Whats the stupidest map?

neoni · Post by **neoni** » Sun Oct 14, 2007 10:47 am

firth4eva wrote:doodle earth is fucking insane but i love it

YEAH ME TOO, WHAT A GREAT MAP

Vace Cooper · Post by **Vace Cooper** » Sun Oct 14, 2007 11:44 am

That super cool map in the map ideas forum sucks

jiminski · Post by **jiminski** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 4:52 am

I am Converted to Peal Harbour! leave it be on the Plane reinforcement.

It's a really imaginative map with some original additions.

thanks for your hard work ..... BOB still not quite working but if you know about the planes its no bother. (any one able to do a patch?)

Cheers,

Jim.

edbeard · Post by **edbeard** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 5:18 am

that Caribbean Islands map is crap

Gilligan · Post by **Gilligan** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 5:20 am

edbeard wrote:that Caribbean Islands map is crap

luv2tri2 · Post by **luv2tri2** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 7:39 am

Any map created in the last 6 months.....especially Age of Merchants!

DiM · Post by **DiM** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 7:40 am

luv2tri2 wrote:Any map created in the last 6 months.....especially Age of Merchants!

i love you too.

wait till you see Age of Realms

and it's a trilogy so it has 3 maps

Kinnison · Post by **Kinnison** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 11:37 am

Interesting...

I guess i'm a freak, I LIKE crossword.

8 Thoughts is interesting, but not great. Much like Chinese Checkers... the symmetry hurts the map. Although 8 thoughts has a 'cooler' look and perspective on it. Haven't tried US Senate...

Pearl Harbor is HUGELY dependent on luck of the drop, with all those bonuses. Never played AoM or D-Day yet, but they appear to have a similar problem.

Doodle Earth is rather silly. ...but then, I went and joined a 6-player public game on it (heh) so who am I to talk?

Circus Maximus... I liked it when I first got here... not so much now. It needs to be limited to Escalating games, really.

Rumondo · Post by **Rumondo** » Fri Oct 19, 2007 4:01 pm

2 player shouldn't even be an option with P-Harbor considering you can get upwards of 15+ reinforcements on the drop. It's just too large of an advantage despite any other setting involved.

I don't agree that you should get the minor bonuses for the planes. I've only played this map in 1-1 but it is realtively easy to take and hold 3 of one type plane without having any real strategical advantage over your opponent. Maybe you should only be able to get the bonus for the planes IF you also hold the gunning stations coordinated with them (Like the +1 bonuses).

DaGip · Post by **DaGip** » Sun Oct 21, 2007 10:17 am

RobinJ wrote:I have to agree that there are some maps out there that just don't work:

Chinese Checkers: just too symmetrical, although it isn't so bad for team games

Crossword: Everything about it sucks

Indochina: nice graphics now it has been updated but the playability still isn't great

Ireland: playability isn't great and the graphics could be better
Montreal: still looks crap (why do we even have a map of Montreal when there are so many other bigger cities?)

Pearl Harbour: Graphics and the idea is fantastic. However, there is just far too much happening - can't understand it. Hopefully I will come to like it as time goes on

Rail USA: just far too abstract and doesn't make for a good game. I hope Rail Europe does not get quenched

US Senate: So symmetrical that the games are just boring

A few other iffy ones like AOM and Space but they're all right once you learn how to play them

Don't know why some of the other maps are getting a beating though. I love Discworld and D-Day for example.

These are the reasons why CC should combine some of the facets of Dungeon and Dragons character generation with the simplistic strategic gameplay of Risk. It would be new and FUN! Dungeon&Dragons and ConquerClub...the two would meld together perfectly! Though it wouldn't be really considered Risk anymore, but a Hybrid version of the two. Also would be a major undertaking to program. But if it ever sees the light of day...I am playing it!

soundout9 · Post by **soundout9** » Sun Oct 21, 2007 12:27 pm

Any maps with gameplay gimmicks

Age Of Merchants
Bonusless Territories
No Continents
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports - Written rules for connections not drawn on the map.

Chinese Checkers
Bonusless Territories
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

Circvs Maximvs
Bonusless Territories
One Way Attack Routes

D-Day: Omaha Beach!
Bonusless Territories
Negative Bonuses
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports - Written rules for connections not drawn on the map.

King Of The Mountains
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports - Written rules for connections not drawn on the map.

Pearl Harbor
Bombardments - Attacks that don't conquer territories but instead turn them neutral.
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

Philippines
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports - Written rules for connections not drawn on the map.

San Francisco
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

Siege!
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

Space Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports

USApocalypse
Negative Bonuses
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

Valley Of The Kings
One Way Attack Routes
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.
Teleports - Written rules for connections not drawn on the map.

World 2.1
Bonusless Territories
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

8 Thoughts
Negative Bonuses
Bonusless Territories
Shared Bonuses - Some places with more than one bonus.

ijnmusashi · Post by **ijnmusashi** » Wed Oct 24, 2007 10:21 pm

my vote would be for crossword because the borders are to hard to see

s.xkitten · Post by **s.xkitten** » Wed Oct 24, 2007 10:28 pm

in my opinion, its age of merchants

owenshooter · Post by **owenshooter** » Thu Oct 25, 2007 3:21 am

merchants? really? that is in my top 3 maps, easily... have to go with crossword on this one.-0

demy7 · Post by **demy7** » Thu Oct 25, 2007 4:22 am

Well maybe Alexander's Empire and Mongol Empire are both morally sick, making people feel guilty