[GON 2nd mafia game] The townies won

[DB4Christ]

TC, I was of course joking about the "Mass Claim". Given my resistance to answer your claim call's in VT, I thought you of all people would appreciate the humor of it coming from me! I agree with what you and Mtamb are saying, with Mtambs exemptions. I don't think we should lynch noobz for not saying much on D1. They could be just trying to get a feel for the game, it can be very confusing at first brother. Remember how many innocent 1st timers were lost in VT for the same reasons.

[Gabsensei]

but i do agree that there are people mroe suspicious then you are so i will vote for someone else unvote thecrown and voting for DB4 cuz of his overeagerness to lynch

[TheCrown]

And a "no vote" is proven to not get us anywhere as townies... even if we lynch a townie, there will be things that can be learned by it. Hard to explain, you'll have to trust me. Voting patterns and such.


FP'ed by DB4.
I thought you might be joking, but wasn't sure. I just put it on record that a "mass claim" is scummy. And, if people aren't participating, newbies or not, they need to be hung.

[Gabsensei]

I was viewed as "talking too much" last game, because I was trying to help everyone. I am letting things develop on here more before I speak, as I don't want to horde all the conversation.

ah! i understand it then there my friend *hand a whiskey on ice* have a drink with me with some doughtnuts

[Gabsensei]

D: i gave you my last portion of whiskey i need more brb *run off to the nearest market to buy some scotch this time*

[DB4Christ]

Your right TC, I remember how tough it can be on D1 to find SCUM, but they have their tells. That said........... lets crack some eggs and see who scrambles!

[DB4Christ]

Unvote Archer - Vote:killuminati

[TuffyLess]

Here are my thoughts:

#1 suspect = killuminati - he has not talked... probably mafia
#2 suspect = qbert - he gives no reason for vote
#3 suspect = jusplay - he bandwagons with no reason
#4 suspect = Ragot - bandwagon voting

Ready to be suspects = crasp and DB4.
Crasp seems so sure of who is scum... Seems like he trying to convince to lynch. He can't be so sure unless he is scum and knows who is town and mafia, and is trying to throw us off.
DB4 seems overeager and asked for a mass claim. Scummy to me.

Then let this be a shout-out to those 4.
Reasonless voting & bandwagoning voting w/ no discussion or explanation.
Lets have some you 4 or else...



Crasp ... well, Ill bite my tongue for now; dunno. Dont think I knew her alignment last game either until the bitter end.
DB4 - I accept that the mass claim was humor; i even chuckled (w/ a "yeah right " comment in mind) when i read that.

[TheCrown]

Again DB4, you seems to go in many different directions very quickly. Suspicious.

I do agree to get killuminati to talk, although if he does, I'm sure he will say he has nothing to say, which is almost the same as posting something that gives absolutely no value. I will wait on voting him though, and just see if he will post with anything he sees that is possibly suspicious.


FP'ed by Tuffy

[archer3base]

Forget football ... where is that rope?
Jocks play ball & intellectuals write poems ... im looking for gangsters.

Tuffy - DB4 brought the rope but Archer had a problem with that and voted to lynch him. Archer must be mafia. Everyone has to get in line on this.
I've already voted to lynch Archer so I don't need to put it in red. But maybe I need to vote it again to get everyone on track. Talking football is great but this is about mafia not football. We gotta flush a mafia out before they start killing us. And believe me, they will.
vote Archer3base

DB4 has been talking too much so I thought he may be overcompensating and trying to convince people he is not mafia. You trying to defend him only increases my suspicion... We'll only really know something after the 1st lynching anyways so I figure he was as good a person to vote for as anyone else.

[crasp]

I have no idea who mafia are. I started off trying to hint to Scarlett lady to watch what she says as most of us know that by round three a statement like "who are we voting for" can come back and bite one right on ones bottom. Then Mith came in giving it the sir Galahad tactics so i started playing around. If they had been i reckon both would have voted for me. Crown is right though, railroading is a sign but most are first timers so who knows.
Unvote mith. Time to get serious. Americano no sugar, no doughnuts. trying to get down to 30 stone for Christmas. Be along shortly.

[TheCrown]

Ok, Killuminati has been on CC since I posted my suspicions of him.... and nothing. Guess I need to make this a little more substantial.

VOTE KILLUMINATI

Am getting the feeling I would like him to claim too... but will wait and see how long it takes him to get in here first.

[archer3base]

Crowner is trying hard to steer the vote... Suspicious to anyone else or normal good guy behavior?

[crasp]

Get talking Kill. if your not sure what to do pm sirius.
Vote killuminati

[crasp]

Crowner is trying hard to steer the vote... Suspicious to anyone else or normal good guy behavior?

Not sure this time Archer.just hold in the back of your head it is always role play. For what its worth i wouldnt trust him as far as i could throw him but we got to start somewhere.

[TheCrown]

Crowner is trying hard to steer the vote... Suspicious to anyone else or normal good guy behavior?

This is not trying hard.... killumiati is definitely suspect and staying on the down low. I am helping in a direction, after watching us flounder for many days. I am not saying to lynch him, just to get him to talk.

FP'ed by crasp
butthead.

[DB4Christ]

It is consistent with his (TC's) first game tactics and approach. What concerns me now, is that he seems to penalize you (that would be me) for following his lead.......very suspicious. That is very inconsistent with his first game responses and roll as a GT/Wtchr.

[TheCrown]

Well, now I know you have experience playing DB4, and seeing you flip-flop all over the place is quite alarming... part of that I'm sure was you "mass claim" joke. But you see a good point and seem to change your mind without asking many questions... signs that you are mafia and just eager to get someone lynched that is town. I could be wrong, but just take Day 1 with a grain of salt, as I'm not even voting you... so put your hackles down.

[DB4Christ]

Well TC, if you want GT's to follow your lead and logic so as to pressure the silent into talking, don't penalize them with your suspicion. While I do have one game under my belt, I would hardly call myself an expert SCUM spotter! You made a good point, it agreed with D1 tactics, and I supported your effort thusly. I know enough not to be chummed in or intimidated by SCUM tactics! Rest easy brother, I have not yet begun a campaign.

[TheCrown]

I guess my opinion was that we didn't need to vote him yet, and you were the 1st one to start it. Over-eagerness IMO, but no big deal.

[DB4Christ]

What a difference 1 game makes! W

[crasp]

Crasp ... well, Ill bite my tongue for now; dunno. Dont think I knew her alignment last game either until the bitter end.

Tuffy got me well sussed out.

[DB4Christ]

Down to business. Lets get 7 or so to vote Kill, and see what he has to say. GT's....the time has come for all to help out in seeking SCUM. As TC said, silence is suspect........ and subject to a "Town Beat Down"!

[DB4Christ]

Keep Tuf on a short leash Crasp.

[SiriusCowKing]

Day 1 vote count:

archer3base - Cump Sherman
crasp - Scarlet Lady
DB4Christ - archer3base, justplay4fun, Ragot25, qbert68, Gabsensei
Killuminati19 - DB4Christ, TheCrown, crasp
TheCrown - CHECK-M8


With 19 players in the game it takes 10 votes to lynch.

Deadline is in 11 days