Sweeney Todd Mafia ~ Town Wins. Ready to be Archived

[Commander9]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

I would like to hear Haggis and Vioiet first, but an actor? Do you have anything else about your role?

[jonty125]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

I would like to hear Haggis and Vioiet first, but an actor? Do you have anything else about your role?

No.

[safariguy5]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

I would like to hear Haggis and Vioiet first, but an actor? Do you have anything else about your role?

No.

Huh, well ok, I guess it's about time for Vio and Hag to claim and we can decide who we want to lynch. Keeping in mind, of course that Lovett probably has a fakeclaim since Todd had Beadle. I'm still leaning Haggis townish, so I'd put more stock in his claim than Vio's, but I'm willing to hear both before making a decision.

[Commander9]

Huh, well ok, I guess it's about time for Vio and Hag to claim and we can decide who we want to lynch. Keeping in mind, of course that Lovett probably has a fakeclaim since Todd had Beadle. I'm still leaning Haggis townish, so I'd put more stock in his claim than Vio's, but I'm willing to hear both before making a decision.

Same here, but I have to say that this seems like a horrible, but definitely fake claim.

[safariguy5]

Huh, well ok, I guess it's about time for Vio and Hag to claim and we can decide who we want to lynch. Keeping in mind, of course that Lovett probably has a fakeclaim since Todd had Beadle. I'm still leaning Haggis townish, so I'd put more stock in his claim than Vio's, but I'm willing to hear both before making a decision.

Same here, but I have to say that this seems like a horrible, but definitely fake claim.

True, but there was no mention of a Royal Marine in the movie version (which I watched). I'm not going to discount the possibility of no name VT's, but I want to see if we can somehow explain why my investigation on Sax failed. I'm thinking jailkeeper as most likely, but I'm not sure.

[TheSaxlad]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

Actually youve been jumping on everyone else bandwagon...

[ShaggyDan]

Just a blanket posts to my mafia games. I'm really swamped with work at the moment, and am unable to do much else than jump on and quickly take my turns. This will probably be the case for the next 3 days or so. Sorry for my lack of activity over the last few days, and over the coming few days. I shall try to make it up to you with as much meat in my posts as possible.

[jonty125]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

Actually youve been jumping on everyone else bandwagon...

Whenever saf drew up a flavour spec I was always trying to bring up their could be VTs.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote Count

saxlad (3) - haggis, jonty, vio
jonty (2) - saxlad, saf


8 alive, 5 to lynch

[safariguy5]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

Actually youve been jumping on everyone else bandwagon...

Whenever saf drew up a flavour spec I was always trying to bring up their could be VTs.

You're trying to use the Haggis defense here, where were you when Haggis convinced me that there might be VT non named roles on Day 2?

Still, a claim from Vio would help greatly.

[jonty125]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

Actually youve been jumping on everyone else bandwagon...

Whenever saf drew up a flavour spec I was always trying to bring up their could be VTs.

You're trying to use the Haggis defense here, where were you when Haggis convinced me that there might be VT non named roles on Day 2?

Still, a claim from Vio would help greatly.

This game will be fairly straightforward with pretty simple roles (there will be a few VTs)

Nobody has considered that someone or some people could be an 'extra' and just be a plain VT

I quoted this on D1

[safariguy5]

I claim Actor (Vanilla Townie)

I have being trying to metion about VT's throughout the game, that just leaves Vio and Hag

Actually youve been jumping on everyone else bandwagon...

Whenever saf drew up a flavour spec I was always trying to bring up their could be VTs.

You're trying to use the Haggis defense here, where were you when Haggis convinced me that there might be VT non named roles on Day 2?

Still, a claim from Vio would help greatly.

This game will be fairly straightforward with pretty simple roles (there will be a few VTs)

Nobody has considered that someone or some people could be an 'extra' and just be a plain VT

I quoted this on D1

Ok, not saying you're not a VT, but VT tends to be a quite popular claim for scum.

That said, I get the rather strong feeling that Haggis might be another VT, and you've at least given us some evidence that you are VT.

unvote vote Vio for her silence is quite scummy.

[VioIet]

I already subtly claimed earlier, but I guess everyone missed it.

I am a London Priest.

[safariguy5]

I already subtly claimed earlier, but I guess everyone missed it.

I am a London Priest.

Hmm...Priest, assuming that's a VT role.

Well ok, let's look at the claims so far. Actor or Priest. And Haggis, but like I said, he's probably been more townie than either of jonty or Vio.

Here's why I believe Vio's claim over jonty's.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsQRZ4TsljI

[safariguy5]

Oh yeah, I forgot, unvote vote jonty

[Commander9]

Guys... Lets hear Haggis claim first.

[safariguy5]

Guys... Lets hear Haggis claim first.

Alright, but I'm just putting out there who I think is more scummy as of right now. I might not survive the night, so I'm trying to lay it out.

[TheSaxlad]

I shall try to make it up to you with as much meat in my pies as possible.

Hey I think I found the scum.

[safariguy5]

I shall try to make it up to you with as much meat in my pies as possible.

Hey I think I found the scum.

He also claimed Pirelli, which means that if you don't believe him, then you're lying about Toby's ability, and we should kil you now...

I guess we might as have Haggis claim, but jonty is the most suspicious one to me right now.

[TheSaxlad]

I shall try to make it up to you with as much meat in my pies as possible.

Hey I think I found the scum.

He also claimed Pirelli, which means that if you don't believe him, then you're lying about Toby's ability, and we should kil you now...

I guess we might as have Haggis claim, but jonty is the most suspicious one to me right now.

IT WAS A JOKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[TheSaxlad]

ebwop

[Haggis_McMutton]

Fuckin' island and it's fuckin' volcanoes did it again. Sorry for the inactivity guys, but I had a really shitty last couple of days outrunning the ash cloud and am operating on no sleep atm.

Anyway, a claim I can do. I'm a Lawyer, VT.
Any more input will have to wait till tomorrow.

[jonty125]

I already subtly claimed earlier, but I guess everyone missed it.

I am a London Priest.

Hmm...Priest, assuming that's a VT role.

Priest can also be a role which means you cannot have the last vote on a lynch (the hammer)

[safariguy5]

Fuckin' island and it's fuckin' volcanoes did it again. Sorry for the inactivity guys, but I had a really shitty last couple of days outrunning the ash cloud and am operating on no sleep atm.

Anyway, a claim I can do. I'm a Lawyer, VT.
Any more input will have to wait till tomorrow.

Ok, well when we're talking about that little musical number there. Let's look at who's mentioned in order.

There's Priest, Poet, Lawyer, Royal Marine, Squire, Vicar, Fop, Shepard, Politician, Friar, Actor.

Now, the Actor is a one liner. Priest is mentioned several times, and Lawyer is the third. We already had the Royal Marine.

Hmm...like I said, Haggis's actions clear him in my point of view. We still don't have an explanation for why my investigation failed last night.

There is one last line of investigation we can try. That is of course, the lovers. Naxus claimed Anthony, and all Com9 did was to say he confirmed that. Naxus himself never said Com9 was his lover and Com9 never said he was Johanna. That's definitely something to consider.

For now though, I think jonty is the best case partly because of his actions and partly because his character is mentioned offhand and never shown as an actual person or extra in the background.

unvote vote jonty

[Commander9]

In case it is really hard for people to read between the lines, I can confirm that I am Johanna.