Conquer Club

spiesr wrote:

Rainbow Eater wrote:BFSPP? really? where did that come from

He pulled it out of his ass of course...

It's an obscure little term.

spiesr wrote:

vodean wrote:How many scum are there total? notice the use of the GENERIC WORD suggesting nothing. It refers to any sort of scum, just like townie refers to any sort of townie. Im guessing at least two: one for each faction. caution, always caution. 6? 7?

Well, if you want to speculate I would say that since if the one faction is eliminated the game end then that group probably has more then one, or the other group has memebers to protect it. The total amount I would say is likely from 3 to 6.

that makes sense.

so once again we have nothing to go on besides colton freaking out, which since ive never played him before, seems slightly scummy to me.Anyone got a good argument on who to go after?

Well, 3-6 is a high number, thats actually quite frightening. I hope the good(s) are powerfull too, to balance that. On the other hand, with that many scums we are more likely to find one. So, I'd rather lynch colton than noone. Is freaking out won't help him in my book.

Ask anyone who has played with me before I do this everytime....and evertime I am town.

This BW is/was scum engineered and ichguy and/or naxus is scum going after me for an OMGUS/BFSPP vote

colton24 wrote:Ask anyone who has played with me before I do this everytime....and evertime I am town.

This BW is/was scum engineered and ichguy and/or naxus is scum going after me for an OMGUS/BFSPP vote

ok Colton claiming to be town everytime u play just makes me suspect u more.and while u might freak out everytime u shouldn't.even if u do freak out everytime, everytime it's still suspicious(spelled wrong?).

colton24 wrote:This BW is/was scum engineered and ichguy and/or naxus is scum going after me for an OMGUS/BFSPP vote

Do you any evidence of why they would be scum, other than the fact that they voted for you?

spiesr wrote:

colton24 wrote:This BW is/was scum engineered and ichguy and/or naxus is scum going after me for an OMGUS/BFSPP vote

Do you any evidence of why they would be scum, other than the fact that they voted for you?

The reasons were OMGUS and it happened quickly

spiesr wrote:

colton24 wrote:This BW is/was scum engineered and ichguy and/or naxus is scum going after me for an OMGUS/BFSPP vote

Do you any evidence of why they would be scum, other than the fact that they voted for you?

there is spell check, and no, there isnt really much evidence, other than they voted for him first. I think we should lynch the scummyish person rather than the peson voting for the scummyish person, and there are two of them , so that would split our votes.

i havent played with colton that much so what do you guys think is he scumy enough to lynch

He is the most scummiest of us all. At some point we have to decide.. and before the Duality Bandwagon happend, there were 5 People voting for Colton, so there are either 5 Scums, or the "everyone who votes for colton is scum" is wrong.

lhcguy wrote:He is the most scummiest of us all. At some point we have to decide.. and before the Duality Bandwagon happend, there were 5 People voting for Colton, so there are either 5 Scums, or the "everyone who votes for colton is scum" is wrong.

What he's saying is that a couple townies voted for him, and all the scum bandwagonned onto that to try and get him lynched. That is not an unusual claim. What I'm more interested in is this:

wercool wrote:i havent played with colton that much so what do you guys think is he scumy enough to lynch

As I recall you've played in at least 2-3 games with Colton in it. That's definitely enough time in my opinion to decide for yourself. Sounds to me like you're trying to stir up the bandwagon on Colton.

vote wercool

FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

vodean wrote:FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

And the evidence against me is:

Either none

or

1. I told people it was a scum BW.

FOS vodean as it wasn't random and there is no evidence for me

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

And the evidence against me is:

Either none

or

1. I told people it was a scum BW.

FOS vodean as it wasn't random and there is no evidence for me

it was random. an innocent question. seems like he doesnt have all that much experience with you, and he asked an innocent question. Also, you have been defensive from the start.

vodean wrote:

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

And the evidence against me is:

Either none

or

1. I told people it was a scum BW.

FOS vodean as it wasn't random and there is no evidence for me

it was random. an innocent question. seems like he doesnt have all that much experience with you, and he asked an innocent question. Also, you have been defensive from the start.

He's been in 2 or 3 games with me. That is total BS from him. Just trying to defend your scum pardner eh?

colton24 wrote:And the evidence against me is:
Either none
or
1. I told people it was a scum BW.

Not exactly, the case against you is more or less based on your spasmodic and reckless behavior to this point in the game. You have been acting in a suspect manner where you have been overly defensive about your actions. You have jumped all over those who voted for you due to your behavior and accused them of being scum, basically for daring to vote for you. Your actions in this have warranted you receiving several day one votes. The fact the you barely acknowledge that your actions could be construed as scummy and refuse to make in serious changes doesn't exactly help your case. Just because you claim all accusations against you are scum engineered does not mean that they are. Nor does it mean that these accusations are baseless and can just be disregarded. You say those voting for you are scum and just doing it to have you lynched, but, no matter what, at the very least some of the people voting for you are town and they did so for legitimate reasons. Reasons that you are failing to address. Admittedly, the case against you is weak. But, this is day 1, pretty much every case that could come up will be weak. If you don't shape up soon it is likely that you will be lynched for lack of a better alternative.

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

And the evidence against me is:

Either none

or

1. I told people it was a scum BW.

FOS vodean as it wasn't random and there is no evidence for me

it was random. an innocent question. seems like he doesnt have all that much experience with you, and he asked an innocent question. Also, you have been defensive from the start.

He's been in 2 or 3 games with me. That is total BS from him. Just trying to defend your scum pardner eh?

No, defending myself. As has been said, you FOS everyone who dares to vote you. Even IF i was scum, and he was my partner, we wouldn't know untill night 1, would we? unless your scum and you know?

vodean wrote:

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:

colton24 wrote:

vodean wrote:FOS safarifor doing random votes. less evidence than for colton.

And the evidence against me is:

Either none

or

1. I told people it was a scum BW.

FOS vodean as it wasn't random and there is no evidence for me

it was random. an innocent question. seems like he doesnt have all that much experience with you, and he asked an innocent question. Also, you have been defensive from the start.

He's been in 2 or 3 games with me. That is total BS from him. Just trying to defend your scum pardner eh?

No, defending myself. As has been said, you FOS everyone who dares to vote you. Even IF i was scum, and he was my partner, we wouldn't know untill night 1, would we? unless your scum and you know?

Yes you would because in a mafia game, the mafia know who each other are right away. I'm gonna chalk this up to inexperience more than anything else.

Can we have a votecount please?

do people just not like colton or is he scum in every game because every game I have played in this has happened. I see this as being a typical over reactor.

safariguy5 wrote:Yes you would because in a mafia game, the mafia know who each other are right away. I'm gonna chalk this up to inexperience more than anything else.

ummm... wouldn't they only know night 1? or do you know otherwise? FOS safari

vodean wrote:ummm... wouldn't they only know night 1? or do you know otherwise? FOS safari

Generally in mafia games on this site your role pm contains the name of your fellow mafia members. It is not like in real life where you could have to wait for night to find out that stuff...

spiesr wrote:

vodean wrote:ummm... wouldn't they only know night 1? or do you know otherwise? FOS safari

Generally in mafia games on this site your role pm contains the name of your fellow mafia members. It is not like in real life where you could have to wait for night to find out that stuff...

ok, thanks unFOS safari

vodean wrote:

spiesr wrote:

vodean wrote:ummm... wouldn't they only know night 1? or do you know otherwise? FOS safari

Generally in mafia games on this site your role pm contains the name of your fellow mafia members. It is not like in real life where you could have to wait for night to find out that stuff...

ok, thanks unFOS safari

FYI, no need to unFOS. It doesn't count as a vote, but thanks anyways.