The Thing - Mafia Style [Winner=The Thing]

[F1fth]

On one hand, I don't like that he just plainly voted for William.

On the other hand, we kinda already know what ace is, and I think the reason he voted was for the reasoning I posted.

Still, what do you think of Ol' Willy, spiesr?

[william18]

Knee-jerk response???? Hehe and just from the person i'd expect protecting Ga7. Anyway we seem to be worring about what if the doc is assimilated, but what about the rogue? Ace's action have been more then unacceptable. I'll let you people think about that.

[spiesr]

Personally I think william is a frustrated townie trying to do what he sees as necessary to get the thing and is getting caught up in the argument and losing his cool...

[/]

Knee-jerk response???? Hehe and just from the person i'd expect protecting Ga7. Anyway we seem to be worring about what if the doc is assimilated, but what about the rogue? Ace's action have been more then unacceptable. I'll let you people think about that.

If ace is/was the rouge, it is impossible he is a thing, yet, since ace would have used his rouge powers on night two, which he could have only used if he had not been assimilated, the following night, the only time when ace could have been assimilated, PMC died from failed assimilation.
Worrying about getting rid of power roles?

[ga7]

Vote William I also thought he could be a moronic townie but throwing accusations around on the only cleared people is going a bit too far on that role; I feel he's digging his own scummy grave.

[william18]

Knee-jerk response???? Hehe and just from the person i'd expect protecting Ga7. Anyway we seem to be worring about what if the doc is assimilated, but what about the rogue? Ace's action have been more then unacceptable. I'll let you people think about that.

If ace is/was the rouge, it is impossible he is a thing, yet, since ace would have used his rouge powers on night two, which he could have only used if he had not been assimilated, the following night, the only time when ace could have been assimilated, PMC died from failed assimilation.
Worrying about getting rid of power roles?

Ok well that clears ace.

Vote William I also thought he could be a moronic townie but throwing accusations around on the only cleared people is going a bit too far on that role; I feel he's digging his own scummy grave.

I was only making a statement. A theory if you will. Plus you never said what exactly my knee-jerk response was . You people are vote me for nothing? Look how that got you with skoffin and switchblade. Hopefully you people have a mind of your own, or are you gonna whole-heartedly follow ga7 like before??? I still believe that either Stroop, F1fth are good lynch prospects since we have the most evidence against them. Unvote

[ga7]

Then why was your vote on me? That's the thing, you looked like you supported those leads but was doing something else instead. I don't buy it anymore...

[Stroop]

I still believe that either Stroop, F1fth are good lynch prospects since we have the most evidence against them. Unvote

So why did you vote ga7?

[william18]

I still believe that either Stroop, F1fth are good lynch prospects since we have the most evidence against them. Unvote

So why did you vote ga7?

He was a good prospect at the time, until he explianed himself.

[spiesr]

William, you are on thin ice so you better watch yourself...

[ace1217]

William, you are on thin ice so you better watch yourself...

...Why are you trying to warn william? If william turns out scum, I'm fairly sure you'll be dead by the time tomorrow ends.

[spiesr]

It wasn't a warning in the sense that I was trying to protect a scum mate, but a warning in the sense that I was informing him of my opinion of his circumstances...

[ga7]

Don't think the "warning" means much... I mean, who remotely good would try to warn their scumbuddy like that? Meanwhile my vote stays on Will for major inconsistencies, backtracking, trying to nail cleared townies, etc. Stroop does leave me a bit of a scummy taste in the mouth but it's a bit less solid for me.

[william18]

So if the thing fails an assimilation, the target just dies??

If you read the first post, you would have known that.

Opps nvm, I thought the thing choose either assimilate or kill.

Fake skimming much? If you are town, I'd have expected you to think for a minute why would the thing prefer to kill than assimilate if it worked like that. Instead we have this incredibly silly statement after days of discussion on how the thing works. Seriously?

But let's reread. We find this day 3:

Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.

1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.

The odds are on number 1.

Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*

I assumed that since the rogue killed that night, the thing recruited, or just failed at whatever it chose to do.

The think killed pmchugh, so logically the thing must be...

Well Ga7 could, since he and pmchugh didn't really see eye to eye. Think about it, Ga7 could be assimilated. We have no proof that a doctor protected him.

We have a doc out there that could prove that. You'd like to know, wouldn't you?

Im just pointing out the fact that you can never be to sure.

Perhaps the Thing just basically failed. But here are the scenerio's.

1) The Thing recruited another person
2) The Thing did not succeed at killing or assimilating.

The odds are on number 1.

Oh wait, that means you do know how things work. Or rather, how the thing works. *wide grin*


Since the rouge killed(or so I believed) I assumed the thing chose to recruit.

EBWOP

(read how I said or)

Vote Ga7 for trying to focus on me and divert attention.

Did you just skim my post or did I strike a nerve? Which one is it uh?
This is a detail, but your way of explaining that is far less clear. What about the rest of my post? Do you have any viable arguments besides "oh I NO! the doc is a moron that doesn't want to come out and is waiting to be NKed instead of outing him as scum!!1!"?

I assume you didn't read the quote. Read the bolded part since I think you didn't and assumed my defence on the matter was just a triviality. Thus making me look scummy.(yes I botched it up)

Vote William I also thought he could be a moronic townie but throwing accusations around on the only cleared people is going a bit too far on that role; I feel he's digging his own scummy grave.

I just said it is a speculation. I never voted or FOSed, just putting the possibility out there until / informed me it's not possible.

Don't think the "warning" means much... I mean, who remotely good would try to warn their scumbuddy like that? Meanwhile my vote stays on Will for major inconsistencies, backtracking, trying to nail cleared townies, etc. Stroop does leave me a bit of a scummy taste in the mouth but it's a bit less solid for me.

I just provided a explanation to make that evidence and your case, nothing. Are you going to vote me for nothing??

[spiesr]

William is frantically defending himself. Does this mean is he is thing? It could go either way as he would probably defend himself the same no matter which side he was on.

[animorpherv1]

William is frantically defending himself. Does this mean is he is thing? It could go either way as he would probably defend himself the same no matter which side he was on.

I'm truely confused. I'm not sure if he is or isn't at this point.

[F1fth]

At the moment I get the feeling that William is town. While his defense has been rather loose and reaching, it seems more to me like the case a frustrated townie would put up and not a scummer. A few things he has said have also seemed like they were coming from a townie's perspective.

But still, he has made accusations of the most cleared players we have. That's the one thing about his actions that bother me, so having said that I would have no problem pursuing this avenue should a little more evidence present itself or the deadline draws closer and we don't have another viable alternative.

Also, I know it's the holidays so people are probably still busy, but in a few days can you give a friendly prod to the couple of people who haven't posted in a while: sam, cena, PCM, etc.

[spiesr]

I thought a deadline was posted, but I don't see one...

[Natewolfman]

I thought a deadline was posted, but I don't see one...

on Dec 26th I placed a 2 week deadline, which would be...

January 9th Deadline

[spiesr]

Silly me...

[william18]

Looks like people thought my little speculation on ace was more then just a pondering thought .

[spiesr]

Game is stagnant. Vote william for pressure to force actions.

[animorpherv1]

I'm going to have to say votee:william Because you are our biggest lead.

[william18]

I'm going to have to say votee:william Because you are our biggest lead.

Please explain to me what I did? I pretty much explained everything I needed to.

[animorpherv1]

I'm going to have to say votee:william Because you are our biggest lead.

Please explain to me what I did? I pretty much explained everything I needed to.

For some reason, you still look scummy to me. I don't know why , but you do.