Conquer Club

I was never told the contents of the letter, just that i had a letter.

I believe milkshake. I think we should lunch sheep for being a factionette personally. Orange + role name of grunt? SCUM.

unvote vote sheep

pmchugh wrote:I believe milkshake. I think we should lunch sheep for being a factionette personally. Orange + role name of grunt? SCUM.

unvote vote sheep

lunch him? sounds delicious!

I shall also, Vote Sheep

Official Vote Count:

Pmchung (1) - Haggis
Sheep (3) - Pmchung, /, Milkshake L-2
TFO (1) - Sheep
Milkshake (1) - TFO

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline May 1st

Deadline put in place due to minimal activity. If activity picks up and it is requested the deadline can be extended.

-SG7 ( )

This is a fircoal game. When have the setup ever been typical?

What's the current theory on the 2 CMC's getting killed? Did we decided to shoot one of our own? No one has claimed to have roleblocked me and the bus driver never targeted any of the CMC members. So what's the likelihood of the CMC having a kill?

Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

nagerous wrote:Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

and why do you think that?

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

and why do you think that?

Your name claim isn't solid, it is a minor character.

Your role claim isn't solid, giving random letters out isn't much of a claim even in a fircoal game and no one can even back that up - all TFO says is he got a muffin.

sheepofdumb wrote:This is a fircoal game. When have the setup ever been typical?

What's the current theory on the 2 CMC's getting killed? Did we decided to shoot one of our own? No one has claimed to have roleblocked me and the bus driver never targeted any of the CMC members. So what's the likelihood of the CMC having a kill?

I don't really have an answer for this.. but I still don't believe it. There are other players lying out there and maybe they will incriminate you in their death. unvote for now.

I still don't think CMC is likely scum but it is true that his role is confirmed but not his alignment.

nagerous wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

and why do you think that?

Your name claim isn't solid, it is a minor character.

Your role claim isn't solid, giving random letters out isn't much of a claim even in a fircoal game and no one can even back that up - all TFO says is he got a muffin.

Yes, i'm a freaking minor character. Whats that got to do with anything?
First I said that i gave TFO the letter.
Second TFO says that he got a muffin.

Now. tell me how my claim isnt solid again?

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

and why do you think that?

Your name claim isn't solid, it is a minor character.

Your role claim isn't solid, giving random letters out isn't much of a claim even in a fircoal game and no one can even back that up - all TFO says is he got a muffin.

Yes, i'm a freaking minor character. Whats that got to do with anything?
First I said that i gave TFO the letter.
Second TFO says that he got a muffin.

Now. tell me how my claim isnt solid again?

What did you do night one?
Whats to say you aren't an SK as well as a muffin man.

pmchugh wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

nagerous wrote:Going to throw my vote out there

vote milkshake


I think that is the best lead out there.

and why do you think that?

Your name claim isn't solid, it is a minor character.

Your role claim isn't solid, giving random letters out isn't much of a claim even in a fircoal game and no one can even back that up - all TFO says is he got a muffin.

Yes, i'm a freaking minor character. Whats that got to do with anything?
First I said that i gave TFO the letter.
Second TFO says that he got a muffin.

Now. tell me how my claim isnt solid again?

What did you do night one?
Whats to say you aren't an SK as well as a muffin man.

I already said that i dont remember who i gave the muffin to N1.
What evidence do you have to say i am?

You asked why your claim was not solid, both of them are very good reasons to think so. Conveniently forgetting an action and having an unconfirmed alignment, in addition to a weird role and a non mainstream pony name make your claim weaker than most.

pmchugh wrote:You asked why your claim was not solid, both of them are very good reasons to think so. Conveniently forgetting an action and having an unconfirmed alignment, in addition to a weird role and a non mainstream pony name make your claim weaker than most.

I sent in that action in on March 29th. when N1 happened. I was modding a game where i had to send out role PM's, and night actions, and my clan was sending out a lot of PM's at that time too.

I sent out the role PM's for my superhero mafia on the 30th. a total of 12 roles plus answering questions.
Superhero N1 started on April 3rd. I had to send out 7 things saying what happened.
Superhero N2 started on April 7th. Had to send out 7 more role results.
Superhero N3 started on April 13th. had to send out 5 Role results.
and all the while we had a clan mate have a family emergency and PM's were flying all around about that.
The first request of me stating who i gave the letter to N1 was on the 14th:

dazza2008 wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:

pmchugh wrote:That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

So who have you given one to each night?

so yes, i had looked, but the PM was not there.

IMO Nag is the scummiest of us all, because N1 he was roleblocked. and N2 he investigated a dead pony. So it could just be a clever fake claim that he made up, he hasnt given us any info at all.

Thats all i have to say. double check my word in my super hero thread.

also unvote

crazymilkshake5 wrote:so yes, i had looked, but the PM was not there.

IMO Nag is the scummiest of us all, because N1 he was roleblocked. and N2 he investigated a dead pony. So it could just be a clever fake claim that he made up, he hasnt given us any info at all.

Thats all i have to say. double check my word in my super hero thread.

also unvote

Yeah, but Haggis also claimed to Driven nagerous and Zimmah N2, which would also partially clear him. Unless you think Haggis and nagerous are working together.

TheForgivenOne wrote:

crazymilkshake5 wrote:so yes, i had looked, but the PM was not there.

IMO Nag is the scummiest of us all, because N1 he was roleblocked. and N2 he investigated a dead pony. So it could just be a clever fake claim that he made up, he hasnt given us any info at all.

Thats all i have to say. double check my word in my super hero thread.

also unvote

Yeah, but Haggis also claimed to Driven nagerous and Zimmah N2, which would also partially clear him. Unless you think Haggis and nagerous are working together.

Wait a minute. If nagerous investigated Zimmah N2, wouldn't that mean he investigated himself? I don't remember him saying anything about that Unless I'm helplessly confusing myself.

TheForgivenOne wrote:Wait a minute. If nagerous investigated Zimmah N2, wouldn't that mean he investigated himself? I don't remember him saying anything about that Unless I'm helplessly confusing myself.

He wouldn't know if he investigated himself and since zimmah came up blue then he wouldn't see anything strange if he was blue himself.

TheForgivenOne wrote:Yeah, but Haggis also claimed to Driven nagerous and Zimmah N2, which would also partially clear him. Unless you think Haggis and nagerous are working together.

We have multiple killers, so that doesn't clear him.

I got a town investigation result..

Also, I claimed first, the main role, and the cop who no one counter claimed either - your vote against me is obviously OMGUS and just confirms to me that you are scum milkshake

nagerous wrote:I got a town investigation result..

Also, I claimed first, the main role, and the cop who no one counter claimed either - your vote against me is obviously OMGUS and just confirms to me that you are scum milkshake

skimming much?

scum much?

I never voted you, i just unvoted.

Ok, rather than your comments that I am the scummiest of all... completely unfounded and reeks of desperation. Made me laugh at least.

Really now? it was a freaking month. I cant even remember hat i did last week

pmchugh wrote:

TheForgivenOne wrote:Wait a minute. If nagerous investigated Zimmah N2, wouldn't that mean he investigated himself? I don't remember him saying anything about that Unless I'm helplessly confusing myself.

He wouldn't know if he investigated himself and since zimmah came up blue then he wouldn't see anything strange if he was blue himself.

Mmkay, Guess I was just going of what happened in another game, where a Tracker got a report on himself because he was driven.

Vote Count please mod?