PLAYER57832 wrote:thegreekdog wrote:The overall point here is that some people are taxed out of proportion to their overall wealth (as tzor puts it) because of the way our federal income tax system works. I don't make as much money as investment bankers, but I really get squeezed... enough that I've been thinking about a career change because it's not worth it anymore.
So, when I hear people saying we have to punish the fatcats and the rich, I want to know what their definition of "rich" is. Because some of the "rich" people are getting punished enough.
No, the people getting taxed are wage earners. Those making money off investments, real estate, inheritances, etc are not paying near as much in taxes as the rest. For one thing, there are plenty of loopholes.
Mostly, its only when you try to take a paycheck, be it from wages or cashing dividend checks to spend, etc, that you wind up paying taxes. You can accrue lots of wealth and power without paying a dime if you simply reinvest it. AND, because so many things are allowed as "legitimate business expenses", you can live pretty decently without showing much or any income. That is even without the games people play like shoving money offshore, etc.
Yes, Player, I agree... and that's pretty much what I've said in my previous posts in this forum - wage-earners (and salary-earners) that make a whole bunch of money pay a whole bunch of taxes. Also, when you get a check (as an employee, dividend earner, whatever) you're taxed on it. There is no, "Oh, I got this paycheck, let me move it overseas." That's not true. What you do have are people, usually business owners, who have money overseas and try to repatriate the money back to the U.S. without paying taxes. That can no longer occur. Even further, if you reinvest money, you cannot use that money without being taxed on it. You can hold it, certainly, and not be taxed on it, but eventually you will be taxed on it.
So, as an example, if I get a $3,000 paycheck, I get taxes taken out of that (withheld) at the federal, state, and perhaps local level. I take whatever is left (let's say it's $1,800). Now, I can take that money and pay my school loans and interest on the school loans (which is no longer deductible because I make too much money), but I don't do the realistic thing. Instead, I invest in the stock market. If I get dividends, they are taxed, if I sell my stock, it is taxed. In effect, I'm taxed at least twice on the same money.
Anyway, I digressed a lot here. My point is that unless you really are wealthy (and not just some schlub making a good salary), you're screwed by taxes. Absolutely screwed.