[GO] Ninja Spoils/Espionage Spoils

[edwinissweet]

oh ok, i see what you mean. i didnt know that about spoils, but yes i supposse that would be the idea

[Mr_Adams]

As a fan of nuclear spoils, I think logically people will also like the exact opposite.

When you turn in a set of spoils, you take over the territories. I would like to see it where you inherit however many troops are already on the region. Or you could just take over the territory and be given an automatic two.

As for the name, what about revolution? as if you are urging the citizens of a territory to revolt, and they then come to your side?

[Queen_Herpes]

Just for clarification, what is it that happens to territories that YOU own when YOU cash a set that includes territories you own? I vote that there would be either an additional 2 armies dropped on those territories, or Option 3. Options 1 and 2 would be punitive to the player turning in a set of spoils who owns territories in those spoils.

[Gorby]

You could call in "Chaos" spoils.

[pmchugh]

Just for clarification, what is it that happens to territories that YOU own when YOU cash a set that includes territories you own? I vote that there would be either an additional 2 armies dropped on those territories, or Option 3. Options 1 and 2 would be punitive to the player turning in a set of spoils who owns territories in those spoils.

i agree with +2 on the territ you own, the worst thing about nuclear spoils is hiitting yourself, waht idiot nukes themselves?

[Queen_Herpes]

edwin, when this run-off poll is finished, there should probably be two more discussions:

-some kind of discussion as to whether any additional armies are awarded to the player turning in a set of ninja spoils to be placed anywhere on the map.

-a discussion as to what happens to already owned territories on a spoil when the ninja spoils are played.

Since the OP isnt around i guess i'll have to be the one to edit the post. I dont think we should have a poll for every idea brought forward. i dont think that extra armies should be awarded, that kind of takes away from it in my opinion.

For the second one we might hve to make a poll to decide if a +2 should be added, or if nothing happens

[Queen_Herpes]

As a fan of nuclear spoils, I think logically people will also like the exact opposite.

When you turn in a set of spoils, you take over the territories. I would like to see it where you inherit however many troops are already on the region. Or you could just take over the territory and be given an automatic two.



edwin edit
The poll will run for a week then we will decide which version we should submit.

This needs more overall votes...

[edwinissweet]

dont let the discussion die out guys. Its a good idea, but there are alot of things left to be decided.

[army of nobunaga]

this is a stupid Idea based off of those fixiated of japanese cartoons... there are 10000's of great ideas in this forum..
I pride myself on playing every game..

I swear to GOD and there is no god. But I swear ill never play a ninja shit on this site... so stupid.


you ppl... there are SO MANY IDEAS ive read the last two years.... ninja spoils as a sticky


f*ck i may leave cc actually.

[edwinissweet]

Maybe you should read the suggestion. The name is just that, the name. It actually has very little to do with the actual game play. That tells me that you arent giving feedback about the suggestion, but actually just trolling. So stop trolling, please.

[army of nobunaga]

Mod Edit.... I renamed my thread.. thanx.. will you lock that too?

[Queen_Herpes]

Is there a winner with this run off poll? Can we move onto deciding what happens to spoils associated with territories you already own when you turn in the set?

[edwinissweet]

Im just the discussion moderator.. i dont "ok" the ideas. It needs community support and discussion. The interest in this seems to have died, so i'll have to unsticky it. I cant move something along just because i like it

[Queen_Herpes]

Im just the discussion moderator.. i dont "ok" the ideas. It needs community support and discussion. The interest in this seems to have died, so i'll have to unsticky it. I cant move something along just because i like it

exactly. What was the result of the poll?

[edwinissweet]

22-18 in favor of standart 3 armies

[00iCon]

Looks like a clear winner!
Now onto the extra armies disussion. I say 3 red spoils = 0 extra troops
3 green = 2 extra troops
3 blue = 4 extra troops
RGB = 6 extra troops
This is on top of any bonus troops to be deployed, on any territory including Ninja'd territories.
If you hand in on your own territory, you get 3 on that territory, no matter if it was 1 or 100 before.
Anyone with me?

[edwinissweet]

idk. i think its getting way to complicated

[Queen_Herpes]

How about if they were called "highjack" spoils?

[Army of GOD]

What happened to this suggestion?

I always thought it'd be like Nuclear spoils, but instead of the territs becoming neutral, they became your color (as 1s).

[edwinissweet]

that was the idea, but it got too complicated and interest died

[Army of GOD]

that was the idea, but it got too complicated and interest died

Why'd get it get "complicated"? The idea is so basically simple. What's with this poll and other stuff?

[edwinissweet]

Well, people disagreed on what they wanted out of it. To me the simple idea would be to simply get the territory and the armies on it as your own with no alteration if you own the place. But thats just what i me. Too many people want something different and it never really got past the name.

[00iCon]

It doesn't bug me too much if it's not the way I saw it. The concept itself is worth implementing.

[greenoaks]

Revolution Spoils


Concise description:

• When a set is cashed the territories on those cards that you don't control revolt

Specifics/Details:

• Cashing a spoil gives you that territory with whatever troops were on it
  or
• Cashing a spoil gives you that territory with half of whatever troops were on it, rounded down, minimum of 1

How this will benefit the site and/or other comments:

• This will alter the way troops are deployed in games. It has similarities with Nuclear in that you are concerned you could lose the troops if an opponent cashes but with this game type the troops don't disappear, they can be used against you.

[IcePack]

Sounds fun