Double Fanucci Mafia (4/14) Endgame

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

[Iron Butterfly]

unvote

[NoSurvivors]

so uh, what's up with that edit NoS?

Changed it back cos you posted, but it called you out on being a scummy player rather than being an inexperienced player due to your flawed logic with the posting system (something you're familiar with) and your skimming

I posted, you posted two and three minutes later, I click "look at latest post in thread" and it brings me to your second post

I don't see how that's skimming. I made a mistake but not seeing you made two posts

Lol totally misread that. Nvm you're right

[NoSurvivors]

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

I'll get at least one protect (more if they don't kill me) but it saves anyone else from getting killed at night

[Metsfanmax]

Re AOG: I can confirm that the forum software kind of sucks. Sometimes I'll click for latest post and I'll miss like the last five because it brings me to the next page.

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

Claimed docs will often get shot. If NoS doesn't get shot tonight, that might be useful information tomorrow when we revisit his case. Though it's not a smoking gun.

[NoSurvivors]

Re AOG: I can confirm that the forum software kind of sucks. Sometimes I'll click for latest post and I'll miss like the last five because it brings me to the next page.

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

Claimed docs will often get shot. If NoS doesn't get shot tonight, that might be useful information tomorrow when we revisit his case. Though it's not a smoking gun.

Depends how experienced the mafia is lol.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

So basically what you are saying (Mets) is:

Hotshot or Streaker. Place your votes people, we have till tomorrow!

NoS can live one day, and if he survives we can kill him D2 Not that it is in anyway conclusive for him to still be alive D2.

fp'd by NoS

[Army of GOD]

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

Well, that's the thing. If he is a doc, and since it's only day 1 and any reads are lukewarm at best, I think he's going to protect himself.

Then you have the cat and mouse game of the mafia going "is he the doc? Should we test if he is? Will he protect himself? Maybe he thinks we think he'll protect himself and he's actually going to protect someone else" etc

But I have a hard time thinking a non vanilla game is doc-less. There might be more than one, but we don't really have the advantage at this point

[Metsfanmax]

So basically what you are saying (Mets) is:

Hotshot or Streaker. Place your votes people, we have till tomorrow!

NoS can live one day, and if he survives we can kill him D2 Not that it is in anyway conclusive for him to still be alive D2.

fp'd by NoS

What I am saying is that it's bad policy to lynch a claimed doc who isn't counter-claimed, and it's also bad policy to let them live forever without proving that they're a doc. There's no clear path out. However, I was never fond of the NoS case to begin with, so I recognize that other people will feel differently given his claim.

[HotShot53]

Well, that was a fast bandwagon... not good that the doc was revealed (I'll assume he's telling the truth at this point)

So IB, now that your one scum read turned out to not be scum, do you have reads on anyone else, either town or scum?

[rishaed]

Bets on TeeGee providing the Hammer?

Counter claims wont work as we could have no doc, five docs or just one.

Is a Doc who is known to be a Doc any use? This is the point when my experience lets me down. Surely he'll just get nightkilled before he can do anything useful?

Fp'd by NoS

So basically what you are saying (Mets) is:

Hotshot or Streaker. Place your votes people, we have till tomorrow!

NoS can live one day, and if he survives we can kill him D2 Not that it is in anyway conclusive for him to still be alive D2.

fp'd by NoS

Which cliff did you choose?
The highest, he admitted.
unvote vote WingCmdr Trigger happy on D1 Lynch. Understand you're new, but after those three quotes I say your scum especially after doc claim.
Why?
I figured that once you've decided to jump off a cliff, you might as well pick the highest one. Why accept the risk, if not for the greatest prize?

[Iron Butterfly]

Well, that was a fast bandwagon... not good that the doc was revealed (I'll assume he's telling the truth at this point)

So IB, now that your one scum read turned out to not be scum, do you have reads on anyone else, either town or scum?

Do you believe the pressure on NoS was unwarranted?

[mtamburini]

I'd still lynch him after his claim.

Reading on phone sucks I'll just say few tr right now cause battery is low.

I like wing virus stor and teegee.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Well, that was a fast bandwagon... not good that the doc was revealed (I'll assume he's telling the truth at this point)

So IB, now that your one scum read turned out to not be scum, do you have reads on anyone else, either town or scum?

Is he actually the doc?

Rishaed - Read the C9 Script I played. Confused Storr with comments of similar nature to those you've highlighted. Its sarcasm, but british sarcasm, so crisp no one notices.

Also, "Trigger happy on D1 Lynch. Understand you're new, but after those three quotes I say your scum especially after doc claim." that looks like an actual written comment to me. No idea what that means though.

[virus90]

i think NoS should be off limit for day 1 lynch, let mafia do it by night if they want to, sure someone can check NoS if they dont believe him.
unless counter claimed off course, but i think that wont happen
also the way that wagon formed so quick was suspicious to begin with, so i think NoS is probably telling the truth.

@ib
as for if the pressure was warranted, maybe pressure but from 0 to claim in 1 day.. that was highly strange, yes we are getting close to deadline but so many people so quick on 1 person? last time i looked hotshot was almost out, next time we get a claimed doc in NoS??

and i still stay with my vote

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

I prodded TeeGee. 3 players have their last post as yesterday, everyone else has posted today. Overall, the activity level is great. Thanks for that.

Tentative Deadline set for next Thursday.

Is this not tomorrow? Hence if no NoS lynch, then we need to bandwagon someone else even faster....

[rishaed]

Well, that was a fast bandwagon... not good that the doc was revealed (I'll assume he's telling the truth at this point)

So IB, now that your one scum read turned out to not be scum, do you have reads on anyone else, either town or scum?

Is he actually the doc? "I'll be bloody in the face if I know," Mat said back.
Lan would consider the ramifications of what was happening only after he knew all of the facts. Only then.

Rishaed - Read the C9 Script I played. Confused Storr with comments of similar nature to those you've highlighted. Its sarcasm, but british sarcasm, so crisp no one notices.
"Is that a good thing?" She whispered to him.

Also, "Trigger happy on D1 Lynch. Understand you're new, but after those three quotes I say your scum especially after doc claim." that looks like an actual written comment to me. No idea what that means though.

@Storr-See bold no color. "What he says. . . it is true?" I don't have time to go and analyze another game on top of this so I'll have to take it at others word for now.

[StorrZerg]

yeah I'll get to it in a few hours.

[NoSurvivors]

I'll be back in a day. Had an exam today-- now im flying back home. At the airport. Will catch up soon. Sorry, very busy day today.

Oh, and hotshot, you didnt defend me, someone said you soft defended me (that is why the "defended" was in quotation marks). When an entire town reads someone scum and you go with "neutral" then it looks strange. That is what I was referring to.

[Army of GOD]

rishaed is getting confusing and annoying now

[Metsfanmax]

rishaed is getting confusing and annoying now

I'm starting to become tickled by some of his quote choices. Maybe it won't be so bad to have him around.

[DoomYoshi]

I prodded TeeGee. 3 players have their last post as yesterday, everyone else has posted today. Overall, the activity level is great. Thanks for that.

Tentative Deadline set for next Thursday.

Is this not tomorrow? Hence if no NoS lynch, then we need to bandwagon someone else even faster....

I meant the following Thursday.

NoSurvivors, I am difficulty figuring out what happened with the edit. For the record, we need you to post what the post originally said. Consider this a warning to everyone in the game: next edit is modkill.

[Metsfanmax]

I don't remember the exact wording of the post, but I saw it before it was edited and I can confirm that NoS is telling the truth regarding its essential content.

[StorrZerg]

i think NoS should be off limit for day 1 lynch, let mafia do it by night if they want to, sure someone can check NoS if they dont believe him.
unless counter claimed off course, but i think that wont happen
also the way that wagon formed so quick was suspicious to begin with, so i think NoS is probably telling the truth.

@ib
as for if the pressure was warranted, maybe pressure but from 0 to claim in 1 day.. that was highly strange, yes we are getting close to deadline but so many people so quick on 1 person? last time i looked hotshot was almost out, next time we get a claimed doc in NoS??

and i still stay with my vote

i think the confusion of deadlines, impacted the speed of the claim. Since many of us thought the deadline was in a matter of days or less, vs having an extra week.

probably interesting the people that pushed on NoS but didnt push on hotshot imo.

[StorrZerg]

Well, that was a fast bandwagon... not good that the doc was revealed (I'll assume he's telling the truth at this point)

So IB, now that your one scum read turned out to not be scum, do you have reads on anyone else, either town or scum?

Is he actually the doc? "I'll be bloody in the face if I know," Mat said back.
Lan would consider the ramifications of what was happening only after he knew all of the facts. Only then.

Rishaed - Read the C9 Script I played. Confused Storr with comments of similar nature to those you've highlighted. Its sarcasm, but british sarcasm, so crisp no one notices.
"Is that a good thing?" She whispered to him.

Also, "Trigger happy on D1 Lynch. Understand you're new, but after those three quotes I say your scum especially after doc claim." that looks like an actual written comment to me. No idea what that means though.

@Storr-See bold no color. "What he says. . . it is true?" I don't have time to go and analyze another game on top of this so I'll have to take it at others word for now.

yeah idk what he is getting at. He needs to quote what he is talking about for me to make a better comment. I tend to be pretty oblivious in general to jokes/ sarcasm in general.