Quentin Tarantino Mafia Night 3 (Mafia Win!)

[safariguy5]

Roles and Night Actions

The fakeclaims for mafia and third party are in parentheses

Town (11)
Hugo Stieglitz-Town Bomb-Haggis_McMutton
Max Cherry-Town Jailkeeper-karelpietertje (Killed Day 2)
Earl McGraw-Town Cop-edocsil (Killed Night 3)
Edgar McGraw-Town Deputy-VioIet (Lynched Day 1)
Mr. Orange-Town Miller-Fircoal (Killed Night 2)
Mr. White-Town Doctor-mandalorian2298 replaced by Commander9 replaced by naxus (Killed Night 3)
Butch Coolidge-Vanilla Townie-colton24 (Killed Night 1)
Shosanna Dreyfus-Town Lover-aage (Killed Night 2)
Mr. Brown- Vanilla Townie-FloresDelMal replaced by ga7 (Lynched Day 3)
Jules Winnfield- Town Governor-lalaland replaced by strike wolf
Hattori Hanzo- Vanilla Townie-MeDeFe (Killed Night 1)

Third Party (1)
Mr. Blonde-Third Party Serial Killer (The Bride-Town Vigilante)-TA1LGUNN3R

Mafia (4)
Bill-Mafia Godfather (Aldo Raines-Bulletproof Bodyguard)-Army of GOD replaced by Victor Sullivan
Stuntman Mike-Mafia Busdriver (Jackie Brown-Town Survivor)-pmchugh replaced by VioIet replaced by Dlanor A. Knox
Fredrick Zoller-Mafia Lover (Marcel-Town Lover)-spurgistan (Killed Night 2)
Elle Driver-Mafia Framer (Zoe-Town Sensor)-nagerous

Night Actions:

Night 1
tailgunner kills MeDeFe
edocsil investigates pmchugh
nagerous frames edocsil
mandy protects ga7
karelpietertje jails edocsil
AoG kills colton

Night 2
naxus protects ga7
edocsil investigates ga7
tails kills spurgistan
nagerous frames aage
Victor kills fircoal

Night 3
edocsil investigates Victor Sullivan
Knox drives edocsil and nagerous
Victor kills naxus
tails kills nagerous

[strike wolf]

I take full responsibility for this loss...I didn't put my full effort into this game and it lead to a bad lynch day 3 whicxh I could have stopped... :s

[Dlanor A. Knox]

There you go Nag and Victor. That's my favor to you guys, done for Skoffin.

Good Game Town <3 It was fun, nanodesu~

[safariguy5]

Notes and Explanations

I did make a mistake in letting VioIet replace a player after edocsil had already told her his role. I completely forgot this, so I'm sorry for that. After edocsil brought this up in pm I had already let her replace so I had to hope that she had forgotten.

Nice fakeclaim there nag, I'm impressed.

As some people have speculated, the characters are not judged on a hard line of good and bad, if that were true, then I would have hardly had any true townies. Mr. White was the doctor because he was trying to save Mr. Orange's life (We need to get him to the hospital!). I had to put Mr. Brown in because it is Quentin Tarantino Mafia no? In my point of view, Orange was the miller because he was trying to play the bad guy while really being the good guy. If I had to choose a mafia member from Resevoir Dogs, it probably would be Nice Guy Eddie or his dad.

My goodness tails nearly got so excited in the beginning that he almost gave himself away.

I put a bunch of VT's in because I knew that we were going to lose at least 2 players a night and I wanted to give the town power roles a chance. For the most part, the VT's were the ones killed first, but I was a bit dissapointed that the SK didn't get any mafia members besides the lovers, and nobody hit the bomb.

That was a clutch busdrive by Knox, well played.

Only 1 person had his fakeclaim tested, but Victor was just able to convince everyone that he was legit. Aldo would be bulletproof to me because he's just 1 of two of the Basterds to survive, and he ends up guarding people (The Jew Hunter, the Actress).

[Dlanor A. Knox]

You did a wonderful job, Mod.

You deserve a congratulations for hosting a well run game (albeit with a small error, but no one ever is perfect, and you were able to rebound it).

[Dlanor A. Knox]

Also, to those who found me to be arrogant:

Gomen Nasai!

I was just playing a part that I needed to do. Replacing into an already passive game, that had to resort to a deadline lynch on day 2 was going to be a challenge. I didn't want to end up in the situation where I had my back against the wall, and was trying to pull off a miracle with no time to do so. I had to be direct and confident, so people would get interested in doing something and making discussion.

Regarding Haggis, I knew he couldn't be a VT simply by the way he posted. No VT defends his claim that hard. It had to be fake, which is why I pushed it. (Too bad it was a bomb @_@)

I would have liked to enter this game and played as myself, and been nice a chat to everyone, but it wasn't what the situation called for. :S

But aggressive scum in a passive town gets overlooked, especially when people continue to write it off as arrogance.

I hope you guys don't hold it against me, I would like to play again with all of you, nipah~

-Dlanor

[strike wolf]

I would have pressed vio more if edoc hadn't said anything...and following that quick wagon on ga7 I was pretty sure knox and nag were mafia but well...should have stopped the lynch...could have stopped the lynch...failed to stop the lynch...

[edocsil]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

[nagerous]

Notes and Explanations



That was a clutch busdrive by Knox, well played.

That was my idea Would also save me from a potential investigation.

[naxus]

*note to self.....kill victor first day, everygame

But besides that well played mafia

[safariguy5]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

Yeah, I remembered after reading your pm and was like...oh crap....

[Dlanor A. Knox]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

Yeah, I remembered after reading your pm and was like...oh crap....

Note that I was never given this information. I only knew you were cop based upon your claim of such.

[edocsil]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

Yeah, I remembered after reading your pm and was like...oh crap....

Note that I was never given this information. I only knew you were cop based upon your claim of such.

A little part of me just died.


Wait, OK, it came back to life at least a little there. Vio never had a chance to act on that knowledge, she was playing when I claimed.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Yeah about N2 I realized that I had to kill some mafs because town was already dwindled. Didn't pan out too well, unfortunately. Only scum I got was spurgistan, but he was a lover, so that came back to bite me.

So Strike and ga7 you were pretty spot on to not trust me.

-Tails

[Haggis_McMutton]

Regarding Haggis, I knew he couldn't be a VT simply by the way he posted. No VT defends his claim that hard. It had to be fake, which is why I pushed it. (Too bad it was a bomb @_@)

Actually, i didn't know i was a bomb. My pm just said VT. And when we're likely at lylo I will defend my claim that hard.

Anyway, well played, really didn't think you were scum(maybe because i don't know your play style).

But yeah town, 3 doctors, how the hell could you guys buy that?
Eh, doesn't matter, I screwed up as well, was too lazy in this game.

[Skoffin]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

Yeah, I remembered after reading your pm and was like...oh crap....

If violet knew someone elses role then what was she doing volunteering to replace anyway?
I'm also curious as to that blowup over Knox's replacing earlier.

Well, it's been a fun read for the past few days.

[Victor Sullivan]

GO MAFIaZZZZzZZ!!!

[Victor Sullivan]

*note to self.....kill victor first day, everygame

But besides that well played mafia

I resent this. Everyone always thinks I'm mafia, I swear. At one time I was accused of being mafia in 4 games, simultaneously, and for the same reasons, at that. I was only mafia in half of them, if that tells you anything

[safariguy5]

Regarding Haggis, I knew he couldn't be a VT simply by the way he posted. No VT defends his claim that hard. It had to be fake, which is why I pushed it. (Too bad it was a bomb @_@)

Actually, i didn't know i was a bomb. My pm just said VT. And when we're likely at lylo I will defend my claim that hard.

Anyway, well played, really didn't think you were scum(maybe because i don't know your play style).

But yeah town, 3 doctors, how the hell could you guys buy that?
Eh, doesn't matter, I screwed up as well, was too lazy in this game.

I don't usually tell my bombs they are bombs. Just like a miller shouldn't know he's a miller.

[safariguy5]

Gah, and saf did give my identity to the mafia...

Yeah, I remembered after reading your pm and was like...oh crap....

If violet knew someone elses role then what was she doing volunteering to replace anyway?
I'm also curious as to that blowup over Knox's replacing earlier.

Well, it's been a fun read for the past few days.

She was unhappy about being replaced because she was actively submarining and knew mafia were close to winning. I had no idea she was deliberately submarining and replaced her because I thought she was inactive. Breakdown of communication there.

[ga7]

I refrained to comment this because it pissed me off but besides town sucking I gotta say this must be the first time I see scum having more powers than town in a game where they were balanced in proportion.
Else Tails you cocky SK Figured you weren't mafia at the end but wouldn't have put my money on SK.

[safariguy5]

I refrained to comment this because it pissed me off but besides town sucking I gotta say this must be the first time I see scum having more powers than town in a game where they were balanced in proportion.
Else Tails you cocky SK Figured you weren't mafia at the end but wouldn't have put my money on SK.

According to the roles, I gave town a cop, doc, deputy, jailkeeper, and governor. Mafia had busdriver and framer. 1 town/mafia lover combination, 1 sker, 1 bomb and 1 miller. Should I have given town more power roles?

[ga7]

Consider the town cop had to deal with a mafia busdriver, a framer, a miller and a gf. That highly limitates his usefulness.
Deputy is not an active role and wouldn't have helped either considering that.
So we had a doc, a governor, a bomb and a jailkeeper that could be remotely useful. The mafia powers were huge, busdriver is as good as GF, framer is perfect to cause mislynches... So yeah, you could have made it NV and still town might not have been strong enough lol

[strike wolf]

Yeah again my apologies...I really screwed that up...I should have stopped the lynch but I hesitated. Honestly I thought the deadline was coming up and not thinking we would get a lynch no matter what put forward a third option. I was honestly stunned with how fast the bandwagon developed and I should have stopped it but I hesitated for a few minutes and by that point it was too late...I cracked under pressure...

[safariguy5]

Consider the town cop had to deal with a mafia busdriver, a framer, a miller and a gf. That highly limitates his usefulness.
Deputy is not an active role and wouldn't have helped either considering that.
So we had a doc, a governor, a bomb and a jailkeeper that could be remotely useful. The mafia powers were huge, busdriver is as good as GF, framer is perfect to cause mislynches... So yeah, you could have made it NV and still town might not have been strong enough lol

Noted. It was the first time I put a third party SKer in the game so I wasn't sure how to account for that. If tails had got lucky and hit the GF night one or something, I don't know whether mafia would have survived.