DaGip wrote:Well, I would have to say that you are not living your life any different morally, because your very essence of existing in America engrained your behaviours to reflect Christianized values and morals.
So to say that Christianity is useless, is not really giving it due credit.
What if America was established by Anton LeVay? And the Satanic Bible was what people adhered to for two hundred some years? Then how would you behave, think, and act? I think you would behave a bit differently.
Whether or not we believe in the Bible or the specific tenents of any particular Christianized faith, we are still emersed by Western Christianized thoughts. That is why (in my opinion) you act no differently morally as a nonChristian as opposed to if you were still practicing Christianity.
Just a thought. Christian teachings (do unto others...,love your enemy..., give to the poor...) need a little credit for how most of us westernized people behave. I don't mind reading the Bible every once in a while, as I like what Jesus says in the New Testament, and it actually makes sense. So even though I do not think of myself as a Christian, I still practice what Jesus says in the Bible. Just as I practice what Buddha had said in his teachings.
I grew up in Christianity, and then when I went to Hawaii for a few months, I was introduce to the teaching of Buddha in the libraries there. I would read those books everyday, along with my Bible I carried with me...and you know what?
Buddha said the EXACT same things, almost entirely verbatim! And Buddha existed 500 years before Jesus! So this tells me something!
Jesus acquired his teachings from the same source as Buddha, or he actually studied Buddhism and brought it to Israel.
But I just wanted you to know that because you are an atheist doesn't mean that you all of a sudden turn into a murderous asshole. You still cling on to teachings of the Christians even if you don't realize it. And that is a good thing!
Sure, there has been an influence, and I'm glad for some of it. However, my parents brought me up with the idea that I should "do unto others" etc. based on empathy and reason moreso than any particular religious affiliation. I would suggest that there are worldviews that impart the more noble ideals of religions without the negative outcomes that can come out of them. You beat me to the point that Christ was not necessarily an original thinker, but he was definitely a good guy, and worth emulating in many respects.
In all honesty, I think it's mildly pessimistic to imply that our morality might be different based on the religious background of our upbringing. I have conserved some views that I had picked up from my Christian upbringing (after much reevaluation of said views) and I have rejected as many, if not more. I wouldn't say that Christianity has had a positive impact on my life as the views that I retained could have been picked up from umpteen other sources, including my own rational thought. This doesn't make me any more or less moral than anyone else, I'll admit, but (tries to phrase next statement in an honest, yet unoffensive manner) I like to think it's based on a more reliable source.