cops vs mafia game thread day 2

[Fuzzylogic99]

yeah...could of.Just being ADD

[pancakemix]

I claim doctor!

First off, this is obviously a joke.

Second, I'm going to repeat myself and say MOD, given the setup, this should begin at Night 0 with no kill, not day 1.

[captainwalrus]

I claim doctor!

there will be:
cop
naive cop
paranoid cop
insane cop
mafia

BS mate no docs in this one. unvote

vote captainwalrus for a fake claim (since there are no docs) and unpressured claim

That was the joke...
I have a lame sense of humor, sue me.

[captainwalrus]

captain walrus makes me suspicious

a) he wanted to start day which helps the mafia
b) his fake DR claims

almost seems to easy though..

Im not sure what to make of the whole mess

a) I hadn't thought of starting at night. I just wanted to get started in general.

[wercool]

well if you want it to start on night you can just vote no lynch and it will be as if it started on nght

Second, I'm going to repeat myself and say MOD, given the setup, this should begin at Night 0 with no kill, not day 1.

if it turns out i need to i can just make another game

[pancakemix]

well if you want it to start on night you can just vote no lynch and it will be as if it started on nght

Second, I'm going to repeat myself and say MOD, given the setup, this should begin at Night 0 with no kill, not day 1.

if it turns out i need to i can just make another game

Actually, that would give scum a kill and make it nigh impossible for town to win without guessing. It wouldn't kill anyone to just make it night now.

[wercool]

well if you want it to start on night you can just vote no lynch and it will be as if it started on nght

Second, I'm going to repeat myself and say MOD, given the setup, this should begin at Night 0 with no kill, not day 1.

if it turns out i need to i can just make another game

Actually, that would give scum a kill and make it nigh impossible for town to win without guessing. It wouldn't kill anyone to just make it night now.

okay i geuss that makes since. sorry scum but it is now
night 0
all cops send in an investagation

[wercool]

after some discussion and some very good persuading by pancake the mod finaly agreed to go to night where the cops woke up in the middle night to look for mafia.
day 2

[captainwalrus]

you mean day one?

[Fuzzylogic99]

I investigated myself...and found myself innocent so Im

the cop or the naive cop...not sure

[colton24]

I meant to investigate myself, but investigated PCM and got guilty. So I'm either insane or parinoid

[pancakemix]

I investigated myself...and found myself innocent so Im

the cop or the naive cop...not sure

I also investigated you and got innocent.

Fuzz-->Fuzz-->Town
Colt-->PCM--->Scum
PCM-->Fuzz--->Town

CW? Greg?

[captainwalrus]

Well, I actually investigated myself and got scum, so I am either paranoid or insane.

[captainwalrus]

Greg?

[gregwolf121]

sorry i investigated fuzzylogic and got guilty so im either insane or paranoid or the sane cop but im not naive

[colton24]

I'm going to vote fuzz since there are 3 different results. 2 for town and one fore mafia just doesn't seem right.

[captainwalrus]

So one of PMC Fuzz or Greg is scum, the other 2 are either insane cop and nieve cop, or normal cop and nieve cop.

[pancakemix]

Fuzz-->Fuzz-->Town----> Naive/Sane/Lying
Colt-->PCM--->Scum----> Sane/Insane/Paranoid/Lying
PCM-->Fuzz--->Town----> Sane/Insane/Naive/Lying
CW---->CW--->Scum----> Paranoid/Insane/Lying
Greg-->Fuzz-->Scum----> Sane/Insane/Paranoid/Lying

We've got no intelligence on Colton, so let's investigate him.

Vote No Lynch

[captainwalrus]

Vote PCM.
No lynch is scummy, especially in this game. If we lynch someone it eliminates the things that other people can be.
Say we lynch you, and you come out to not be scum
I you are sane, we a) cleared Fuzz, b) know that no one else is sane, making our results more accurate in the future.
If you are Naive we just know that no one else is naive which is a good help, as naive throw us off.

[wercool]

quick note i wont reveal what sanity a cop is when he gets killed
vote count
pmc 1 cw
fuzz 1 colton
no lynch 1 pcm
not voting fuzz greg
3 to lynch

[colton24]

quick note i wont reveal what sanity a cop is when he gets killed
vote count
pmc 1 cw
fuzz 1 colton
no lynch 1 pcm
not voting fuzz greg
3 to lynch

WHAT!!!That is complete BS. Everyone does. I knew I shouldn't of joined this, unvote

vote mod

[colton24]

quick note i wont reveal what sanity a cop is when he gets killed
vote count
pmc 1 cw
fuzz 1 colton
no lynch 1 pcm
not voting fuzz greg
3 to lynch

WHAT!!!That is complete BS. Everyone does. I knew I shouldn't of joined this, unvote

vote CW It is a logical reason that PCM wants to go no lynch and that is to see what my investigation says

EBWOP, just a jokr vote

[captainwalrus]

quick note i wont reveal what sanity a cop is when he gets killed
vote count
pmc 1 cw
fuzz 1 colton
no lynch 1 pcm
not voting fuzz greg
3 to lynch

WHAT!!!That is complete BS. Everyone does. I knew I shouldn't of joined this, unvote

vote CW It is a logical reason that PCM wants to go no lynch and that is to see what my investigation says

EBWOP, just a jokr vote

If the roles are not revealed, yet, if they are, then no. That just gives the mafia an extra kill but we still don't know our state of sanity.
At the time he voted, he did not know that wer was not going to say if they are sane or not.

[gregwolf121]

Fuzz-->Fuzz-->Town----> Naive/Sane/Lying
Colt-->PCM--->Scum----> Sane/Insane/Paranoid/Lying
PCM-->Fuzz--->Town----> Sane/Insane/Naive/Lying
CW---->CW--->Scum----> Paranoid/Insane/Lying
Greg-->Fuzz-->Scum----> Sane/Insane/Paranoid/Lying

so im going to put this in a different chart so that we can figure out who is who
naive cop-->Fuzz, PCM
insane cop-->Colt, PCM, CW, Greg
Paranoid cop-->Colt, Cw, Greg
sane cop-->Fuzz, Colt, PCM, CW, Greg
mafia-->Fuzz, Colt, PCM, CW, Greg-the only reason i include myself in the mafia list is that three of you are not as sure that im town, the two who know im town are the mafia dude and me

[pancakemix]

Vote PCM.
No lynch is scummy, especially in this game. If we lynch someone it eliminates the things that other people can be.
Say we lynch you, and you come out to not be scum
I you are sane, we a) cleared Fuzz, b) know that no one else is sane, making our results more accurate in the future.
If you are Naive we just know that no one else is naive which is a good help, as naive throw us off.

Actually I'm quite familiar with this setup, having participated (and modded) in it numerous times. That's why I was so insistant on a Night 0: It's just how it's done. If we lynch today and are right, we got lucky. If we're wrong (and we have a 4/5 chance of being wrong), we're down a 2 cops (counting the NK) and we're at LYLO without enough info, especially considering this:

quick note i wont reveal what sanity a cop is when he gets killed

Is proper procedure for the Dethy setup (yes, I even know its proper name). That said, if we forego the lynch, we will have 4 alive and hopefully enough info to find the scum, and even if we don't, we can opt to No Lynch again, ending up at LYLO with plenty of info.