Pokemon Endgame: Mafia Victory + jonty

[shieldgenerator7]

This lack of activity necessitates a reread of the thread to find a case. Will post later.

[ShaggyDan]

Thinking that this is a huge cult game I have a theory. Mafia can either get a kill or a recruit a night(GF Kill). This is based purely on flavor text from the night scenes. Assuming that they started out with with 2 possibly 3 members at the beginning they Must've started recruiting N1. Now Shaggy brought up that it's unlikely that someone could be recruited, gain powers, and then use said powers. But if thats the mechanic the mod chose universally then its a possibility. With Hanks earlier question of Mafia alliance they sticks out pretty hard but Lala did a good job of making up for Hanks mistakes. But Combined with the fact of Freezies claim of Miller(Which from a mod standpoint I would never tell the person they were) Seems like they could have been the starting mafia. Lala being the GF with freezie being a goon/some sort(Thinking that mafia would start with 2+ members just incase the SK got incredibly lucky.) If they recruited Evil Chaos N1 then he poisoned Oak N1 Makikarp N2 and someone N3.

@Underlined section #1: I just find it unlikely because the recruiter could send in their action after the pokemon that was recruited has already targetted someone. Though I guess it is possible. I would think they would find out they are recruited after the day phase (probably throughout the next day phase or maybe even the next night phase) making it tricky to trace kills / voting patterns back to scum.

@Underlined section #2: I've been told in a PM I was miller before. And it makes sense coming out on day one as a miller to have a start point. That said; I'm not sure whether mafia would fake-claim miller or not. I would say if our vig is short on targets that the miller claim is a good idea, or if they do something scum-like it could be an addition to the case. Though for now with the time we have left I do agree that there isn't a lot we can do.

On the case of lala: it is entirely possible that a double voter is also a scum character. Though I would say more unlikely.

On the case of freezie: miller is a claim difficult to back up. In a speed lynch situation I'd be happy to vote the miller (though we have already had a cop death so it really might not matter). Even though the behaviour hasn't swung me to an allignment either way, in a bind it makes a good target. For now it doesn't look like it would be support for it. I really hope tomorrow we have some better cases to go off.

All I've really gotten out of today is that we have a town-busdriver, a charizard that has been recruited(possibly good or evil), a (probably) anti-town thief and someone who will die from poison tonight.

[DoomYoshi]

This is a very low activity game I thought it would've generated more interest than this.

Anyways, BGtheBrain has replaced Commander. Maybe some people could take it upon themselves to coach him, and hopefully this will provide some interest in the game

[Rodion]

This is a very low activity game I thought it would've generated more interest than this.

Anyways, BGtheBrain has replaced Commander. Maybe some people could take it upon themselves to coach him, and hopefully this will provide some interest in the game

I'm sorry. It's not that I don't have interest in the game, it's just that the setup you created (filled with 3rd parties being recruited) makes it too hard for us to find any leads. I'm completely lost as far as finding scum goes.

Our cop getting modkilled didn't help.

[Rodion]

I think deadline is tomorrow. I don't have anything strong against anyone, but if people want to pursue a lynch, here are the options I (barely) see in no particular order.

1 - Freezie - claimed town miller
2 - Lalaland - if we consider the doublevoter question to be a legit attempt at hiding his pro-town power role, we only have the mafia alliance comment against him
3 - Fircoal - claims to be a town bus driver that got robbed right when we needed a bus driver the most. Had a chance to swap himself on N3 to avoid having his power stolen AGAIN, but got lazy/forgetful and didn't use his power
4 - Victor Sullivan - claims to have been recruited. On the night he performed his NK, the Water Gun pokémon did not. Makes me wonder whether there is a godfather deciding who makes the kills and he decided to rest "Blastoise" for Charizard

As I said, I don't feel there is enough evidence to get anyone lynched, but if the consensus is that we need to lynch someone (which makes sense statistically), I'd vote on any of those (whoever is closer to being lynched).

[Victor Sullivan]

...So vote any of the claimed townies? Vote Rodion. Yeah, I don't think so...

-Sully

[BGtheBrain]

****

[shieldgenerator7]

Vote BGtheBrain welcome to the game!

I think we should pursue Mr. Squirrel. he got cuaght up in two lies, one that helped make lala look scummy, and one that made me look scummy. I think he's trying to cast suspicion on townies so he can start bandwagons without much suspicion.
Unvote Vote Mr. Squirrel

[jonty125]

Our cop getting modkilled didn't help.

Well you guys were up for lynching me anyway so I may not have lasted much longer

[Rodion]

Our cop getting modkilled didn't help.

Well you guys were up for lynching me anyway so I may not have lasted much longer

You don't understand how important a claim of cop is. If you're a cop and you get to L-1 (but I prefer L-2) you can claim and easily get rid of that lynch, UNLESS someone is willing to counterclaim you. The good thing (it's kind of bittersweet) about being counterclaimed, in this case, is that after you are lynched and people confirm you were the cop, the person that counterclaimed can easily die (and is probably anti-town, unless there are multiple cops out there).

[DoomYoshi]

This is a very low activity game I thought it would've generated more interest than this.

Anyways, BGtheBrain has replaced Commander. Maybe some people could take it upon themselves to coach him, and hopefully this will provide some interest in the game

I'm sorry. It's not that I don't have interest in the game, it's just that the setup you created (filled with 3rd parties being recruited) makes it too hard for us to find any leads. I'm completely lost as far as finding scum goes.

Our cop getting modkilled didn't help.

Point Noted. The Mistake will not be repeated again. Votes for dead players will not be counted.

Vote Count:

jimfinn (1) - nagerous
freezie (1) - jonty125
Rodion (1) - Victor Sullivan

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch

Deadline in 1 day.

[jonty125]

Vote Count:

jimfinn (1) - nagerous
freezie (1) - jonty125
Rodion (1) - Victor Sullivan

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch

Deadline in 1 day.

I have already done this but unvote

[BGtheBrain]

****

[BGtheBrain]

****

[nagerous]

Vote BGtheBrain welcome to the game!

I think we should pursue Mr. Squirrel. he got cuaght up in two lies, one that helped make lala look scummy, and one that made me look scummy. I think he's trying to cast suspicion on townies so he can start bandwagons without much suspicion.
Unvote Vote Mr. Squirrel

He be dead


unvote vote bg the brain

no lynch be scummy FOOL!

[BGtheBrain]

****

[jonty125]

y u be trippin?

Huh?

[BGtheBrain]

****

[jonty125]

y u be trippin?

Huh?

Sorry, that was in reference to

I'm indicating I can't understand the post

[BGtheBrain]

****

[jonty125]

Negerous said "no lynch be scummy FOOL!"
I responded in ebonics with "y u be trippin?"

Trippin: "When someone is overreacting or getting all bent out of shape over something small."

Considering im new to mafia games I felt that Nagerous calling me scummy would be an overreaction. Actually his reaction makes me want to vote for him, not out of spite, but because he was quick to vote for me. This seems like something a mafia member would do to try to get a lynch vote on the new guy.

vote Nagerous

I wouldn't call voting a no lynch small but I am suprised nag did vote for you which does raise my concerns.

[nagerous]

OMGUS AKA OH MY GOSH U SUCK

OH MY GOSH U SUCK

OH MY GOSH U SUCK

Vote stands scummy mcscummerson

no lynch when there is a possible mafia cult developing and building power?

You cannot be serious monsieur!

[BGtheBrain]

****

[shieldgenerator7]

what Mr. Squirrel died? ok, maybe I should remember what I read... I don't skim but I selectively remember.

[Victor Sullivan]

(I still think Rodion is a SCUMZOR)

-Sully