LOTR Mafia-Night 3[On hold]

Koesen · Post by **Koesen** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 7:41 pm

Huckleberryhound wrote:Question, how do we distinguish between votes for ring bearers, and votes for lynch ?

That being said....vote Koesen (lynch vote)

For Getting behind the TWO Lynch early on, and for no apparent reason.

In truth, i think there are a lot of people who jumped on TWO for no reason, but this one seems kinda scummy.

Well, evidently my vote for TWO was a mistake. However, I'm hardly the only one who was wrong there.

What can I say? It was a day one vote. Mine was mostly a joke, but then he drew suspicion from other people and became the most likely target for a lynch. If you make a mistake on Day One, you die.

You can lynch me in turn, but it won't get you anywhere, cause I am town too. I'm not going to roleclaim on one vote though.

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 8:20 pm

i say we give it to some1 whoimmediatlypasses it on secretly so the mafia doesnt know

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:32 pm

Reading back, Koesen's behaviour seems pretty normal to me for a Day1, I'm not convinced.
I'll vote Dwight for now, he's posting everywhere but here, and his only 2 posts were voting TWO and saying that's a lynch.

dwightschrute · Post by **dwightschrute** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:33 pm

ga7 wrote:Reading back, Koesen's behaviour seems pretty normal to me for a Day1, I'm not convinced.
I'll vote Dwight for now, he's posting everywhere but here, and his only 2 posts were voting TWO and saying that's a lynch.

just because i am not posting doesnt mean i am not active. I have read the thread as new posts come, but dont post cause i dont feel i need to. That is a really bad reason to vote.

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:37 pm

Strangely I knew voting for you would make you appear magically, it has happened before

Ok you don't feel the need to post, for the lynch side I understand, however I think the ringbearer situation is interesting enough to deserve as much input as we can get. So, any opinion on that?

dwightschrute · Post by **dwightschrute** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:40 pm

ga7 wrote:Strangely I knew voting for you would make you appear magically, it has happened before
Ok you don't feel the need to post, for the lynch side I understand, however I think the ringbearer situation is interesting enough to deserve as much input as we can get. So, any opinion on that?

oh yeah i should talk about that, sorry. I personally think we should hand it over to a noob and then have the doc protect for one night so they can pass it on to a veteran, so i think what everyone else thinks. So i will Vote MM for Ringbearer as long as he understands what he must do.

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:42 pm

Fair enough. I'm not sure about whether he should pass it to another noob or a veteran though.
unvote

dwightschrute · Post by **dwightschrute** » Wed Jul 04, 2007 9:44 pm

ga7 wrote:Fair enough. I'm not sure about whether he should pass it to another noob or a veteran though.
unvote

yeah because then mafia can just guess a veteran and might come up with the right person, so he could probably pass it on to anyone to keep it moving. I do think it should change hands every night.

LSU Tiger Josh · Post by **LSU Tiger Josh** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 1:19 am

Koeson while I appreciate the fact you think that I am worthy of the ring, I would prefer not to have it as it would too easily make me a target by the mafia at night. I would just be passing it on to someone random with my best guess to try to keep the mafia from receiving it.

Vote Huck Hound to be lynched as Koeson's method of voting on day 1 wasn't all that out of sort.

Minister Masket · Post by **Minister Masket** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 3:03 am

Wow. Can't say I was expecting that. Even more surprising is that mandy himself started it. A swift change of heart from you there.

Anyway, if I am the next ringbearer and I decide I'm gonna pass it on, I need to know who is townie and who isn't. Accidentally passing it into the hands of the scum is gonna end this game pretty sharpish...

jnd94 · Post by **jnd94** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 6:56 am

Minister Masket wrote:Wow. Can't say I was expecting that. Even more surprising is that mandy himself started it. A swift change of heart from you there.
Anyway, if I am the next ringbearer and I decide I'm gonna pass it on, I need to know who is townie and who isn't. Accidentally passing it into the hands of the scum is gonna end this game pretty sharpish...

I am convinced this is bullshit. FOS MM. I dont believe a word you just said, scum.

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 7:20 am

I agree there, what are you expecting, a mass roleclaim?
For previously mentioned reasons I feel you are a good choice MM, but you'll have to rely on your own judgment there.
The way I see it, if scum gets it and decides to use it they'll sacrifice one of them; it'd be costly for the town but a pretty sure way to get scum.

jnd94 · Post by **jnd94** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 7:24 am

ga7 wrote:I agree there, what are you expecting, a mass roleclaim?
For previously mentioned reasons I feel you are a good choice MM, but you'll have to rely on your own judgment there.
The way I see it, if scum gets it and decides to use it they'll sacrifice one of them; it'd be costly for the town but a pretty sure way to get scum.

its common sense we cant mass roleclaim this early. If MM is scum, then he will know all the power roles and he wont be killed becuase we think he is the ringbearer. Even if he isnt scum, the scum can just pretend to be town during the roleclaim, and they have all roles.

Chad22342 · Post by **Chad22342** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 8:27 am

Vote Count

(1)Koesen-(Huckleberryhound)
(1)Huckleberryhound-(LSU Tiger Josh)

For the Ring of Power

(4)Minister Masket-(Mandy,ga7,Dwightshrute,Koesen)
(1)Koesen-(Firth)

With 12 alive it will take 7 to decide, Day ends friday 5PM!

Koesen · Post by **Koesen** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 8:33 am

Since I may not be on much in the next few days, I'll change my vote for the ringbearer from LSU to Minister Masket.

It makes sense that the ringbearer wants to know who is town. It also makes sense that the townies don't want to tell him

It's all a gamble at this stage anyway.

Huckleberryhound · Post by **Huckleberryhound** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 9:46 am

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Koeson while I appreciate the fact you think that I am worthy of the ring, I would prefer not to have it as it would too easily make me a target by the mafia at night. I would just be passing it on to someone random with my best guess to try to keep the mafia from receiving it.

Vote Huck Hound to be lynched as Koeson's method of voting on day 1 wasn't all that out of sort.

That makes sense...i am the only one who votes for anyone, so you jump on me and vote for me....just like you did with TWO, except then it was "Bandwaggoning" you claimed.

fos LSU

Huckleberryhound · Post by **Huckleberryhound** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 9:49 am

Huckleberryhound wrote:
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Koeson while I appreciate the fact you think that I am worthy of the ring, I would prefer not to have it as it would too easily make me a target by the mafia at night. I would just be passing it on to someone random with my best guess to try to keep the mafia from receiving it.

Vote Huck Hound to be lynched as Koeson's method of voting on day 1 wasn't all that out of sort.

That makes sense...i am the only one who votes for anyone, so you jump on me and vote for me....just like you did with TWO, except then it was "Bandwaggoning" you claimed.

fos LSU

Oh yeah, i wasn't saying TWO was the only one who voted when he got it, just that you jumped on him too. Even if my ideas aren't sound, i'm the only one trying to play for some reason....and yesterday yous voted for the dumbest reasons, and what did that get yous ????

oh yeah...and fos dwight for submarining yesterday.

firth4eva · Post by **firth4eva** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 11:10 am

vote koesen for suggesting lsu

firth4eva · Post by **firth4eva** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 11:10 am

vote koesen for suggesting lsu to be ringbearer

Minister Masket · Post by **Minister Masket** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 11:53 am

ga7 wrote:I agree there, what are you expecting, a mass roleclaim?

Not necessarly a role claim, more like a side claim.
Anyway, I think I probably won't pass it on, just to be sure. Unless you think I really should in the town's best interest? I need opinions....
Where's mandy when you need him...?

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 12:05 pm

Firth, is that a lynch vote and if yes why choosing LSU was a bad thing?

MM, I highly doubt someone will stand and say "I'm scum, don't give me the ring! Oh, you can lynch me btw kthxbai"

Joke aside, I think it's more useful to pass the ring at least one time, even if it's nice I don't see the point on everyone knowing who the ringbearer is, especially if there's a SK on top of the scum. They'll both want it for sure

firth4eva · Post by **firth4eva** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 12:07 pm

ga7 wrote:Firth, is that a lynch vote and if yes why choosing LSU was a bad thing?

lynch vote
same reason we currently want mm as ringbearer

Huckleberryhound · Post by **Huckleberryhound** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 12:07 pm

Minister Masket wrote:
ga7 wrote:I agree there, what are you expecting, a mass roleclaim?
Not necessarly a role claim, more like a side claim.
Anyway, I think I probably won't pass it on, just to be sure. Unless you think I really should in the town's best interest? I need opinions....
Where's mandy when you need him...?

I would guess that if the doc is active, he'd protect you. So, as long as a role blocker doesn't get the doc...you'll be alright.

Huckleberryhound · Post by **Huckleberryhound** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 12:09 pm

ga7 wrote:Firth, is that a lynch vote and if yes why choosing LSU was a bad thing?

MM, I highly doubt someone will stand and say "I'm scum, don't give me the ring! Oh, you can lynch me btw kthxbai"
Joke aside, I think it's more useful to pass the ring at least one time, even if it's nice I don't see the point on everyone knowing who the ringbearer is, especially if there's a SK on top of the scum. They'll both want it for sure

If he passes the ring, then it could go to scum.....vote MM ring bearer....just on the hunch that he isn't scum.

ga7 · Post by **ga7** » Thu Jul 05, 2007 12:15 pm

Firth - but Koesen changed his ringvote to MM then?

Huckle - well I just figured it would be a bad thing for the doc to be blocked all game on him, but it's true that it's a riskier move. Ah well, I don't know