Page 24 of 79
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 4:48 pm
by aage
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:aage wrote:Edoc, previous page. I believe I read somewhere that TheHerkman had investigated someone before the game started and decided to investigate Tails. Please tell me if I am confusing players/games or something, I seriously believe I read this, but it might not be exactly as I said it is.
I think you're confusing the Crusades mafia w/ this one. Saxlad investigated me prior to the game starting in that one. I was close to getting lynched.
FOS aage for getting mixed up.
jk its understandable, 30+ pages is a lot to read to catch up.
-Tails
Yeah, those 11 pages of Edoc'sil's game really are laughable when compared to this one lol.
Either way, we still have a deadline for THE DAY AFTER TOMORROW! *woooot*
Since TheHerkman's only scummy behavior is just posting overly massively seriously extensively ridiculously too much, and the fact that he both claims to have a life
and have read the Mindscrew games, I don't feel it's enough reason to vote the newb off in this big a game. But on the other hand we only have inactive dudez and a Roleblocker to come back at. There's 38 pages out there! What have we got?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 4:50 pm
by TheSaxlad
VioIet wrote:aage wrote:Edoc, previous page. I believe I read somewhere that TheHerkman had investigated someone before the game started and decided to investigate Tails. Please tell me if I am confusing players/games or something, I seriously believe I read this, but it might not be exactly as I said it is.
I think you are confusing this game with Crusades. Thus confusing herk with sax...lad.
But doing some metagaming here- sax's behavior seems to be exactly the same in both games. And equally scummy.
VoIet, exactly the same?
I think not.
If I was exactly the same I would have saved someones ass, perhaps just trying to point the blame on me perhaps.
FOS Vi
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 4:54 pm
by blakebowling
I'm leaving my vote on lala because I'd rather see someone that's not bothered to read the thread lynched than someone who's at least trying. However, FOS Violet, you seem to be involved in a lot of the drama early in the game, a scumtell IMO.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 4:58 pm
by aage
blakebowling wrote:I'm leaving my vote on lala because I'd rather see someone that's not bothered to read the thread lynched than someone who's at least trying. However, FOS Violet, you seem to be involved in a lot of the drama early in the game, a scumtell IMO.
Having personal relations with the drama queens a scumtell? lmao.
I agree on the first bit though.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 5:19 pm
by theherkman
I'm still FOS sensfan. Seriously look at what he has posted. I have also seen him in this thread, so I know he has been following it.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 5:21 pm
by sensfan
theherkman wrote:I'm still FOS sensfan. Seriously look at what he has posted. I have also seen him in this thread, so I know he has been following it.
come on, geez. What do you expect me to say?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 5:22 pm
by aage
I suspect he expects you to say more intelligent stuff than that. Still, you're not the only one, so it'd be pretty random to choose you of all players.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 5:25 pm
by dazerazer
OMG!!! F*** S*** A*** Woah!!!####3333!!!!!!********^&*%$#!!!!!!!
okie dokey ya'll I just needed to let out some steam. Whew!!
And AHAHAHAHAHAHA!!! I AM A DRAMA QUEEN!!!
Thank ya to all who have been sticking up for me. Smooches.
But I'd like to address one thing.
Stop saying I don’t contribute. Okay ya’ll want me to contribute. Okay here it is ya’ll.
dazerazer (4) - saxlad, sensfan, flores, haggis
They all voted me. That’s the mob!!
I think theherk be votin me too- but I think he is townie. Just a bit excited there bro, LOL!!!
They all voted me. I present my case. Didn't ya'll say my possible lynch could provide information on possible wagons. Everyone has unvoted me cept them. I don't see no one suspectin the wagons cept for Vio.
Also if i get more leads as to who the mob may be, I can use my roleblocking powers against them and prevent a night kill. On Day 2 the town is gunna look like a slaughterhouse LMAO!!!!
So ya'll really don't wanna lynch me.
FOS Sensfan, Saxlad, Haggis
Vote Flores
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 5:52 pm
by theherkman
sensfan wrote:theherkman wrote:I'm still FOS sensfan. Seriously look at what he has posted. I have also seen him in this thread, so I know he has been following it.
come on, geez. What do you expect me to say?
Let me go through your posts as an example of what not to say.
sensfan wrote:vote sensfan for voting myself
sensfan wrote:dazer is just being annyoning
vote dazer
sensfan wrote:VOTE COUNT please
sensfan wrote:absent until sunday.
sensfan wrote:come on, geez. What do you expect me to say?
And now this last post? I mean come on. You reek of scum. And for that reason
UNVOTE VOTE SENSFAN.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:18 pm
by TA1LGUNN3R
theherkman wrote:sensfan wrote:theherkman wrote:I'm still FOS sensfan. Seriously look at what he has posted. I have also seen him in this thread, so I know he has been following it.
come on, geez. What do you expect me to say?
Let me go through your posts as an example of what not to say.
sensfan wrote:vote sensfan for voting myself
joke vote
sensfan wrote:dazer is just being annyoning
an opinion, nothing too scummy, although it could be grounds for lurking and trying to hide
vote dazer
Tons of people BW'ed her
sensfan wrote:VOTE COUNT please
wanted a vote count
sensfan wrote:absent until sunday.
forewarning us
sensfan wrote:come on, geez. What do you expect me to say?
What do you expect him to say?
And now this last post? I mean come on. You reek of scum. And for that reason
UNVOTE VOTE SENSFAN.
He's definitely suspicious of lurking and maybe trying to remain unobtrusive, but your post doesn't really have very convincing evidence. Maybe you're trying to draw attention from yourself?
But FOS on sens for lurking.
-Tails
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:20 pm
by naxus
unvote [/b]vote theherkman[/b]
The last few pages really proved my point in that Herk is constantly switching his vote around. That and he is contributing mostly random info and fluff. He's switched his vote multiple times in the last few days
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:21 pm
by naxus
naxus wrote:unvote vote theherkman
I say kill Herk.The last few pages really proved my point in that Herk is constantly switching his vote around. That and he is contributing mostly random info and fluff. He's switched his vote multiple times in the last few days
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:24 pm
by spiesr
dazerazer wrote:dazerazer (4) - saxlad, sensfan, flores, haggis
They all voted me. That’s the mob!!
While it is certainly possible that there are scum members trying to keep the lynch on daze now that the deadline makes it probably once again, simply saying omg all the guys voting for me must be scum isn't a very compelling argument. Over the course of a game any player who receives any non-trivial amount of votes is bound to be voted for by both scum and town aligned players. While you can use someone voting for someone at a certain time as partial evidence when making a case against them, it needs collaborating evidence before a decent argument can be made. And it can't be applied in mass like this. A situation where four members of a scum faction all vote together with no one else voting with them against one person on day one, would be pretty bad strategy on their part. They would not want to link themselves in such a way so early in the game, at least not when it is unlikely to accomplish anything that would have a major effect on the game. And several of those people you have listed their have played mafia enough to see that as not really a that good of an idea.
In short, could a scum member be amongst those voting for you? Sure Are all those voting for you scum member acting together in a unified way? No way.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:26 pm
by Jace22
yeah, I agree. Herk has been FOS anyone who accuses him of anything and saying they've been skimming. As well as bringing unneeded info from mafiascum wiki which confused the hell out of a lot of people, so unvote vote herk
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:27 pm
by Haggis_McMutton
spiesr wrote:dazerazer wrote:dazerazer (4) - saxlad, sensfan, flores, haggis
They all voted me. That’s the mob!!
While it is certainly possible that there are scum members trying to keep the lynch on daze now that the deadline makes it probably once again, simply saying omg all the guys voting for me must be scum isn't a very compelling argument. Over the course of a game any player who receives any non-trivial amount of votes is bound to be voted for by both scum and town aligned players. While you can use someone voting for someone at a certain time as partial evidence when making a case against them, it needs collaborating evidence before a decent argument can be made. And it can't be applied in mass like this. A situation where four members of a scum faction all vote together with no one else voting with them against one person on day one, would be pretty bad strategy on their part. They would not want to link themselves in such a way so early in the game, at least not when it is unlikely to accomplish anything that would have a major effect on the game. And several of those people you have listed their have played mafia enough to see that as not really a that good of an idea.
In short, could a scum member be amongst those voting for you? Sure Are all those voting for you scum member acting together in a unified way? No way.
Yeah, she's most likely not going to read that.
That's why i didn't bother to respond myself to her very compelling argument.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:28 pm
by spiesr
Jace22 wrote:yeah, I agree. Herk has been FOS anyone who accuses him of anything and saying they've been skimming. As well as bringing unneeded info from mafiascum wiki which confused the hell out of a lot of people, so unvote vote herk
Just trying to hop onto the newest shiniest bandwagon and present a facade of a contribution? FOS Jace...
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:29 pm
by FloresDelMal
herkman, i am not skimming, you shouldnt use this accusation so freely, for many of us it does hold a meaning, even thought i went through the pain of read every post, in my couple of years as mafia player i have never came across to such a role, the first time i ever saw it pop up is when you brought it to the table, that in itself is reason enough for FOS you.
Now i got an idea, in the hypothetical scenary that we dont lynch daze, being her the first one to claim, if the herkman is actually a punisher he will have to kill her, so if daze get killed the herkman could do a pretty damn good lynch or day vig target. what do you think guys?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:38 pm
by Haggis_McMutton
FloresDelMal wrote:herkman, i am not skimming, you shouldnt use this accusation so freely, for many of us it does hold a meaning, even thought i went through the pain of read every post, in my couple of years as mafia player i have never came across to such a role, the first time i ever saw it pop up is when you brought it to the table, that in itself is reason enough for FOS you.
Now i got an idea, in the hypothetical scenary that we dont lynch daze, being her the first one to claim, if the herkman is actually a punisher he will have to kill her, so if daze get killed the herkman could do a pretty damn good lynch or day vig target. what do you think guys?
It seems pretty unlikely that both daze and herk will survive the day though. They're number 1 and 2 in votes i think and herk seems to be the new bandwaggon of choice.
IMO he still seems like an overanxious townie, but i agree that there's some suspicion in his overzealous defence. I don't really buy the punisher thing though. Sure, he's a newb, but why the hell would he randomly start talking about the very rare role that he happens to have?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:41 pm
by blakebowling
spiesr wrote:Jace22 wrote:yeah, I agree. Herk has been FOS anyone who accuses him of anything and saying they've been skimming. As well as bringing unneeded info from mafiascum wiki which confused the hell out of a lot of people, so unvote vote herk
Just trying to hop onto the newest shiniest bandwagon and present a facade of a contribution? FOS Jace...
FOS spiesr, you've been judging everyone, and it seems like you're trying to throw around suspicion, maybe to keep it off of yourself?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:41 pm
by strike wolf
To be honest vio and Daze. I think you've both let personal feelings get in the way. I believe I mentioned this early in a different context but that's not good for anyone. It screws with the dynamic of the game and it can lead to bad lynches and messed up night actions (for instance a cop not investigating a friend who turns out to be scum because they trust them outside of the game). you both need to take a step back and look at this more analytically and all three of you (including flores) need to put this behind you for the game to continue properly.
Other than that I don't really like how Sensfan has been lurking either but considering the high amount of fluff herk has posted, the odd mention of a punisher in this game out of nowhere, the convenient leads that come mostly after someone else has posted similar information and that just about anyone who's questioned him about being scum has either been called scum or a skimmer possibly both and a couple times he out right voted for them, I feel that A. he is the most likely anti-town role out there and B. if he is the punisher and I think there is a good chance he is if there is one in this game, he has a kill ability in a role that isn't town friendly so why not get rid of one of the people who can kill overnight?
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:43 pm
by FloresDelMal
Haggis_McMutton wrote:Sure, he's a newb, but why the hell would he randomly start talking about the very rare role that he happens to have?
because he is a overanxious newb, not so long ago he wanted to lynch ppl just out of curiosity, and he wanted to claim for the lol's, he was overexcited like a pup waiting for his walk, i dont think is awfully far fetched to beliave that he got this very cool role and couldnt resist the temptation of talk about it, and since he is such a noob, he thought that this was a fairly common role and therefor couldnt raise any suspiscion.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:44 pm
by Thezzaruz
dazerazer wrote:Stop saying I don’t contribute. Okay ya’ll want me to contribute. Okay here it is ya’ll.
dazerazer (4) - saxlad, sensfan, flores, haggis
They all voted me. That’s the mob!!
An OMGUS rant isn't much of a contribution though. And as spiesr mentioned it is very unlikely that experienced players would throw most of the scum faction on a single BW, let alone be the whole BW, and thus your point falls flat.
If you want to contribute you could start with clearing up why a roleblocker would be linked with a Doc???
TA1LGUNN3R wrote:He's definitely suspicious of lurking and maybe trying to remain unobtrusive, but your post doesn't really have very convincing evidence. Maybe you're trying to draw attention from yourself?
But FOS on sens for lurking.
It isn't lurking as he actually posts. Crappy posts I'll admit and they don't make him look good but still not lurking.
theherkman wrote:And now this last post? I mean come on. You reek of scum.
A valid case for once, improvement noted.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:47 pm
by theherkman
Well, I think we need a vote count now so I know if I need to claim...
You guys are making the biggest mistake of the game if you kill me...
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:49 pm
by aage
Thanks spiesr, if you hadn't i might've thrown that FoS, if not for the fact that I kind of agree with the wagon... Posting like a madman, responding in trifold and an omgus on every hint of an accusation towards him and still managing to achieve nothing is a good enough reason for d1 lynch for me...
vote theherkman I think. I'd like a roleclaim though.
Also, fastposted. FoS blakebowling. I suppose I'll get an omguFoS back, but anyway... Spiesr wasn't getting accused so I don't see why he's trying to avoid attention by FoS'ing others.
Re: New Briarsburg Mafia. Day 1 REPLACEMENTS NEEDED
Posted: Tue Nov 16, 2010 6:50 pm
by aage
theherkman wrote:Well, I think we need a vote count now so I know if I need to claim...
You guys are making the biggest mistake of the game if you kill me...
Do explain why, out of 30 roles, you are the ONE role that we cannot possibly miss if we are to succeed in killing all the mafia? I think you're overrating your role, or lying.