CYOC II Game Over!

[sheepofdumb]

Stubbs. I didn't have any strong town leads yet, and I figured nobody goes to kill new players.

But you did use it?

You could've just done nothing.

I'm pretty sure he said he used it on Stubbs

[aage]

Stubbs. I didn't have any strong town leads yet, and I figured nobody goes to kill new players.

But you did use it?

You could've just done nothing.

I'm pretty sure he said he used it on Stubbs

I'm not stupid. Some questions are rhetorical.

[spiesr]

You saying that you made you decision on how to use your power based on the apparent goal of maintaining your own life doesn't inspire much confidence in your claim of bodyguard. (Or at least a town aligned one.)

[strike wolf]

1. I'm ambivalent on the claim itself. The role would fit the character but it's not a strong claim.

2. I feel that a bodyguard is not a big loss if this is a mislynch.

3. I am as well perplexed by the choice of targets and the reasoning behind it.

Overall, I see no reason to change my mind on this lynch.

[TheForgivenOne]

You saying that you made you decision on how to use your power based on the apparent goal of maintaining your own life doesn't inspire much confidence in your claim of bodyguard. (Or at least a town aligned one.)

I thought the same, but I think I understand where he is coming from. If it is played as "If he protects a death, he dies", he rather sacrifice his life on a cop/watcher/etc then on a possible Treestump or a role that might not be as helpful.

[TheForgivenOne]

You saying that you made you decision on how to use your power based on the apparent goal of maintaining your own life doesn't inspire much confidence in your claim of bodyguard. (Or at least a town aligned one.)

I thought the same, but I think I understand where he is coming from. If it is played as "If he protects a death, he dies", he rather sacrifice his life on a cop/watcher/etc then on a possible Treestump or a role that might not be as helpful.

EBWOP: Not saying Stubb's role is useless/not a cop.

[Nebuchadnezer]

Bah, let's get on with it...UNVOTE. VOTE DOOMYOSHI

I was his defender based on the his hints at power. He has a "meh" role, and others feel his play is dodgy enough. I'll follow the vets on this one.

[aage]

I'll follow the vets on this one.

So which of us will you be attempting to lynch tomorrow if Doom is who he says he is?

[DoomYoshi]

Meh. Bodyguard's job is to die, after all, isn't it?

Kill blakebowling. Guaranteed scum right there.

[pancakemix]

Vote Count

Blake - 1 (Doom)
Neb - 2 (Saf, DJ)
Doom - 5 (Aage, SW, spiesr, edoc, Neb)

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch. Deadline will be July 6 at 23:59 ET.

[safariguy5]

With all due respect to stubbs, I would figure that you would want to prevent mafia from taking out a vet who might have a good read on someone. I don't see how the target made sense all other things being equal.

unvote vote doom

[DoomYoshi]

With all due respect to stubbs, I would figure that you would want to prevent mafia from taking out a vet who might have a good read on someone. I don't see how the target made sense all other things being equal.

unvote vote doom

I didn't trust any of the vets last night.

Last time aage got me mislynched he was scum... although this time seems more genuine.

[new guy1]

With all due respect to stubbs, I would figure that you would want to prevent mafia from taking out a vet who might have a good read on someone. I don't see how the target made sense all other things being equal.

unvote vote doom

I didn't trust any of the vets last night.

Last time aage got me mislynched he was scum... although this time seems more genuine.

It is very genuine this time. Youve made alot of mistypes and made yourself look pretty scummy. The only reason Im not voting you is a gut feeling .

[TheForgivenOne]

With all due respect to stubbs, I would figure that you would want to prevent mafia from taking out a vet who might have a good read on someone. I don't see how the target made sense all other things being equal.

unvote vote doom

I didn't trust any of the vets last night.

Last time aage got me mislynched he was scum... although this time seems more genuine.

You didn't have any town vibes on anyone?

But since the deadline is tonight, may as well as Vote: Doom

[Gilligan]

All aboard, there's no stopping this wagon.

vote doomyoshi

[TheForgivenOne]

All aboard, there's no stopping this wagon.

vote doomyoshi

CHOO CHOO

[StubbsKVM]

Okay, just got back home.

How did I get caught up in this again?

that last vote was the hammer right?

I suppose there's not much to say then.

[DoomYoshi]

Okay, just got back home.

How did I get caught up in this again?

that last vote was the hammer right?

I suppose there's not much to say then.

Nobody is stopping you from talking... spill the beans.

[StubbsKVM]

I'd like to hear why you protected me of all people.

[spiesr]

I'd like to hear why you protected me of all people.

Because he thought nobody would try to kill you.

Stubbs. I didn't have any strong town leads yet, and I figured nobody goes to kill new players.

[Nebuchadnezer]

I'd like to hear why you protected me of all people.

Because he thought nobody would try to kill you.

Stubbs. I didn't have any strong town leads yet, and I figured nobody goes to kill new players.

Odd. I didn't think Stubbs was asking you...

[DoomYoshi]

I already answered though.

Who would the rest of you rather me have protected?

[spiesr]

Odd. I didn't think Stubbs was asking you...

He was asking a question which already had a stated answer.

[Gilligan]

it's nighttime

[DoomYoshi]

it's nighttime

I don't see a lynch scene Mr. Jumps-on-the-wagon-scum-pants.