Skoffin's Madhouse mafia Day Seven

[Skoffin]

Lord voldemort replaced by sierra leon.

[Fircoal]

I have some MOAR SURPRISES

Surprise #1: Skoffin is a guy

Surprise #2: SKoffin loves Reed

(Neither of which are that surprising. >_____>

[Skoffin]

Fircoal's vote has been removed for the day, SURPRISE!

[Sierra_Leon]

Hi all, I haven't been following this thread, so give me some time to read up before I start pointing out who's scum.

[Iliad]

Hi all, I haven't been following this thread, so give me some time to read up before I start pointing out who's scum.

qft

[fireedud]

I can replace, if you let me.

[Fircoal]

Fircoal's vote has been removed for the day, SURPRISE!

XD how did I think something like that would happen.

[Fircoal]

I don't think I should say Surprise #4...

[Sierra_Leon]

Ok, I've read up. I found Ditocoaf the most suspicious player for the whole of day 1. The fact that Kalish defended him and turned up scum reinforces my suspicions. If Dito turns out to be scum, I see possible connections between him and fircoal and/or animorph and/or Nark. Vote Ditocoaf.

Let me also clarify that LoVo had nothing to do with the messages over the PA system. I can only assume that the IAMLORDVOLDEMORT riddle hints to there being a Lord Voldemort role, from the Harry Potter books. The fact that LoVo didn't post had nothing to do with those messages; I don't have a post restriction. It had to do with LoVo's lack of participation, hence Skoffin has blacklisted him from what I understood.

[DRoZ]

At least some of the LoVo / Voldemort have been cleared up.

Exile has been looking scummy for awhile now, in my opinion. But I think it's too late with the size of this game, if you guys want a lynch there's probably no option other then Ditto at this point but my vote won't go there. Personally I'd rather see a no lynch today then Ditto lynched, I really don't think he's the proper lynch because he got feed up, it happens to every mafia player at some point.

In this post kalish is trying to push the vote on exile but says it rather defeated... And adds the part about dito would be the only lynch available. It seems to be pushing for a dito save/exile lynch or a no lynch, and I might add it is the only time I have seen a push for no lynch look like a town idea. With this information it would seem that kalish would be aligned with dito, or just using him for a no lynch. Strangely enough it would seem that exile would be the scummier of the two. Considering the second claim that wasn't necessarily a counter-claim.

[The Weird One]

Fircoal's vote has been removed for the day, SURPRISE!

XD how did I think something like that would happen.

Ja, I'm kinda dissapointed...there were no repercussions from voting for skinoff yesterday. [Not that, in any way, I'm complaining. ]

[kalishnikov]

What is an inflitrator?

Good question...



My first game in ages and I still can't make it passed night 1... Good game though guys, it was a tough night on ga, he's gonna be all lonely now. Sorry for the delay, I was out of town for the weekend.

<------ that's at Skof, she knows why.... lol

[animorpherv1]

Ok, I've read up. I found Ditocoaf the most suspicious player for the whole of day 1. The fact that Kalish defended him and turned up scum reinforces my suspicions. If Dito turns out to be scum, I see possible connections between him and fircoal and/or animorph and/or Nark. Vote Ditocoaf.

This makes sense to me. vote: Ditcoaf

[Anarkistsdream]

Ok, I've read up. I found Ditocoaf the most suspicious player for the whole of day 1. The fact that Kalish defended him and turned up scum reinforces my suspicions. If Dito turns out to be scum, I see possible connections between him and fircoal and/or animorph and/or Nark. Vote Ditocoaf.

Let me also clarify that LoVo had nothing to do with the messages over the PA system. I can only assume that the IAMLORDVOLDEMORT riddle hints to there being a Lord Voldemort role, from the Harry Potter books. The fact that LoVo didn't post had nothing to do with those messages; I don't have a post restriction. It had to do with LoVo's lack of participation, hence Skoffin has blacklisted him from what I understood.

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

[Anarkistsdream]

As a matter of fact, I have a significant problem with this...

How can people see Dito as being scummy when he was very forthcoming and honest with what his abilities were, while Exile just sort of tagged/limped behind..?

I don't see any reasoning for this, and think that Exile looked way worse than Dito.

I withhold my vote until there is actually some evidence presented. There must be some good investigative roles that had SOME sort of info. So far, everyone is playing this really close to the vest, which is fine, but there is no one to trust enough to believe what they say.

[The1exile]

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

I think you may both be scum, for starters.

[DRoZ]

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

I think you may both be scum, for starters.

Do you have info backing this or are you just going on a hunch?

[Anarkistsdream]

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

I think you may both be scum, for starters.

Well, first I was asking Sierra.

Second, anybody in this game could be scum.

I still believe you are scum, too, and have actually given reasons for my beliefs. What makes you think so?

[The Weird One]

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

I think you may both be scum, for starters.

You're pointing the finger at the nearest person who's not you. . .classic.

[mr. incrediball]

May I ask how Dito and I have any connection to one another whatsoever?

I think you may both be scum, for starters.

and why do you think that? odd thing to say.

[animorpherv1]

I'm going to have to back up Anarak here, his side sounds better. unvote vote: exile

[Fircoal]

What is an inflitrator?

Good question...



My first game in ages and I still can't make it passed night 1... Good game though guys, it was a tough night on ga, he's gonna be all lonely now. Sorry for the delay, I was out of town for the weekend.

<------ that's at Skof, she knows why.... lol

No worries Kalish, I'm already trying to solve that problem

[The1exile]

I have already started to outline why:

I don't know why everyone assumes it was Vig, SK or bodyguard, rather than two scum groups. I think that's much more likely, frankly, maybe there were more kills and a doc/roleblocker got lucky, too.

so, we have any leads at all?

This is usually the point where someone looks back at kalish's posts to see if there was anything fishy.

Immediately coming to mind is his "AD you're playing like scum" line. FOS AD

Kalish launched what can at best be described as a half-arsed attack on nark, and we know now that he turns out to be scum. this serves two purposes: one, it theoretically distances kalish from nark if (when) he turns out be scum, and two, it dicvides opinion from Suspect #1, Dito.

[The1exile]

How can people see Dito as being scummy when he was very forthcoming and honest with what his abilities were, while Exile just sort of tagged/limped behind..?

Answered this already: it could have been given as a safe claim by skoff. I tend to always give fake claims to scum in my games if they ask for it.

He also jumped the gun with the role-claiming - why would I lead the way in exposing my role and potentially aiding the scum?

[/]

Can our claimed "historians" use their roles every once in awhile so we can actually pretend to believe at least one is telling the truth *cough*votes*cough*?
Also, do safe claims usually come with complete roles, I thought it's usually just names?