I'm thinking about it, on one hand hippo is definitely not lying about being a tracker, and skill is definitely not lying about being two-face, hippo was at least truthful enough to never claim he was town himself.
A PGO role is OP for mafia, but a half PGO, I'm not sure
The main problem I have with them at this point is that they fail to acknowledge day three's death scene,
crazymilkshake5 wrote:
*Ting*
As one hero catches with a glimpse of his eye something shinny flying in the air, it lands in the senders hand.
"You sir, are one unlucky man." Said one
"What are you talking abou..." said the other
*bang*
When the other heroes hear this, they all come rushing.
"What happened here!?" said the Leader.
"I don't know, I just found him here. dead."
"I can tell you one thing though, This was no act of nature." The leader proclaimed.
"Well no freaking duh, Bullets aren't natural!"
why do you keep saying it was a
possibility that shield killed someone? did you honestly thing that shield is coincidentally a man who ritualistically flips shiny object in the air before shooting someone?
They, to me proves their group obviously cares nothing for town, which make me doubt their alignment.
On the other hand there is jgordon, who I believe to be one of the more skilled and reasonable players here, he has thus far acted logically and like town should act, but his role claim makes my brain sad every time I think of it, I personally consider The Punisher is a hero, an awesome one at that. But I don't understand at all why he would be a bodygaurd, sure he has a bulletproof vest, but when does he ever directly protect people? Every problem the punisher solves is solved pretty much the same way, kill it awesomely. I suppose I might be able to put it under reasonable doubt the same way I'm Spider-man and not a role-blocker despite having iconic web shooters.
The other problem with the claim lays with only protecting against bullets, which so far we may believe only skill possesses, assuming leerhar is truthful about being captain America and having no action, assuming those who claimed actions are truthful, plus one vanilla townie, knowing hippo or potentially other scum and skill himself of course wouldn't target twoface, 8 or 7 townies have a 1/11 chance of targeting skill, a 50% chance of this being fatal, and for the punisher to be useful he must target the same 1/11 person who by chance targeted the unknown PGO and then dies for his trouble, he may as well just be vanilla...
