dazza2008 wrote:I want to hear what codierose has to say first if that is ok. Golden egg does not seem like a character to me. So are you Humpty Dumpty codie?
omg it was a joke haha lol there's no need for mass claim there seems to be 2 sides
clever and ghost. in all the games I've seen clever play this one he's put the most effort into i say he has a power role but what town or scum i don't believe he's vt he would not put so much effort in. Look at your game dazz he put no effort in what so ever turns out to be vt my vote stays with clever
dazza2008 wrote:I want to hear what codierose has to say first if that is ok. Golden egg does not seem like a character to me. So are you Humpty Dumpty codie?
omg it was a joke haha lol there's no need for mass claim there seems to be 2 sides
clever and ghost. in all the games I've seen clever play this one he's put the most effort into i say he has a power role but what town or scum i don't believe he's vt he would not put so much effort in. Look at your game dazz he put no effort in what so ever turns out to be vt my vote stays with clever
OK so it was a joke but why are you so against the mass claim?
dazza2008 wrote:I want to hear what codierose has to say first if that is ok. Golden egg does not seem like a character to me. So are you Humpty Dumpty codie?
omg it was a joke haha lol there's no need for mass claim there seems to be 2 sides
clever and ghost. in all the games I've seen clever play this one he's put the most effort into i say he has a power role but what town or scum i don't believe he's vt he would not put so much effort in. Look at your game dazz he put no effort in what so ever turns out to be vt my vote stays with clever
OK so it was a joke but why are you so against the mass claim?
I think what codie is saying is that he's sure clever is one of the mafia. Therefore, he believes that a massclaim is not necessary.
dazz if you think mass claim is best for town lets have a show of hands i cant see it helping town every one will claim vt so where will that get us. but if thats what everyone wants to do lets do it
codierose wrote:dazz if you think mass claim is best for town lets have a show of hands i cant see it helping town every one will claim vt so where will that get us. but if thats what everyone wants to do lets do it
I'm not sure it is the best thing. It just seemed that you were against it and I wanted to know why.
I wanted to see what you had to say about the egg comment but you seem to have been joking.
i believe he was joking about the egg comment (i think i remember reading about it). anyways, as this game as slowed substantially, i am going to go find the most recent vote count so that i can remember who has how many votes. maybe we should do a roll call, i could randomize our names and then when it was your turn you could post who you think is the scummiest and why. just trying to get conversation going again.
new guy1 wrote:i believe he was joking about the egg comment (i think i remember reading about it). anyways, as this game as slowed substantially, i am going to go find the most recent vote count so that i can remember who has how many votes. maybe we should do a roll call, i could randomize our names and then when it was your turn you could post who you think is the scummiest and why. just trying to get conversation going again.
here you go thanks to random.org
List Randomizer
There were 6 items in your list. Here they are in random order:
new guy1 wrote:i believe he was joking about the egg comment (i think i remember reading about it). anyways, as this game as slowed substantially, i am going to go find the most recent vote count so that i can remember who has how many votes. maybe we should do a roll call, i could randomize our names and then when it was your turn you could post who you think is the scummiest and why. just trying to get conversation going again.
here you go thanks to random.org
List Randomizer
There were 6 items in your list. Here they are in random order:
Alright then. My vote stands with Clever. He and New guy1 seemed to be working together constantly to try to pin safari, and therefore, though none of us 3 exactly had a scum slip, I believe them to be the summiest and would not mind starting the lynch off with him due to his overall talk, and new guy1's overall defending of him even though admittedly, they broke down their own case in the end in my opinion.
I still find Codierose the scummiest. For his joking about being the egg. Seemed a bad time for a joke. He has now said it was a joke but I thought he was serious to begin with as did others or just Saf. My point is someone else thought it too.
Also the reasons he was against the mass claim made me think he was worried about claiming. If we do at any stage do the mass claim I would like codie to claim first.
Ok my turn
I still find safari scummy in the fact that he wanted trini gone and I know mafia could have set him up like that but I can't take that risk
And also that ghostly is defending him even if it supports his case seems like scum biddies to me so my vote stands on safari
And in about the mass claim codie seemed right in saying that everyone would claim vt
But I highly agree with dazza that we should pick the names out
Some7hingCLEVER wrote:Ok my turn
I still find safari scummy in the fact that he wanted trini gone and I know mafia could have set him up like that but I can't take that risk
And also that ghostly is defending him even if it supports his case seems like scum biddies to me so my vote stands on safari
And in about the mass claim codie seemed right in saying that everyone would claim vt
But I highly agree with dazza that we should pick the names out
Thats what I have to day about it so
Next
Honestly, I found clever the scummiest mainly because whether through willful ignorance or general stubbornness, he won't let go of a clearly WIFOM statement. I'm not going to reargue the point.
However, the fact that codie seems unwilling to claim seems scummy to me. While getting a lot of VT claims is probable, we can still learn something from the character flavors. A massclaim is not without merit at this point with the game stalling.
FOS dazza i clearly said i dont have a problem claiming i said if it is in the best interested of town and asked you if thats what we want. Now you completely skimmed over the question and say i look scummy for not claiming lol. Now again your dodging claiming by asking me to go first looks to me like your trying to put pressure on me and avoid claiming your self.
I will say it again i have no problem claiming only if its in the interest of the town not everyone has agreed to it yet i will go first if you like new guy needs to claim aswell need a show of hands first.
There are already cases on the table do we not want to deal with that first or are we going to keep changing the subject ie the suspicion away from the two..
This whole deal with claiming seems to be a plan from scum to defect suspicion
codierose wrote:FOS dazza i clearly said i dont have a problem claiming i said if it is in the best interested of town and asked you if thats what we want. Now you completely skimmed over the question and say i look scummy for not claiming lol. Now again your dodging claiming by asking me to go first looks to me like your trying to put pressure on me and avoid claiming your self.
I will say it again i have no problem claiming only if its in the interest of the town not everyone has agreed to it yet i will go first if you like new guy needs to claim aswell need a show of hands first.
There are already cases on the table do we not want to deal with that first or are we going to keep changing the subject ie the suspicion away from the two..
This whole deal with claiming seems to be a plan from scum to defect suspicion
I was asked to say who I am most suspicious of and why. I did that and I have not skimmed anything. I clearly explained why I am suspious of you. Why not let this roll call finish then discuss it??
i cant really say i find anyone scummy now. i believe CLEVER's claim, but he does seem quite scummy due to many slip ups, but he seems to have those in every game. i still believe ghostly to be scummy, but he has shot down every arguement i presented him with, which has detered me greatly. besides that i could see safari being his partner, but i must admit CLEVER and I have been much more cooperative then they have together.
new guy1 wrote:i cant really say i find anyone scummy now. i believe CLEVER's claim, but he does seem quite scummy due to many slip ups, but he seems to have those in every game. i still believe ghostly to be scummy, but he has shot down every arguement i presented him with, which has detered me greatly. besides that i could see safari being his partner, but i must admit CLEVER and I have been much more cooperative then they have together.
the only reason im cooperating with you and dazza and codie is because i believe so strongly that ghostly and safari are scum...therefore leaving everyone else town and since im town this is why i cooperate