Conquer Club

kalishnikov wrote:

jnd94 wrote:Aye. vote kalish I confirmed him as town.....skimmer!

I don't remember that happening. No, it wasn't from skimming, it was from this day lasting for like 2 weeks now or something.

I'll go re-read, when I find it I'll unvote.

I guess it was kind of easy to miss. I mean, first there was I saying 'Jnd, would you please confirm that I am pro-town' and then ther was Jnd saying 'Yes, Mandalorian realy is pro-town'.

C'mon people, stop lynching innocents just to spite me!

I finally read that all. Ok, in my opinion I think that Koesen is town. I don't think his actions are scummy and that some people *cough*jnd*cough* were acting a bit dumb. I don't know why he didn't reveal that he had 2 lives a while ago. I can also confirm that jnd does have 2 lives.
As for Kalish, I'm not sure if what he did was that scummy. Maybe not the best thing to do, but maybe he skimmed. I trust Jnd and so I'm pretty sure about Mandy, so probably Kalish is scum or skimmed, but I still think he need more to see if he's deserving of a lynch. Though I think his reaction would be the best way. Vote: Kalish

wicked wrote:How do we know that anything is confirmed? I don't remember exactly, was JND told by the game mod himself that Mandy was indeed town? Just b/c Mandy visited JND doesn't automatically confirm him as town. Yes I know Mandy claimed if he visited the wrong person, he'd die.... but 1. he could be lying, and 2. he could be/mean a cult leader. Or another option could be both Mandy and JND are town, but I highly doubt that.

So anyway, I definitely think there's less chance those two are scum, but nothings confirmed.

1. Jnd has recieved my role's name. It's something like a Mason Recruiter, but without Night-talking.

2. As for the Cult all that I can tell you that it doesn't seem to fit into the theme + I usually don't like to put all of my eggs in one basket.

I'm not sure what to do at this point. There's nobody who appears really scummy at this point, although some people haven't been all they could be.

Jumping the Kalishnikov bandwagon is tempting just to get the day over with and see what evidence can be collected tonight, but other than the fact that he seems to be so nice he just might be evil, I have no real suspicions against him.

I'm not sure if I should ask this, but Fircoal, how do you know about jnd's lives?

I re-read and found mando's 'confirmation' so unvote I guess for the time being.

Oh and it's not skimming when it happened so long ago that you forgot about it, I like to call that forgetting, myself. It's easy to call someone a skimmer when you sit down and read the whole thread as opposed to being part of the longest day ever from the beginning.

Again, I'll point out I'm willing to be the martyr should you guys wanna get this day over with, but I'm town so my lynch isn't gonna get you much in the way of info. I'll give you my role before-hand if you like.

So, Mandy, that electricity lady you mentioned... is there any way she will turn out to be good for town, if she's in the game?

Koesen wrote:So, Mandy, that electricity lady you mentioned... is there any way she will turn out to be good for town, if she's in the game?

I really don't know. The stuff on Wikipedia is inconclusive and I never saw the show. But, I think that I found and alternative theory to 'Super-Syler'. Maybe the 'Company' are Mafia and Syler is a SK?

Seriously, could someone who actualy watched the show AND isn't part of Mafia (sorry Kalish, but that kind of excludes you ) add something to the discussion?

Ah, I thought you knew the show.

Didn't Kwanton suggest something similar about the company, whatever that is?

mandalorian2298 wrote:

Koesen wrote:So, Mandy, that electricity lady you mentioned... is there any way she will turn out to be good for town, if she's in the game?

I really don't know. The stuff on Wikipedia is inconclusive and I never saw the show. But, I think that I found and alternative theory to 'Super-Syler'. Maybe the 'Company' are Mafia and Syler is a SK?

Seriously, could someone who actualy watched the show AND isn't part of Mafia (sorry Kalish, but that kind of excludes you ) add something to the discussion?

Seriously. I said that exact same thing a few pages ago....

kwanton wrote:
Just to put out an alternate view on things:

Sylar is not mafia but an overpowered SK and the mafia is actually the company. Any thoughts on this?

So. Let's go wild and assume there is some substance to this theory.

What would be things for me to look out for when I absorb people's abilities? I assume 'the company' has superpowers too?

Koesen wrote:So. Let's go wild and assume there is some substance to this theory.

What would be things for me to look out for when I absorb people's abilities? I assume 'the company' has superpowers too?

Only some members of the company have superpowers. I'm assuming that there are ordinary people in this game too. Ordinary in the sense that they have no powers in the show but they may have regular mafia-game powers.

The only reason I would doubt the company as mafia game is that there aren't that many players. A single overpowered Sk with a follower maybe would make more sense based on the plot of the show.

I also want to know what LSU is. I don't think that he would be the electrical woman as that was pretty recently in season two and I just assumed this was season one or there would be more players.

Is there anything in Season One that could explain a late arrival?

Not that i can think of off the top of my head. But I can't think of one from season two either. Then again I haven't watched the whole of either.

Maybe LSU just really wanted to play and forced our mod to make an extra role

Koesen wrote: I'm not sure if I should ask this, but Fircoal, how do you know about jnd's lives?

I don't know if I should say it. But for now, I'll just tell you this. I'm an idiot. I played Day 1 terribly.

So that doesn't lead to anything either for now.

Any ideas? I feel the Kalishnikov bandwagon is not convincing. We might get lucky, but if we don't, I doubt we'll learn much from it.

Fircoal wrote:

Koesen wrote: I'm not sure if I should ask this, but Fircoal, how do you know about jnd's lives?

I don't know if I should say it. But for now, I'll just tell you this. I'm an idiot. I played Day 1 terribly.

Interesting comment. If slightly mystifying

This makes me want to vote fircoal.....

If we keep this up, that mass roleclaim will happen after all

The reason I asked Fircoal how he knew about jnd's two lives, in case it isn't blatantly obvious, is that Sylar probably would have gotten the exact same information as me.

There are probably other explanations too, so I don't want to jump to conclusions, but that's what I was thinking.

Vote Count:

Koesen (1) Exile
Kwan (1) Wicked
Exile (1) Mandy
Freezie (1) LSU
Kalish (3) Jnd, Fircoal, Secret
6 to lynch.

hrm....that is very odd, indeed.

The1exile wrote: I can only post like once a day.

I am going back to Voting Exile, because this is clearly not true. Exile has been fairly active in other threads today, such as his own, but he has hardly contributed anything here.

Koesen wrote:

Fircoal wrote:

Koesen wrote: I'm not sure if I should ask this, but Fircoal, how do you know about jnd's lives?

I don't know if I should say it. But for now, I'll just tell you this. I'm an idiot. I played Day 1 terribly.

Interesting comment. If slightly mystifying

I'll say it if enough people want me too, but for now I'd rather keep quiet.

Fircoal wrote:

Koesen wrote:

Fircoal wrote:

Koesen wrote: I'm not sure if I should ask this, but Fircoal, how do you know about jnd's lives?

I don't know if I should say it. But for now, I'll just tell you this. I'm an idiot. I played Day 1 terribly.

Interesting comment. If slightly mystifying

I'll say it if enough people want me too, but for now I'd rather keep quiet.

Well yeah, I would like to know.

Unvote Vote Fircoal as I'm also curious as to how he just came to the conclusion that he had evidence that JND had 2 lives.

in regards to why i'm playing, i had reserved a spot a while back via pm and sent a reminder about it and was told to start typing day 2.