Periodic Table Mafia: Nonmetals (TOWN) win

[vodean]

I know I'm a tad late on this, but I want to formally apologize to jonty for casting undue suspicion on him - I hadn't read the Vacation Thread.

That's all for now.

Hey no probs.

Oh and for those who are clueless about betiko's colours the orange are noble gases. And I don't think we should assume noble gases are cleared townies.

Agreed. That would unbalance the setup if it were true.

i believe that most of the noble gases are telling the truth, but i think one is lying. then one other claim is lying, depending on /'s claim

[safariguy5]

I'll be honest, if Noble Gas is a good fakeclaim, it logically would be given to the GF. He being the strongest mafia role would logically get the strongest mafia fakeclaim.

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

[betiko]

I'll be honest, if Noble Gas is a good fakeclaim, it logically would be given to the GF. He being the strongest mafia role would logically get the strongest mafia fakeclaim.

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

lol defensive? and you're the one that claimed out of the blue if you remember.. So what you are saying basically is that sam did a setting where only nameclaiming would make us clear completely half of the players and that we should trust all noble gases blindly?

we pobably have 2 anti town left, and I would say at least 1 has a noble gas fakeclaim...

other than this, what's up with /? would like to know if he claims P or H. and would also want him to post the day scene in lovecraft mafia lol!

[sempaispellcheck]

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

So did NoS.

At any rate, it's interesting to note that no one has claimed to be a halogen - any halogen - even though the halogens are also nonmetals. Flourine may be in here as an SK (giving us another potential fakeclaim), but I find it surprising that no one would claim chlorine or bromine.

[betiko]

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

So did NoS.

At any rate, it's interesting to note that no one has claimed to be a halogen - any halogen - even though the halogens are also nonmetals. Flourine may be in here as an SK (giving us another potential fakeclaim), but I find it surprising that no one would claim chlorine or bromine.

if someone did so, he'd be the first one we'd all point our finger at. sam went for fakeclaim that wouldn't stand out that much.

[DoomYoshi]

Saf, the mafia still have night talk. A fakeclaim to one is a fakeclaim to all.

[betiko]

Saf, the mafia still have night talk. A fakeclaim to one is a fakeclaim to all.

true! didn't think of it either. I guess we can't speculate on that anymore then. it was kind of the only conclusion I made out of those nameclaims...

[sempaispellcheck]

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

So did NoS.

At any rate, it's interesting to note that no one has claimed to be a halogen - any halogen - even though the halogens are also nonmetals. Flourine may be in here as an SK (giving us another potential fakeclaim), but I find it surprising that no one would claim chlorine or bromine.

if someone did so, he'd be the first one we'd all point our finger at. sam went for fakeclaim that wouldn't stand out that much.

Actually, I misspoke. I should have said "be" instead of "claim."
The fact that sam gave NoS selenium, a non-noble gas fairly far down on the table, but didn't give anyone a halogen like chlorine is what surprises me.

[betiko]

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

So did NoS.

At any rate, it's interesting to note that no one has claimed to be a halogen - any halogen - even though the halogens are also nonmetals. Flourine may be in here as an SK (giving us another potential fakeclaim), but I find it surprising that no one would claim chlorine or bromine.

if someone did so, he'd be the first one we'd all point our finger at. sam went for fakeclaim that wouldn't stand out that much.

Actually, I misspoke. I should have said "be" instead of "claim."
The fact that sam gave NoS selenium, a non-noble gas fairly far down on the table, but didn't give anyone a halogen like chlorine is what surprises me.

well to me it all makes sense. he used green and orange elements from the op periodic tabe for town names + anti town fakeclaims and purple for anti town real names.

[NoSurvivors]

I'd just like to point out that betiko casts doubt on the Noble Gases being VT theory partly because he's not a noble gas but claiming VT. Definitely not coincidence IMHO.

So did NoS.

At any rate, it's interesting to note that no one has claimed to be a halogen - any halogen - even though the halogens are also nonmetals. Flourine may be in here as an SK (giving us another potential fakeclaim), but I find it surprising that no one would claim chlorine or bromine.

if someone did so, he'd be the first one we'd all point our finger at. sam went for fakeclaim that wouldn't stand out that much.

Actually, I misspoke. I should have said "be" instead of "claim."
The fact that sam gave NoS selenium, a non-noble gas fairly far down on the table, but didn't give anyone a halogen like chlorine is what surprises me.

I do have to agree with you.. I'm not sure why there aren't any halides either.. :l

[samgrossy]

Vote Count, Day 2.8

Betiko - (1) Vodean, L-6
thehippo8 - (1) Betiko L-6
Gillipig - (5) sempaispellcheck, DoomYoshi, Jonty125, Dukasaur, safariguy5 L-2

Not Voting - (5) NoSurvivors, Gillipig, thechuck51, /, thehippo8,

To make gameplay easier for players, the player(s) closest to lynch at the time of vote count will be in red bold

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline for Day 2 is 10 PM EST, October 25th. That's 2 days from now.

[vodean]

can we get a prod on / to remind him he's in here? hes probably busy with lovecraft, but if he could just take a minute...

[betiko]

can we get a prod on / to remind him he's in here? hes probably busy with lovecraft, but if he could just take a minute...

he wrote on lovecraft a couple of hours ago!

[/]

Sorry, I was making a big post on Angels and demons, I'm phosphorus

[sempaispellcheck]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

[NoSurvivors]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

[vodean]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

FOS NoS. just because he is last doesnt mean he is fake-claiming.

[betiko]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

i'm sure the last fakeclaim was hydrogen anyway, weather it was iron butterfly's fakeclaim or the goon's and that this guy decided to trade with is or not.

[NoSurvivors]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

FOS NoS. just because he is last doesnt mean he is fake-claiming.

Um.. vode.. that wasnt directed at /... maybe i should have put a "there could have been".. my bad.. calm down there bubb lol

[vodean]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

FOS NoS. just because he is last doesnt mean he is fake-claiming.

Um.. vode.. that wasnt directed at /... maybe i should have put a "there could have been".. my bad.. calm down there bubb lol

i wasnt sure so i FOSed, but i thought it needed answering.

[jonty125]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

i'm sure the last fakeclaim was hydrogen anyway, weather it was iron butterfly's fakeclaim or the goon's and that this guy decided to trade with is or not.

Hmm, FOS betiko. Only scum would know what the fakeclaims are, it could very well be someone had a halogen.

[vodean]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

i'm sure the last fakeclaim was hydrogen anyway, weather it was iron butterfly's fakeclaim or the goon's and that this guy decided to trade with is or not.

Hmm, FOS betiko. Only scum would know what the fakeclaims are, it could very well be someone had a halogen.

i picked up on the same thing

[betiko]

I'm phosphorus

So, I guess the metals convinced hydrogen not to get involved. Good to know.

As far as we know.. could be a fakeclaim..

i'm sure the last fakeclaim was hydrogen anyway, weather it was iron butterfly's fakeclaim or the goon's and that this guy decided to trade with is or not.

Hmm, FOS betiko. Only scum would know what the fakeclaims are, it could very well be someone had a halogen.

That s stupid. So if there was a halogen all by himself wouldn t it be suspicious? I d definitely vote for him as as far as i know fluorine is a halogen.

[jonty125]

So with fulorine been a halogen, then if someone was bromine, what would you expect their alignment?

[betiko]

So with fulorine been a halogen, then if someone was bromine, what would you expect their alignment?

why, did you fake nameclaim jonty?