ML: I wasn't skimming, i found something that seemed scummy to me and i pointed it out. obviously you didn't get the same whiff i did, but it doesn't mean i was wrong. and w/ all this indecision between / and fircoal i presented another option.
AD: that's the 2nd time in this game you've said i'm not contributing, but i've posted every day(i think anyway). I haven't posted anything since my Selin theory because it was solidly ignored. I contributed the lead i had, not much to say after that.
"You see stars that are clear, have been dead for years…
But the idea, just lives on…" ~ Bright Eyes
gimpyThewonder wrote:ML: I wasn't skimming, i found something that seemed scummy to me and i pointed it out. obviously you didn't get the same whiff i did, but it doesn't mean i was wrong. and w/ all this indecision between / and fircoal i presented another option.
AD: that's the 2nd time in this game you've said i'm not contributing, but i've posted every day(i think anyway). I haven't posted anything since my Selin theory because it was solidly ignored. I contributed the lead i had, not much to say after that.
One post or two a day is not really contributing when there are so many things going on.
You are usually more active than this, is all I am saying. Out of the list I made, you are by far the most talkative.
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
looking at that list again its very unusual for skoffin to be so quiet
Don't now why people on here don't like being cooks, remember under siege: A former SEAL, now cook, is the only person who can stop a gang of terrorists when they sieze control of a US Navy battleship.
gimpyThewonder wrote:ML: I wasn't skimming, i found something that seemed scummy to me and i pointed it out. obviously you didn't get the same whiff i did, but it doesn't mean i was wrong. and w/ all this indecision between / and fircoal i presented another option.
AD: that's the 2nd time in this game you've said i'm not contributing, but i've posted every day(i think anyway). I haven't posted anything since my Selin theory because it was solidly ignored. I contributed the lead i had, not much to say after that.
One post or two a day is not really contributing when there are so many things going on.
You are usually more active than this, is all I am saying. Out of the list I made, you are by far the most talkative.
actually i think this is the most active i've ever been on day 1. don't worry, you'll see moe of me on the later days so you won't have to miss me so much
"You see stars that are clear, have been dead for years…
But the idea, just lives on…" ~ Bright Eyes
gimpyThewonder wrote:ML: I wasn't skimming, i found something that seemed scummy to me and i pointed it out. obviously you didn't get the same whiff i did, but it doesn't mean i was wrong. and w/ all this indecision between / and fircoal i presented another option.
AD: that's the 2nd time in this game you've said i'm not contributing, but i've posted every day(i think anyway). I haven't posted anything since my Selin theory because it was solidly ignored. I contributed the lead i had, not much to say after that.
One post or two a day is not really contributing when there are so many things going on.
You are usually more active than this, is all I am saying. Out of the list I made, you are by far the most talkative.
actually i think this is the most active i've ever been on day 1. don't worry, you'll see moe of me on the later days so you won't have to miss me so much
Good. It's lonely here without you.
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
Well could be a couple things... either RL or the other big game(s). Usually only noob scum are the ones too scared to post so they dont' slip up and/or stay out of the spotlight. Kinda like Ice mentioned earlier. Anyway, I wouldn't read too much into submarining. But if we have to lynch someone and no one else is standing out as scummy, a submariner is the best pick.
wicked wrote:Well could be a couple things... either RL or the other big game(s). Usually only noob scum are the ones too scared to post so they dont' slip up and/or stay out of the spotlight. Kinda like Ice mentioned earlier. Anyway, I wouldn't read too much into submarining. But if we have to lynch someone and no one else is standing out as scummy, a submariner is the best pick.
This goes against everything you ever say in any game I've played with you.
You ALWAYS ask for people to be replaced first. We have two people who are dead who could replace any of those people.
Very odd for you to say that, Wicked.
Very odd indeed.
FOS: Wicked
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
wicked wrote:Well could be a couple things... either RL or the other big game(s). Usually only noob scum are the ones too scared to post so they dont' slip up and/or stay out of the spotlight. Kinda like Ice mentioned earlier. Anyway, I wouldn't read too much into submarining. But if we have to lynch someone and no one else is standing out as scummy, a submariner is the best pick.
This goes against everything you ever say in any game I've played with you.
You ALWAYS ask for people to be replaced first. We have two people who are dead who could replace any of those people.
Very odd for you to say that, Wicked.
Very odd indeed.
FOS: Wicked
Not to mention 3 reserves listed in the first post as well.
wicked wrote:Well could be a couple things... either RL or the other big game(s). Usually only noob scum are the ones too scared to post so they dont' slip up and/or stay out of the spotlight. Kinda like Ice mentioned earlier. Anyway, I wouldn't read too much into submarining. But if we have to lynch someone and no one else is standing out as scummy, a submariner is the best pick.
This goes against everything you ever say in any game I've played with you.
You ALWAYS ask for people to be replaced first. We have two people who are dead who could replace any of those people.
Very odd for you to say that, Wicked.
Very odd indeed.
FOS: Wicked
Nonsense. You're really grasping for anything, eh Ank? Understandable on Day 1. If they weren't participating AT ALL, then yes, replace them by all means. If they're not participating AS MUCH, then they're submarining, and possibly for those reasons I mentioned. Big difference. Usually if an experienced player submarined, it's probably not b/c they're scum is all I'm saying, there's usually something else going on (for example me last week). A noob submarining b/c he's scared to talk is more of a scum tell.
... So a noob submariner would be a good pick for a lynch. 1. b/c they're a noob, 2. b/c there's a slightly greater than average chance they're scum b/c of the "scared to talk" mentality. Sorry if I didn't spell it out clearly in my first post... sometimes my entire thoughts don't make down the neural pathways to the keyboard at the same time, or even at all.
wicked wrote:Well could be a couple things... either RL or the other big game(s). Usually only noob scum are the ones too scared to post so they dont' slip up and/or stay out of the spotlight. Kinda like Ice mentioned earlier. Anyway, I wouldn't read too much into submarining. But if we have to lynch someone and no one else is standing out as scummy, a submariner is the best pick.
This goes against everything you ever say in any game I've played with you.
You ALWAYS ask for people to be replaced first. We have two people who are dead who could replace any of those people.
Very odd for you to say that, Wicked.
Very odd indeed.
FOS: Wicked
Nonsense. You're really grasping for anything, eh Ank? Understandable on Day 1. If they weren't participating AT ALL, then yes, replace them by all means. If they're not participating AS MUCH, then they're submarining, and possibly for those reasons I mentioned. Big difference. Usually if an experienced player submarined, it's probably not b/c they're scum is all I'm saying, there's usually something else going on (for example me last week). A noob submarining b/c he's scared to talk is more of a scum tell.
So what is your definition of at all compared to as much?
Several of the people on that list have posted less than 5 times.
I'd dare say I haven't seen Dustn post at all.
Also, I don't really feel that any of the people on that list were 'noobs'. They may not have the experience some others have, but they have all played in other games.
I'm not grasping. What you said goes against things you have said in the past. It looks suspicious.
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
OK Nag, can we get prods and/or replacements for those not posting?? Dustn, Skoffin, Exile. Anyone else Ank? Oh and Spurg-somebody? (sorry going from memory and I don't know that person)
wicked wrote:OK Nag, can we get prods and/or replacements for those not posting?? Dustn, Skoffin, Exile. Anyone else Ank? Oh and Spurg-somebody? (sorry going from memory and I don't know that person)
I think those four are the main ones I am surprised aren't contributing.
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
p.s... I can't even remember what I said yesterday, let alone in a game long long ago with you in a galaxy far far away. I do know I've always asked for replacements for absent people, and I still do. I wasn't talking about absentees in my previous post(s). Everyone is grasping around looking for a firsy day sacrifice, so I suggested a submarining noob. OMG!!! That's what happens most games, so what's the big deal? Let's move on...
Skoffin played an RT mafia game today. She is active, just not posting. Exile, spurgistan and dustn may be worthy of replacements, however EXILE and DUSTN are browsing this forum right now. [/b]
im gonna be honest...since about page 50 ive waited for this day to end...
Theres been meaningful things said, and i am glad that they are there and the discussion was reasonable. I dont really have anything to add to the exploits of / as ive thought fircoal was the best target for a lynch for about 20 pages (im just guessing at the number). The back and forth of explaination has i think crossed a point where although relevant it is no longer continuing to be meaningful.
