Moderator: Community Team
LOL Awesomespiesr wrote:Wow, so captainwalrus was an insane cop, but when he investigated the godfather his backwards result turned out to actually be true.

I had actualy figured that out, and was going to say it once the day started.spiesr wrote:Wow, so captainwalrus was an insane cop, but when he investigated the godfather his backwards result turned out to actually be true.
It was, but don't forget we have a week vacation from coltoncowboyz wrote:LOL Awesomespiesr wrote:Wow, so captainwalrus was an insane cop, but when he investigated the godfather his backwards result turned out to actually be true.
So we killed Mafia Godfather, lost an insane cop (worthless), and got LSU (watcher) back. Great night!
Well, since he had deduced his sanity he was actually very far from useless.cowboyz wrote:lost an insane cop (worthless)
So are you saying that you took no action on night 0?LSU Tiger Josh wrote:on night 0 when I never did anything.
gregwolf121 wrote:well idk about a dead line
what i want to know cowboyz is why do you think an insane cop is worthless, captainwalrus knew he was insane so he could tell if they were scum if he got an innocent answer.
I think this was more of a slip up of his logic than any sort of scummyness though...LSU Tiger Josh wrote:I definitely agree with Greg. FOS at Cowboyzgregwolf121 wrote:well idk about a dead line
what i want to know cowboyz is why do you think an insane cop is worthless, captainwalrus knew he was insane so he could tell if they were scum if he got an innocent answer.
If some cop thinks everyone he investigates is mafia, then that sounds pretty worthless to me. We lost an insane cop and killed a mafia doing it. We still have a normal cop around. All in all it was a good night. How saying that is scummy is beyond me.gregwolf121 wrote:well idk about a dead line
what i want to know cowboyz is why do you think an insane cop is worthless, captainwalrus knew he was insane so he could tell if they were scum if he got an innocent answer.

Right, an insane cop could investigate himself on night 1 and find that if he is guilty, his sanity is either insane or paranoid.gregwolf121 wrote:i could be wrong but an insane cop gets guilty for town and innocence for mafia, a paranoid cop gets guilty for everyone.

Do any cops actually do this though? Most people would just assume they're sane and play accordingly.safariguy5 wrote:Right, an insane cop could investigate himself on night 1 and find that if he is guilty, his sanity is either insane or paranoid.gregwolf121 wrote:i could be wrong but an insane cop gets guilty for town and innocence for mafia, a paranoid cop gets guilty for everyone.
Maybe not. We never know how this game is set up. On my old forum, we would occasionally set up games with no investigative roles so that the town had to work only with scum-tells. They were difficult, but extremely rewarding when you won.cowboyz wrote:We still have a normal cop around.
I don't know if cowboyz statement could really be a scum-tell. Although it is strange that he would say it when the insane cop was extremely helpful yesterday. I'll watch him closely, but I think it was more a lapse of thought than a scummy action.spiesr wrote:I think this was more of a slip up of his logic than any sort of scummyness though...LSU Tiger Josh wrote:I definitely agree with Greg. FOS at Cowboyzgregwolf121 wrote:well idk about a dead line
what i want to know cowboyz is why do you think an insane cop is worthless, captainwalrus knew he was insane so he could tell if they were scum if he got an innocent answer.
An insane cop does not always get scum, that is a paranoid cop. An insane cop gets the wrong opposite result every time.cowboyz wrote:If some cop thinks everyone he investigates is mafia, then that sounds pretty worthless to me.
This isn't necessarily true we might not have an insane cop and a sane cop. Especially since an insane isn't completely useless and we have a watcher then I doubt we have a sane cop.cowboyz wrote:We still have a normal cop around.
Well, he had investigated pmc who had the ability of appearing innocent under investigations and got a guilty result. After pmc was lynched he realized he was either insane or paranoid. At that point he investigates someone else. If he gets innocent then he knows that he is insane. Otherwise he continues to just tell the town everyone he gets a guilty for and we just keep that info until one of them dies, cw gets an innocent result, or cw dies. Then we know his sanity and the results of all his investigations.cowboyz wrote:Also, how can an insane cop deduce his sanity?
No since insane cops would always get opposite of what they would've normally received as their real role.Crazyirishman wrote:I thought when you investigated the mafia godfather you get town, so when his insaneness reverses that he would get scum which what he reported. Wouldn't that make his deduction just luck?