Soundman's First Mafia [End] Arsonist Wins!!

[zimmah]

squirrel had like 4 posts right? so maybe he does too. but either way, if you get silenced like that, you shouldn't waste your posts.

[soundman]

Sorry guys, my fault. Not counting his 2nd post, because he wouldn't have said that if he'd known, and his 3rd, because he would have included that in his first.

[Rodion]

2) I think you need a stronger case against Rodion in order to vote him. The evidence you gave MIGHT be enough for a FOS.

It isn't. Maximum was a claimed vanilla townie. He didn't have any "inside scoop" of the game, like a cop or a watcher would have.

What Milkshake portrayed as "me going heavy against Max" was merely a reality check that as a claimed (and up until that point unconfirmed) VT he should not deserve doctor protection (the doctor should target other people to actually have odds of a town power role being protected). He based his deserving of a protection in being the most logical player and other shit like that and I showed him that his premise was flawed. It was in fact so flawed that the self-acclaimed logical player was part of the stupid bandwagon that lynched a claimed doctor (one of the biggest mafia mistakes I've ever seen).

That considered, I don't see how Maximum dying implicates me as mafia.

In the absence of a cop claiming a guilty, I'd suggest us to look for scum in Teegee's bandwagon.

[chapcrap]

2) I think you need a stronger case against Rodion in order to vote him. The evidence you gave MIGHT be enough for a FOS.

It isn't. Maximum was a claimed vanilla townie. He didn't have any "inside scoop" of the game, like a cop or a watcher would have.

What Milkshake portrayed as "me going heavy against Max" was merely a reality check that as a claimed (and up until that point unconfirmed) VT he should not deserve doctor protection (the doctor should target other people to actually have odds of a town power role being protected). He based his deserving of a protection in being the most logical player and other shit like that and I showed him that his premise was flawed. It was in fact so flawed that the self-acclaimed logical player was part of the stupid bandwagon that lynched a claimed doctor (one of the biggest mafia mistakes I've ever seen).

That considered, I don't see how Maximum dying implicates me as mafia.

In the absence of a cop claiming a guilty, I'd suggest us to look for scum in Teegee's bandwagon.

To be honest, I didn't spend the time I should have looking at TeeGee yesterday. I should never have voted TeeGee with his claiming doctor. I don't know what I was thinking. Probably just in too many mafia games at once and got squeezed for time in RL.

Anyway, I think that looking at people who pushed for TeeGee to be lynched is a good start, but also people who sat back, said nothing, and just let it happen. I don't remember seeing anyone arguing against lynching the doc, which is what I would have done if my head would have been on straight.

[thehippo8]

2) I think you need a stronger case against Rodion in order to vote him. The evidence you gave MIGHT be enough for a FOS.

It isn't. Maximum was a claimed vanilla townie. He didn't have any "inside scoop" of the game, like a cop or a watcher would have.

What Milkshake portrayed as "me going heavy against Max" was merely a reality check that as a claimed (and up until that point unconfirmed) VT he should not deserve doctor protection (the doctor should target other people to actually have odds of a town power role being protected). He based his deserving of a protection in being the most logical player and other shit like that and I showed him that his premise was flawed. It was in fact so flawed that the self-acclaimed logical player was part of the stupid bandwagon that lynched a claimed doctor (one of the biggest mafia mistakes I've ever seen).

That considered, I don't see how Maximum dying implicates me as mafia.

In the absence of a cop claiming a guilty, I'd suggest us to look for scum in Teegee's bandwagon.

To be honest, I didn't spend the time I should have looking at TeeGee yesterday. I should never have voted TeeGee with his claiming doctor. I don't know what I was thinking. Probably just in too many mafia games at once and got squeezed for time in RL.

Anyway, I think that looking at people who pushed for TeeGee to be lynched is a good start, but also people who sat back, said nothing, and just let it happen. I don't remember seeing anyone arguing against lynching the doc, which is what I would have done if my head would have been on straight.

As one who had the boot on TeeGee's throat, I am definitely upset to see how wrong I was. Frustrating isn't half the word for it but disappointed and annoyed at myself gets close. The annoying thing for me was that I never got a chance to withdraw my vote in time, albeit that I did withdraw it. I feel for you Chap!

I also didn't believe that Max would be on the chopping block and at the time I saw that his comments could have gone either way. But revealed as VT in more ways than one is doubly frustrating for me too.

As to the suggestion of a case against Rodion, maybe I'm just getting shy but I am not convinced and find myself agreeing with General here.

I've said it before and no doubt I'll say it again. But USAir ... where are you? Time to say something or I'm going to start going for you again.

[zimmah]

well, i just didn't understand hippo's clue soon enough, if i released sooner, i'd have known better then to vote teegee. however what has been done cannot be undone, let's see if we can find anything suspicious from the past few days and nights.

[thehippo8]

For the next two weeks I'm going to be away and pretty much uncontactable. I hope that isn't a problem, if it is then I am sorry. I've said what I've needed to say which should see us through until the night, I doubt tomorrow will run quickly so I hope to squeek back in with assistance next day. Have a good Christmas and New Year everyone.

[TheGeneral2112]

For the next two weeks I'm going to be away and pretty much uncontactable. I hope that isn't a problem, if it is then I am sorry. I've said what I've needed to say which should see us through until the night, I doubt tomorrow will run quickly so I hope to squeek back in with assistance next day. Have a good Christmas and New Year everyone.

Merry Christmas, I think we are all a bit occupied ATM with the holidays.

[TeeGee]

wow, way too quiet, it's like somebody died here.


oh that's right, I did


Have a great christmas, or whatever it is you celebrate

/me returns to the grave which I popped out of

[maximumbandit]

::pulls blankets off TeeGee:: "Quit hogging the covers!

[soundman]

So now that Christmas is over I'm hoping we get some activity. Because of the inactivity due to the holidays I'm going to extend the deadline a week from today. That's Monday Jan. 2nd.

[chapcrap]

I am going to have to review things. I'm still ticked that the doctor got lynched.

[MoB Deadly]

I am here but I am not sure who to pursue

[maximumbandit]

::voice from beyond the grave::

So uhh... who had fun on January 2nd? Yeah? Yeah? Good day, wasn't it. Good deadline day. And I love being dead on deadline days.

[soundman]

Codierose is replacing Shieldgenerator7.

[thehippo8]

Sporadic internet for the next week before I get home on Saturday next week (that's Friday for the rest of thed world as I am a time traveller from the other side of the date-line!)

I've caught up ... lol ... there is heaps of activity in other mafia games ... hello ... hello ... hello ... ??

Anyway, next chance I get to think about things I'll consider where to from here.

[codierose]

i confirm
hey guys sorry to say im a newbeeeee to but have just spent 4 hours reading everything so far
so after screeming at you lynchers for killing your doc
there seems to be a couple that stands out so far and a couple that have not had any involment also will not say who as yet but they have already been mentioned will be back soon after some clarifications more reading

[codierose]

would like to add that i know who i would like to vote for but would like some involement from the non active first
also the fact that the DOC did not protect the watcher but decided to protect another could have been for good reason there are other power roles i think that are just important if not more so hey but what do i know im a noob

[codierose]

ok my vote usAir

[MoB Deadly]

ok my vote usAir

care to explain why?

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Mr. Squirrel -
Codierose -
Chapcrap -
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir - codierose - (L5)
thehippo8 -
TheGeneral2112 -

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline: Monday, Jan. 9th

If activity really picks up then I'm willing to extend the deadline.

[codierose]

ok my vote usAir

care to explain why?

firstly i will say that my FOS is not 100% at him.
i will say the 1 reason voting for usair is his complete inactiveness so far imo very scummy i wanted to see who would challenge the post and if usair would come out from under his rock. The fact you posted first is noted

[chapcrap]

I can't see a reason not to vote for usAir really.

This game has been a little dead and I'm not really remembering what he did. I also don't really remember who has claimed and who hasn't.

I'm going to have to go back through and read.

[codierose]

the reason you cant remember what he did is because he has done zip nothing apart from FOS on you

usAir wrote:I love how rapidly these games go from joke votes to extremely tense accusations over very little.

On that note, FOS chapcrap, for, at least in my opinion, unnecessarily, and over-aggressively, pursuing a very minor mistake.

and

usAir wrote:After re-reading this discussion, FOS General, Chapcrap, and Sully. I'm not sure if I can make any more sense of this foolishness.
I'll leave my vote on chapcrap for now, until something else develops.

chap said

I don't trust you. This post seems pretty skimmy to me. And skimmy is scummy's cousin. unvote vote usAir

and hipp said

I've said it before and no doubt I'll say it again. But USAir ... where are you? Time to say something or I'm going to start going for you again.

and i agree with the hipp

[MoB Deadly]

for the sake of sparking this game unvote vote usair