
Moderator: Cartographers
Um, if Hector's dead, shouldn't Troy be on fire or in ruins?ericwdhs wrote:It's definitely Troy. If it's not, it would still be perfect for it. The island is Lemnos (their god is Hephaestus). The grave is Hector's.
I don't know. In the book, Troy hadn't been under any real seige. Hector was killed in the fields outside of Troy before the Greeks ever got in. Also, King Priam had many sons, some of which were dead long before the battle. It could be any of them. Honestly though, I've never seen the movie so I don't know how it varies from the book.Incandenza wrote:Um, if Hector's dead, shouldn't Troy be on fire or in ruins?ericwdhs wrote:It's definitely Troy. If it's not, it would still be perfect for it. The island is Lemnos (their god is Hephaestus). The grave is Hector's.![]()
Amazing work, mibi... can't wait to see the whole thing.
Hector wasn't buried, he was burned on a funeral pyre. Maybe they buried him after that but I imagine there would be much left.Incandenza wrote:Um, if Hector's dead, shouldn't Troy be on fire or in ruins?ericwdhs wrote:It's definitely Troy. If it's not, it would still be perfect for it. The island is Lemnos (their god is Hephaestus). The grave is Hector's.![]()
Amazing work, mibi... can't wait to see the whole thing.
Leaving aside the fact that there is no book as such, the literary tradition does hold that the Greeks were camped outside for ten years, which would make it a pretty serious siege.ericwdhs wrote:In the book, Troy hadn't been under any real seige.
Troy lay between the Skamandros and the Simoeis. Sure, they weren't quite so close as the map makes out but they were fairly close and he has said the map isn't to scale for gameplay purposes.Spritzking wrote:for troy was not between 2 rivers
If he's messed around with the geography then it could be but I think Tenedos fits better. It's closer to the shore than Lemnos and has more relevance to the siege of Troy.ericwdhs wrote:The island is Lemnos (their god is Hephaestus).
Atlantis was also considered to be in the middle of the Atlantic ocean, and very big. Atlantis also wouldn't of had many battles, as the Atlantians had a great fleet, which was only defeated by the Athenians.Wisse wrote:but atlanthis was build round, and now look to his map how much round things you see and the river tooericwdhs wrote:I don't know whether that can be considered historical. It's debatable.Wisse wrote:atlantis?
KraphtOne wrote:when you sign up a new account one of the check boxes should be "do you want to foe colton24 (it is highly recommended) "
lol, people theorize that Atlantis was in the Atlantic most often perhaps, but there are theories that it was in the Pacific, the mediterranean and that its even the current continent of Anarctica!Skittles! wrote:Atlantis was also considered to be in the middle of the Atlantic ocean, and very big. Atlantis also wouldn't of had many battles, as the Atlantians had a great fleet, which was only defeated by the Athenians.
Could it be on the island of Sicily?