Simpsons Mafia Game OVER!!! SK WINS!!!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

good job wicked until you were killed. I knew you were the cop early on and huck you really should stop commenting on about how witty or smart you are as you are showing yourself to be anything but that in this game.

[wiggybowler]

Guys can we get a list of who wicked cleared before she died. Who was she suspicious of then dropped that suspicion the next day.

Freezie.....and who else. this will narrow down who we need to look at.

[wiggybowler]

I read back over the last 20 pages and the scummiest thing person I saw was Skoffin. He has not posted much the entire game probably less then 10 total and he constantly has tried to discredit wicked so the doc would not protect her. He used such words as "even with you being who you say you are, does that make you any more important than us?" Obviously it does she was a power role. So if you ask me there is your mafia.

Vote--Skoffin

[I GOT SERVED]

Interesting point you have with skoffin. I am also worried about spin, because it seems like he overreacted a bit in his reply. With this being said:

Vote: Skoffin

[Puff]

Vote spinwizard

Yesterday you were trying to make wicked spell out her role. She left major hints (after I got off) and you still kept pushing and now she's dead.

I know people are going to vote me because of my past arguments with wicked. I will say this as my one and only defense. I am Bart Simpson so there is no point to lynching me as I thought wicked was mafia from what I saw and there is no more to it than that. If you don't believe me then the only thing that will happen is that the town will loose a voter.

ok so you are voteing me why, i said i was suspitious of wicked yesterday but that does not mean i killed her, quite the oposite, if i was mafia don't u think that i have played enough mafia to know that killing her would make me look very scummy!!!

Also you were the one that was pushing for a role claim form wicked not me, because of this FoS-Puff

give me a minute and I'll get back to you

[Puff]

This spin is what I am talking about.

Because we have a very smart doc who recognizes his main role in this thing is to protect me. 'Nuff said. The smarter players have hopefully all figured it out already, so I'm not going to spell it out for the rest.

just bringing up points for everyone to see

I voted wicked a page or two before with my suspicions and left for most of the day. I was not present for this argument but after I saw it I am am pretty sure that was a scum slip up.

So don't start changing who said what.

[wiggybowler]

This spin is what I am talking about.

Because we have a very smart doc who recognizes his main role in this thing is to protect me. 'Nuff said. The smarter players have hopefully all figured it out already, so I'm not going to spell it out for the rest.

just bringing up points for everyone to see

I voted wicked a page or two before with my suspicions and left for most of the day. I was not present for this argument but after I saw it I am am pretty sure that was a scum slip up.

So don't start changing who said what.

Are you trying to cover for Skoffin or did I completely misunderstand that. Could you explain?

[Talapus]

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?!? We lost Wicked overnight...what the hell? The one power role left besides the doc and now she's gone! Edna K. was going to die anyway...but seriously, this is bad. HBH why in the
world did you switch roles with Wicked last night! It's the only explanation to her death beacause she's been droping major hints as to her identity for the last few days. The doc would have to have been blind not to realize he needed to save her each night. SO, THAT MEANS YOU SWITCHED ROLES...WHY? You're pro-town, remember??? Act like it!

Also, where was the janitor in all this...

[wiggybowler]

Maybe Gimpy/ Waylon Smithers had the ability to clean up after anyone Mr. Burns voted killed. He does clean up after Mr. Burns a lot. Not sure but just an idea.

[Talapus]

Guys can we get a list of who wicked cleared before she died. Who was she suspicious of then dropped that suspicion the next day.

Freezie.....and who else. this will narrow down who we need to look at.

Right now this is the best idea and lead we have...I'm going back through the whole thread, there has to be something there...and HBH...STOP CHANGING ROLES before you get the doc killed. If that happens, we're really screwed.

[wiggybowler]

Right now this is the best idea and lead we have...I'm going back through the whole thread, there has to be something there...and HBH...STOP CHANGING ROLES before you get the doc killed. If that happens, we're really screwed.

I think our best lead is Skoffin right now.

[Talapus]

Right now this is the best idea and lead we have...I'm going back through the whole thread, there has to be something there...and HBH...STOP CHANGING ROLES before you get the doc killed. If that happens, we're really screwed.

I think our best lead is Skoffin right now.

I agree with this for right now...I also kinda like the whole idea of Smythers being the cleaner...it makes a lot of sense. I guess we won't know for sure though until the next day or so.

[Talapus]

Vote - - - Skoffin until a better lead comes along, but you look kinda scummy right now. However, I'm listening if you have evidence to clear you.

[wiggybowler]

Has anyone completely followed gimpy around this game, votes/accusations. Burns could have to wait for Smithers to do things for him.

[Skoffin]

I read back over the last 20 pages and the scummiest thing person I saw was Skoffin. He has not posted much the entire game probably less then 10 total and he constantly has tried to discredit wicked so the doc would not protect her. He used such words as "even with you being who you say you are, does that make you any more important than us?" Obviously it does she was a power role. So if you ask me there is your mafia.

Vote--Skoffin

I am not the only person that has been suspicious of wicked, and most of all I was trying to get people to form their own opinions and to stop agreeing with whatever one person said and leave it at that. Which is what you're all doing now. And at the time I did not know she was a powerrole so you can hardly use that against me. Claiming my innocence probably won't stop you from lynching me, but if you choose to look through my previous posts you will see the name of my role.

Also, it's she.

[Skoffin]

Hmm I've just looked over, and that quote of wiggy's that's supposed to be mine is not even my quote. It was Hounds. Not to mention Wiggy also jumped on me earlier claiming I tried to push for a no lynch when I did no such thing.

Wiggy, get your facts straight please.

[Talapus]

Hmm I've just looked over, and that quote of wiggy's that's supposed to be mine is not even my quote. It was Hounds. Not to mention Wiggy also jumped on me earlier claiming I tried to push for a no lynch when I did no such thing.

Wiggy, get your facts straight please.

This is true...here is the quote:

So, why is the doc protecting wicked again ? Even if she who she claimed, does that mean she's more important than anyone else ?

HOWEVER...Skoffin you claim you never tryed to push a no lynch, which you didn't, but you certainly didn't help us out either:

I've finally finished read through 30 pages of this that I missed. <_<

I'm not going to hop the bangwagon and vote Greece because the reasoning for it is absurd. "now Greece is worried that that he'll come back and expose his side - scum." If LSU had been scum he couldn't come back as an opposing side, because he'd know exactly who to point at. Honestly it makes no sense to me. Needs a better excuse then that to decide to lynch someone.

So you would rather have no lynch. That's scummy.

Where did I say not to lynch at all? I said don't jump on someone for the worst excuse out there that doesn't even make sense. Are you just going to say 'that's scummy' over the slightest thing?

In fact, according to your own quotes...you never even voted. Any vote would have helped us out at that point, but the fact that you are trying to deflect Wiggy's arguements against you so much without helping the rest of our town out, seems really scummy. Wiggy may have had some of the facts incorrect, but you definately are trying to hide something. My vote stands!

[Talapus]

Vote - - - Skoffin until a better lead comes along, but you look kinda scummy right now. However, I'm listening if you have evidence to clear you.

What I said earlier is accurate still. You give me a GOOD reason not to vote for you, and I'll change it. But I just went over the last 50 pages...and I couldn't find it. Prove me wrong.....

[Skoffin]

So by not voting for a very stupid reason I'm hurting the town? I was going to vote when I got back online, but I ended up missing the deadline. But if I had gotten back I probably would of voted wicked or wiggy at the time if you're wondering.

And as I said I mentioned the name of my role, but just because you go back 50 pages and don't find it doesn't mean it's not there. Also, you *could* of just gone through my own posts since there's a lot less of them.

This is the quote I was referring to, but it's up to you whether you want to believe me or not.

Hey atleast you didn't say you're Ned Flanders though, otherwise everyone would of jumped on you instantly just because... well, it's Flanders.

[Talapus]

So by not voting for a very stupid reason I'm hurting the town? I was going to vote when I got back online, but I ended up missing the deadline. But if I had gotten back I probably would of voted wicked or wiggy at the time if you're wondering.

And as I said I mentioned the name of my role, but just because you go back 50 pages and don't find it doesn't mean it's not there. Also, you *could* of just gone through my own posts since there's a lot less of them.

This is the quote I was referring to, but it's up to you whether you want to believe me or not.

Hey atleast you didn't say you're Ned Flanders though, otherwise everyone would of jumped on you instantly just because... well, it's Flanders.

First off, I could care less what reason you did or didn't choose to vote for. The point of the matter is, you criticised the rest of us for voting for a reason(although you didn't agree with it) and then didn't post any other reason for any other player. If you don't like the reasoning out there, FINE...but give us something. Don't just tell us all that we're making a mistake and then not explain who would have been a better choice. That's how you hurt the town.

Secondly, I'm not just going to reread YOUR posts....geez, talk about skiming. How do you expect to find any clues in a game if I just read one persons posts?!?

Third, that really isn't a roll claim....but that's fine because roll claims haven't gone well for most folks yet(i.e. Wicked---thanks again HBH ).

But if this was your arguement, then my vote stays. You proved nothing and then advised me to go back and just read your posts...If you want to skim or have the rest of us skim, that's just poor playing. You are scum in my mind...

[Skoffin]

Maybe I haven't been clear, but you've missed what I've been trying to say. And I had said it was a stupid reason, then I also put my suspicions on Wiggy. Also I stated that if you went back through my own posts you would see the name of my person, that is why I suggested you do so. Well it doesn't matter now, I know I'm getting lynched but I have other things I can do, it will have more impact on you lot then myself.

~Cheerio.

[Talapus]

Maybe I haven't been clear, but you've missed what I've been trying to say. And I had said it was a stupid reason, then I also put my suspicions on Wiggy. Also I stated that if you went back through my own posts you would see the name of my person, that is why I suggested you do so. Well it doesn't matter now, I know I'm getting lynched but I have other things I can do, it will have more impact on you lot then myself.

~Cheerio.

Ummm....supposedly you're Ned Flanders....what in the world kind of power role could you possibly have?!? Because unless you're the doc(which I find EXTREMELY unlikely) your death shouldn't have any impact on us. Although...instead of mafia you could be the SK....but you can't claim bomb either because we've already had one....SCUM!!!!!!

[Skoffin]

pff, I'm not claiming a power role. Flanders is just a regular townie. Every townie you lose brings the mafia one step closer to victory, and at the moment it doesn't seem like you have any clue as to who the mafia are. So this will go in their favour. And you know, that equals bad.

[The1exile]

Also, where was the janitor in all this...

My guess, HBH switched the mafia's target with the serial killers target.

Thus whoever the mafia were targeting got the doc protection, but the cop didn't and got the SK targeting them instead.

HBH really needs to tell us who he switched.

[The1exile]

on an OOC note, I'm glad the game is still alive on day 6. usually it would have petered out by now.