Newbie Mafia (Mandalorian Loses)

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 3:52 pm

Random vote:
random vote Rictus

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 4:29 pm

NESconqueror wrote:Random vote:
random vote Rictus

Wow. I try and defend you against a bandwagon, and that's the thanks I get? NES - you're really living down to your reputation at this point...

Vote: NES for 'randomly' voting for me. You're now at -2 to lynch (-1 if Kiwi redos his vote in blue so it counts), smartarse - I really hope you didn't jsut skim the thread and then vote. My current pet hate is skimmers....

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 5:24 pm

Rictus wrote:
NESconqueror wrote:Random vote:
random vote Rictus
Wow. I try and defend you against a bandwagon, and that's the thanks I get? NES - you're really living down to your reputation at this point...

Vote: NES for 'randomly' voting for me. You're now at -2 to lynch (-1 if Kiwi redos his vote in blue so it counts), smartarse - I really hope you didn't jsut skim the thread and then vote. My current pet hate is skimmers....

rictus, being honest, you might want to calm down there... A random vote is just that... And I did NOT skim at all.

mandalorian2298 · Post by **mandalorian2298** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 6:10 pm

VOTE COUNT

NES(2) - Jake, Rictus
Diddle(1) - MTG
Jake (1) - boroX0
Rictus (1) - NES

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch

Thanks for staying diddle.

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 6:51 pm

NESconqueror wrote: rictus, being honest, you might want to calm down there... A random vote is just that... And I did NOT skim at all.

Then you knew you were 'randomly' voting for someone who was sticking up for you? Yeah, that's great strategy... why is it you keep getting blacklisted, do you think?

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:16 pm

thats 3 on you nes

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:33 pm

I am a cop already! No more pain upon me! Hopefully there is a doctor in the house... cause I ain't living long due to you voters upon me.

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:36 pm

ehhhhhhhhhhhhhunvote... i believe you for now.

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:45 pm

He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:48 pm

Rictus wrote:He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.

That sounds VERY scummy there...
Lynching the real cop is a bad idea.

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:53 pm

Rictus wrote:He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.

....unless you straight out tell me you are a cop im voting you. There is a doc and hell protect you IF you really are.vote rictus

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:54 pm

NESconqueror wrote:
Rictus wrote:He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.
That sounds VERY scummy there...
Lynching the real cop is a bad idea.

Right. Lynching you, with your fake claim, on the other hand, would be the perfect start.

Lynch him - if I'm lying, lynch me tomorrow. But I'm not - he's lying, and I'm 90% certain he's scum.

Hammer. Then protect me, doc, if there is one. If not, scum will kill me tonight and you'll have your proof - by which time, it'll be too late.

Do this right town and we could get a perfect victory here...

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 8:56 pm

0ojakeo0 wrote:
Rictus wrote:He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.
....unless you straight out tell me you are a cop im voting you. There is a doc and hell protect you IF you really are.vote rictus

You're either an idiot or NES's scum buddy - FOS Jake either way, once NES is lynched and shown to be scum, you're next - unless they get me, in which case, they'll have a hard time choosing between you and NES..

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:01 pm

EBWOP - and Jake, pushing for a second role declaration on Day 1? Scummy as hell. Do the math on who I am, come to your senses and vote for NES. Then when you see I'm telling the truth, make sure I'm protected.

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:05 pm

Rictus wrote:
NESconqueror wrote:
Rictus wrote:He's lying. Lynch him.

Then protect me tonight.
That sounds VERY scummy there...
Lynching the real cop is a bad idea.
Right. Lynching you, with your fake claim, on the other hand, would be the perfect start.

Lynch him - if I'm lying, lynch me tomorrow. But I'm not - he's lying, and I'm 90% certain he's scum.

Hammer. Then protect me, doc, if there is one. If not, scum will kill me tonight and you'll have your proof - by which time, it'll be too late.

Do this right town and we could get a perfect victory here...

How the f*ck can you be 90 percent certain???my vote stays on you. Odds are mandy picked a game w/ a doc, cop and two mafia. And if he picked out of the 4 randomly mandy you suck

Also if your not the cop then the doc should not protect you. B/C if you are wrong you are a prime bandwagon for them tomorrow

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:05 pm

Rictus wrote:EBWOP - and Jake, pushing for a second role declaration on Day 1? Scummy as hell. Do the math on who I am, come to your senses and vote for NES. Then when you see I'm telling the truth, make sure I'm protected.

1. its called role CLAIM. and two its still one if you guys are claiming THE EXACT SAME ROLE.

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:13 pm

0ojakeo0 wrote:
Rictus wrote:EBWOP - and Jake, pushing for a second role declaration on Day 1? Scummy as hell. Do the math on who I am, come to your senses and vote for NES. Then when you see I'm telling the truth, make sure I'm protected.
1. its called role CLAIM. and two its still one if you guys are claiming THE EXACT SAME ROLE.

Jake, I give up - you're either NES's scum buddy or the dumbest townie ever - guys, if I get lynched, once you see my role, lynch these two jokers in order and you'll probably win anyway - providing the doc can find a townie to protect - anyone know if a night 1 victory for the scum is mathematically possible?

0ojakeo0 · Post by **0ojakeo0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:14 pm

Rictus wrote:
0ojakeo0 wrote:
Rictus wrote:EBWOP - and Jake, pushing for a second role declaration on Day 1? Scummy as hell. Do the math on who I am, come to your senses and vote for NES. Then when you see I'm telling the truth, make sure I'm protected.
1. its called role CLAIM. and two its still one if you guys are claiming THE EXACT SAME ROLE.
Jake, I give up - you're either NES's scum buddy or the dumbest townie ever - guys, if I get lynched, once you see my role, lynch these two jokers in order and you'll probably win anyway - providing the doc can find a townie to protect - anyone know if a night 1 victory for the scum is mathematically possible?

Give me one reason in THIS game i should belive YOU and not nes?

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:27 pm

[quote="0ojakeo0]Give me one reason in THIS game i should belive YOU and not nes?[/quote]

His claim is not credible. He ALWAYS claims Cop, seriously - every game he's played, check his posting history. Plus - I've told you he's lying. Think about the information that gives you now if you lynch him. I'm telling the truth, and we've got a day 1 scum lynch. If I'm wrong, you've got a lock for Day 2 - me. Either way, the town gets solid info from a day 1 lynch, which is pretty golden if you think about it. If I'm lying, I'm a dead man some sunrise, and the town is still in reasonable shape. If I'm telling the truth, and you lynch me, however... things will go badly for the town (though once I am lynched and my role is seen, you and NES will no doubt be done over - him first).

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:31 pm

Rictus wrote:[

I have indeed claimed a few times NOT as a cop, but as a doctor and townie before (Along with jack of all trades). The past is plain ol history, and should not be something to brood on...

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:44 pm

NESconqueror wrote:I have indeed claimed a few times NOT as a cop, but as a doctor and townie before (Along with jack of all trades). The past is plain ol history, and should not be something to brood on...

Right - I forgot about the Doc claims.

See. here's where you could be better - when you're scum, you always role claim a power role, instead of vanilla townie. That's not smart, but it's double not-smart in a game this small, because the real power role will always out you, and you have nowhere to hide. If you'd claimed vanilla townie, you're in a much better spot, because that role is countirfietable - others may hold it, but so what? There's more than one, so it's OK.

And if it works in this game, I may never play Mafia again, because it would mean I suck worse than you. No offence.

So yeah Jake, I suppose that's a claim on my part. So can we lynch this scum and get the ball rolling please?

NESconqueror · Post by **NESconqueror** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:48 pm

Rictus wrote:
NESconqueror wrote:I have indeed claimed a few times NOT as a cop, but as a doctor and townie before (Along with jack of all trades). The past is plain ol history, and should not be something to brood on...
Right - I forgot about the Doc claims. See. here's where you could be better - when you're scum, you always role claim a power role, instead of vanilla townie. That's not smart, but it's double not-smart in a game this small, because the real power role will always out you, and you have nowhere to hide. If you'd claimed vanilla townie, you're in a much better spot, because that role is countirfietable - others may hold it, but so what? There's more than one, so it's OK.

And if it works in this game, I may never play Mafia again, because it would mean I suck worse than you. No offence.

So yeah Jake, I suppose that's a claim on my part. So can we lynch this scum and get the ball rolling please?

We will get the ball rolling either way, let us wait to hear the verdict on the others first... To be honest, I speak the truth in my roleclaims. (Which means I am saying that I AM a cop). If there is no doctor, then the mafia has the cop market cornered, so I hope to see you believe me as then, I can begin the investigations to find the villains.

borox0 · Post by **borox0** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:54 pm

Rictus wrote:
0ojakeo0 wrote:
Rictus wrote:EBWOP - and Jake, pushing for a second role declaration on Day 1? Scummy as hell. Do the math on who I am, come to your senses and vote for NES. Then when you see I'm telling the truth, make sure I'm protected.
1. its called role CLAIM. and two its still one if you guys are claiming THE EXACT SAME ROLE.
Jake, I give up - you're either NES's scum buddy or the dumbest townie ever - guys, if I get lynched, once you see my role, lynch these two jokers in order and you'll probably win anyway - providing the doc can find a townie to protect - anyone know if a night 1 victory for the scum is mathematically possible?

Unvote Vote Rictus

If he's NOT mafia then we know what to do next day, if he is then we got him. Good enough logic to me.

KiwiTaker · Post by **KiwiTaker** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 9:56 pm

Hmm didn't relise I had to pote in bold and blue.

Rictus · Post by **Rictus** » Thu Nov 08, 2007 10:03 pm

borox0 wrote:
If he's NOT mafia then we know what to do next day, if he is then we got him. Good enough logic to me.

That's actually true, and as a townie, I win if the town wins. So yeah, the only problem with this is lynching your only cop on day one instead of scum.

seriously guys, do the math on this - if there's only 2 scum, how bad a scum player would I have to be to put my neck on the block like this on round 1? The only rational reason for me to claim cop is becasue I am cop - nothing else adds up...

Either way though, the town has a ton of leads tomorow...