Moderator: Community Team

lol, well, I was wondering how this started; vote zimmah, because there is no logic whatsoever in that reasoning... Unfortunately, we don't know if deuceswild222 is town or scum, because zimmah could be targeting an innocent, or, very cleverly, be targeting one of his scum buddies with a ridiculous reason, such that we are fooled into thinking deuceswild222 must be innocent...zimmah wrote:for 3 obvious reasons:
he has 0 posts
he has a ?
he has too much 2's in his name.
and on top of that he's wild.
dude, are you even serious? trying to start a bandwagon over the very first vote?catnipdreams wrote:lol, well, I was wondering how this started; vote zimmah, because there is no logic whatsoever in that reasoning... Unfortunately, we don't know if deuceswild222 is town or scum, because zimmah could be targeting an innocent, or, very cleverly, be targeting one of his scum buddies with a ridiculous reason, such that we are fooled into thinking deuceswild222 must be innocent...zimmah wrote:for 3 obvious reasons:
he has 0 posts
he has a ?
he has too much 2's in his name.
and on top of that he's wild.
Well, interesting response... This is my first game, and anyone who read the posts would know that... So it was not my intent to "start a bandwagon", per se, but it seems to me that you are protesting quite a bit...zimmah wrote:dude, are you even serious? trying to start a bandwagon over the very first vote?
catnipdreams wrote:Well, interesting response... This is my first game, and anyone who read the posts would know that... So it was not my intent to "start a bandwagon", per se, but it seems to me that you are protesting quite a bit...zimmah wrote:dude, are you even serious? trying to start a bandwagon over the very first vote?
It was a return joke, you cant possibly start a bandwagon with one vote. He was kiddingcatnipdreams wrote:The thing is, you are an experienced player, Zimmah, if I understand your posts correctly... So if I am making newbie mistakes, the other players will see that, and discount what I have said. However, your reaction was pretty strong, which simply makes me more suspicious. Why would an experienced player react that way? Something just seems off to me... And isn't this what we are supposed to do? Look for inconsistencies? You could have just said "Dude, lighten up, it's day 1" or something like that...

Can others confirm this statement? Or is this scum buddy damage control?MoB Deadly wrote:It was a return joke, you cant possibly start a bandwagon with one vote. He was kidding
Day 1's usually are pretty chaotic early on, and you can't seem to gain much information, I would suggest reading over a completed mafia game to see kinda how the 1st day plays out if you are new.catnipdreams wrote:Can others confirm this statement? Or is this scum buddy damage control?MoB Deadly wrote:It was a return joke, you cant possibly start a bandwagon with one vote. He was kidding

Yeah, a proper bandwagon takes about 3 votes to get rolling. It's not considered a bandwagon until it reaches that point.catnipdreams wrote:Can others confirm this statement? Or is this scum buddy damage control?MoB Deadly wrote:It was a return joke, you cant possibly start a bandwagon with one vote. He was kidding
aage wrote:Never trust CYOC or pancake.
catnipdreams wrote:The thing is, you are an experienced player, Zimmah, if I understand your posts correctly... So if I am making newbie mistakes, the other players will see that, and discount what I have said. However, your reaction was pretty strong, which simply makes me more suspicious. Why would an experienced player react that way? Something just seems off to me... And isn't this what we are supposed to do? Look for inconsistencies? You could have just said "Dude, lighten up, it's day 1" or something like that...
Iron Butterfly wrote:
Vote Catnipdreams
Day one is usuelly joke votes and silly bs.
I voted you because your new...and I beleive your mafia hiding behind a newbie shield.
skillfusniper33 wrote: 5. All ‘votes’ and ‘unvotes’ must be in bold and red. If they are not, they will not be tallied. (I.E. Vote: Skill). You must first unvote and then vote to change your vote from someone. Mods may change this according to their wishes.
catnipdreams wrote:The thing is, you are an experienced player, Zimmah, if I understand your posts correctly... So if I am making newbie mistakes, the other players will see that, and discount what I have said. However, your reaction was pretty strong, which simply makes me more suspicious. Why would an experienced player react that way? Something just seems off to me... And isn't this what we are supposed to do? Look for inconsistencies? You could have just said "Dude, lighten up, it's day 1" or something like that...
guys look if you were to choose a killer you would choose the least likely person. The new recruit. Therefore we have to vote him!catnipdreams wrote:lol, well, I was wondering how this started; vote zimmah, because there is no logic whatsoever in that reasoning... Unfortunately, we don't know if deuceswild222 is town or scum, because zimmah could be targeting an innocent, or, very cleverly, be targeting one of his scum buddies with a ridiculous reason, such that we are fooled into thinking deuceswild222 must be innocent...zimmah wrote:for 3 obvious reasons:
he has 0 posts
he has a ?
he has too much 2's in his name.
and on top of that he's wild.
I believe Rodion can be another option due to his high rank. A third option would be a player who's experienced in mafia.jonty125 wrote:vote Rodion Because he is bound to lie like in the Nightmare Before Christmas
eagleblade wrote:ONE more thing. Whatever we go lets vote someone off either way. Like just force a majority basically. I might sound like a noob to mafia so someone correct me if your not suppose to do this