End Game: Town Wins! (Island Mafia)

[DoomYoshi]

Vote rishaed

Thechuck convinced me.

[rishaed]

I'm done fighting today. Lynch me if you will, I suppose it might make things easier tomorrow. I can't really fault any of you for voting me either, its all been bad play on my part.

[jonty125]

Not much to add, I still think rishaed's play has been appalling and he has confessed to it.

[Djfireside]

As stated I agree with the rest that as stated I stand to believe them to a point, everything just gets clouded up and in the end its a better roll of the dice to test the claim

UNVOTE Vote Rish

However on a side note, Does GregWolf still exist? Had 3 posts all game.

[sheepofdumb]

Not too much to add. Rish said he knows there's a GF in the game and then asks me to investigate him. Pretty scummy to me. Unvote vote Rish

[gregwolf121]

hey yall im back, and dj if you had read my posts you would have known that i did tell yall that i would be gone till well yesterday, and from my reading im inclined to believe sheep, and ill agree that rishaed's play has been pretty bad but im not fully convinced that hes scum so i won't vote, and i would also agree that it is in towns best interest for sheep to investigate who he will without town telling him what to do, as that would tip off scum and they would be free to take evasive actions. that being said im pretty sure we have other protective roles out there and they will need to keep our cop safe, i for one will be watching

[new guy1]

Official Vote Count:

Rishaed: Safariguy, nebuchadnezer, Jonty, Thechuck, doomyoshi, djfireside, sheepofdumb LYNCH
Thechuck: Rishaed (L-6)



A lynch has been reached. I should have enough time to make a scene tonight. Until the scene, you may speak amongst yourselves.

[new guy1]

Throughout the days, there was one person who just didn't sit right with the rest of the group. He claimed to be a doctor, but that he couldn't help anyone until the primary doctor died. Because this was unverifiable, there were doubts. It didn't help that this man, Asim was his name, could not stop slipping on his words. After a failed case on someone who claimed to be a detective, the group had reached the end of their nerves. They strung him up and hung him from a tree far from the town. Upon searching his pockets, they found nothing. They went to his home and found documents of his past patients during the last World War. They also found documents which verified that he could have been a doctor in their time of need. With this, and no evidence of wrong doing, they concluded that he actually was a doctor. While some were saddened, others laughed to themselves, knowing it put them one step closer to their ultimate goal.

Rishaed, Asim, Back up Doctor has been lynched!

Night Actions may now be sent in. Actions are due in 48 hours, June 5th at around 7:00 PM Server Time.

[rishaed]

Go Town.

[zimmah]

/facepalm

Another classic mislynch

[new guy1]

During the night, many people rushed from place to place, whether they were just nervous or for other unknown reasons. A man walked out on to his porch to look at the moon. Maybe he thought he would see someone in the light it emitted and be able to stop the bloodshed. As these and many more thoughts ran through his head, he was shot in the chest. He fell on the ground, but was able to hold in his urge to yell. After around twenty minutes, he stood up, and walked inside. He patched himself up, and went to bed. No more lights on during the night and no more midnight views of the moon, he thought to himself as he dozed to sleep.

Another man walked with intention to kill. At around two hundred feet from his target's house, his neck grew stiff, and right before he passed out, he pulled a dart from his neck. The next thing he knew, he was in his bed at his home, safe and sound. He could not find his gun, and so he decided he would try again another night.

Elsewhere, a man woke in a sweat. He couldn't remember having a nightmare, and yet for some reason he couldn't shake the feeling that something was off. He stood beside his bed and looked outside his window. Because of the glare of his lamp, he was unable to see clearly. He quickly pinched the flame to recieve total darkness, and when he turned back to the window he saw a hooded figure standing directly on the other side. He almost let out a scream, but quickly ducked and started loading his gun. He loaded four rounds before his bedroom door opened and put the magazine in the gun. He turned to face his adversary and was knocked to the floor. On his way down his arm hit his nightstand, knocking the gun out of his hand and across the room. The hooded figure revealed his face to Benson with a grin as he stabbed him in the chest. He waited for Benson to stop breathing and walked out of the cabin, quite satisfied with his work.

Djfireside, Benson, Back up cop has been stabbed to death!

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. Deadline is June 20th at around 5:00 Server time. Deadline extensions may be requested.

[zimmah]

looks like 3 killers to me, one could be a vig though.

from the scene it makes me think a roleblocker prevented a kill, if that's the case, maybe the roleblocker should say who was targeted, because if he prevented a kill, than it may be a mafia.

[thechuck51]

looks like 3 killers to me, one could be a vig though.

from the scene it makes me think a roleblocker prevented a kill, if that's the case, maybe the roleblocker should say who was targeted, because if he prevented a kill, than it may be a mafia.

I thought the same thing too at first but he could have blocked the vig. So we could end up exposing our vig and roleblocker. Not sure it's worth the chance

[DoomYoshi]

vote zimmah

time for death

[thechuck51]

vote zimmah

time for death

Care to explain why?

[Iron Butterfly]

looks like 3 killers to me, one could be a vig though.

from the scene it makes me think a roleblocker prevented a kill, if that's the case, maybe the roleblocker should say who was targeted, because if he prevented a kill, than it may be a mafia.

You have a very bad habit of trying to draw roles out and to direct traffic.

If the role blocker prevented a kill and it was a vig that would play right into mafia hands. Then you have the role blocker and Vig exposed.

[zimmah]

looks like 3 killers to me, one could be a vig though.

from the scene it makes me think a roleblocker prevented a kill, if that's the case, maybe the roleblocker should say who was targeted, because if he prevented a kill, than it may be a mafia.

You have a very bad habit of trying to draw roles out and to direct traffic.

If the role blocker prevented a kill and it was a vig that would play right into mafia hands. Then you have the role blocker and Vig exposed.

that would only be the worst case scenario, i don't think outing a roleblocker for having a 50% shot at killing mafia is that bad. and even losing a vig isn't that bad either, as the chance of him shooting the wrong guy is pretty high.

if nothing else from tonight is being revealed, we should follow either this lead or pressure some of the voters who were responsible for the death of our back up doc. i'm pretty sure at least 1 or 2 of them are scum.

also, doom, why do you vote me all of a sudden without any kind of explanation?

[DoomYoshi]

In the 2 years I have been playing mafia on this site, the only people who post a regret about the lynch during the night are scum.

[zimmah]

In the 2 years I have been playing mafia on this site, the only people who post a regret about the lynch during the night are scum.

what a worthless reason. i never voted for lynching him after his claim, and i was opposed to it from the start, i'm still angry about the miss-lynch, because it could have easily been prevented, his claim was rock solid, and there was no reason at all to lynch him, why does that make me scum?

better chase some real leads before you make another miss lynch, we already lost both backups and it's pretty likely the identity of the cop is also known, we can't afford to make too many miss lynches, especially not the two that enable us to play follow the cop. the backups are already dead, so they were of no use at all, which is very unfortunate.

Also, after having played with me for several games, you still seem to not realize i tend to have a habit of showing my feelings about events quite often and quite strongly. if that's a scum tell to you or anyone else than so be it, but it's a worthless tell.

if you want to lose that badly than by all means lose, but i prefer to play this one out without carelessly lynching everyone for bullshit reasons like this, especially when there's probably a lot more sensible evidence lying readily available. That being said, our cop is still alive, and since someone already claimed cop, let's hair what he has to say before we jump to voting.

maybe we're lucky and cop found one, that'd be a really easy lynch.

[thechuck51]

looks like 3 killers to me, one could be a vig though.

from the scene it makes me think a roleblocker prevented a kill, if that's the case, maybe the roleblocker should say who was targeted, because if he prevented a kill, than it may be a mafia.

You have a very bad habit of trying to draw roles out and to direct traffic.

If the role blocker prevented a kill and it was a vig that would play right into mafia hands. Then you have the role blocker and Vig exposed.

that would only be the worst case scenario, i don't think outing a roleblocker for having a 50% shot at killing mafia is that bad. and even losing a vig isn't that bad either, as the chance of him shooting the wrong guy is pretty high.

if nothing else from tonight is being revealed, we should follow either this lead or pressure some of the voters who were responsible for the death of our back up doc. i'm pretty sure at least 1 or 2 of them are scum.

also, doom, why do you vote me all of a sudden without any kind of explanation?

Rishaed was essentially a VT in a no vanilla game. Would you have preferred we lynch our vig or roleblocker instead?

In the 2 years I have been playing mafia on this site, the only people who post a regret about the lynch during the night are scum.

I found that scummy as well but I'd like to hear from our detective first. Speaking of him...

As a side note, I use detective and cop interchangeably. With this said, I will not confirm that either role is in the game, and will leave that to your discretion.

so do we have a cop and a detective? Or does the backup cop backup the detective? Or is the detective claim garbage?

[zimmah]

i think if it was a fakeclaim he would have claimed cop, therefore, i think the detective claim is true.

i doubt we have a cop AND a detective, as we already had a backup cop.

and rishiad might be useless as long as the doc survives, but the chances of the doc surviving are small. we have been lucky up until now that each night we only lost 1 person, but we can't be sure of that to keep happening, and even if we lose one person, if the doc dies we're screwed, the cop will likely die the night after the doc dies, maybe even sooner if we're unlucky (for example if the doc would assume the killers would not focus the cop because they'd assume the cop was protected anyway, but than the cop got targeted anyway, or if the doc got roleblocked and the kill got through even though the doc tried to protect or if the cop is not who the doc thinks it is, etc, etc.).

if rishead wasn't lynched, at the very least it'd safe us another night. (unless he would be NKd, but even than it'd mean that another life was spared). same for the backup cop, it's pretty sad that he died, because when we lose the current cop, we won't have a new one. unless there's a backup-backup, but i truly doubt that.

[Nebuchadnezer]

In the 2 years I have been playing mafia on this site, the only people who post a regret about the lynch during the night are scum.

what a worthless reason. i never voted for lynching him after his claim, and i was opposed to it from the start, i'm still angry about the miss-lynch, because it could have easily been prevented, his claim was rock solid, and there was no reason at all to lynch him, why does that make me scum?

Please explain how his claim was "rock solid". There was nothing solid about it. Knowing what we now know, I can see that the back up roles can mean that mafia has some pretty stacked players...and I am now very nervous. But Rishaed's play along with his claim added up to scum for me.

*Logistical clarification for me please*
Can someone explain to me who kills with guns and who uses knives? I don't know that it really matters, but N1 the guy was shot and stabbed. N2 the shooter shot a bulletproof player, while the stabber stabbed the backup cop. The only difference it makes to me is to know who targeted the bulletproof player, I think. If it was mafia, then we have a town bulletproof (or bulletproof SK, which is really nasty). If it was the SK, then it tells us nothing (either town or mafia bulletproof).

I would like our cop/detective to shed some light on his target before pushing anyone.

[Iron Butterfly]

Usually a Serial killer stabs their victim.

Aagee was stabbed and shot.

Last night three people were targeted.

As far as bullet proof is concerned it could be a one shot deal or unlimited. My theory is that mafia has just as much to worry about as there is an SK and Vig. It is quite possible that a mafia person was actually targeted and perhaps it was the God Father as that could be a standard power along with being immune to investigation.

[thechuck51]

and rishiad might be useless as long as the doc survives, but the chances of the doc surviving are small. we have been lucky up until now that each night we only lost 1 person, but we can't be sure of that to keep happening, and even if we lose one person, if the doc dies we're screwed, the cop will likely die the night after the doc dies, maybe even sooner if we're unlucky (for example if the doc would assume the killers would not focus the cop because they'd assume the cop was protected anyway, but than the cop got targeted anyway, or if the doc got roleblocked and the kill got through even though the doc tried to protect or if the cop is not who the doc thinks it is, etc, etc.).

did you vote no lynch? no you didn't, so you wanted somebody lynched. This is a non vanilla game so what potential role (besides scum) would have made a better lynch? it was either lynch the scummy as f*ck back up doctor or nothing.

if rishead wasn't lynched, at the very least it'd safe us another night. (unless he would be NKd, but even than it'd mean that another life was spared). same for the backup cop, it's pretty sad that he died, because when we lose the current cop, we won't have a new one. unless there's a backup-backup, but i truly doubt that.

Again, aside from the obvious answers of scum or nobody, who would you have preferred been killed? and backup-backup? now you are being ridiculous.


side note: since when do curse words get censored?

[thechuck51]

Usually a Serial killer stabs their victim.

Aagee was stabbed and shot.

Last night three people were targeted.

As far as bullet proof is concerned it could be a one shot deal or unlimited. My theory is that mafia has just as much to worry about as there is an SK and Vig. It is quite possible that a mafia person was actually targeted and perhaps it was the God Father as that could be a standard power along with being immune to investigation.

This line from the scene makes me think its 1-shot:

During the night, many people rushed from place to place, whether they were just nervous or for other unknown reasons. A man walked out on to his porch to look at the moon. Maybe he thought he would see someone in the light it emitted and be able to stop the bloodshed. As these and many more thoughts ran through his head, he was shot in the chest. He fell on the ground, but was able to hold in his urge to yell. After around twenty minutes, he stood up, and walked inside. He patched himself up, and went to bed. No more lights on during the night and no more midnight views of the moon, he thought to himself as he dozed to sleep.