0----4

[pancakemix]

Yea but i also know that I am cop and that tells me that Dwight is either paranoid or else insane cop. I know I investigated Fircoal last night b/c of his hammer granted the deadline was a few hours away so when I got innocent on him I was goign to just let it pass and try for another investigation or two to try to figure out my sanity instead of painting a target on my back right away by claiming cop. I figure we have at least 1 paranoid cop, 1 naive cop, and 1 sane cop although there could also be an insane cop mixed in. If it's only the first 3 then Chad would be right since all my investigations would turn up as innocent.

Seems like we have quite a few investigative roles in this. Your sanities, however cannot be determined by one investigation. Since you both investigated Fircoal and got different results, I'll Vote Fircoal

Fircoal, care to claim?

[0ojakeo0]

if u investigate some1 does it come out cop, or insane,naive etc cop?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Simple he voted the same person as the one in front of him had just done which got my 2nd vote.

In regards to Gimpy I was heading out to celebrate the 4th of July so i cast my vote at that time.

I stand by my thoughts that Jake is scum and will try to investigate him tonight although I have a feeling that I may be naive cop and get innocent on everyone. If Jake turns out scum then that leaves GA and Dwight as my 2 biggest suspicious players in the game.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

no Jake usually a cop investigation will only state Scum, neutral, or protown unless the mod decides otherwise. Your cop role in the other game is one of the "otherwise" situations as I've never gotten a cop role that told me the name of the player I was investigating along with their innocence or guilt.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

You figure out your sanity or lack of it via death of someone you investigated.

[ga7]

I still feel it's a mistake to lynch Fircoal first, but well we'll see what he has to say. He and LSU seemed to back each other quite often, before LSU felt the heat and changed his vote while claiming cop.

I don't know about Jake, but I do think you were trying to pick on him for a lynch

Dwight, regardless of his sanity, seems pretty clear to me. If he was scum he would never have claimed cop first. Then all of a sudden 2 more cops appeared, last one being, again, LSU.

Of course it is possible we have so many cops, but after only one night of investigations I'd rather rely on the posts of the claimed cops than on this possibility.