DD is either a complete idiot or really bad at playing as mafia. Not going to reply to that. But I don't like your posts (probably because you're deflecting cases on mtamb/aog onto the claimed doc but that's none of my business).
I have scum reads on:
AoG, mtamb and DD. I used to have one on IB but both wing and HS flipping town really screwed with me.
Mtamb has annoyed me all game with his lack of giving a crap when asked something and I finally get a chance to say "screw you, claim!". vote mtamb. I think rishead has been playing well and I've understood every single one of his votes.
I have townie reads on:
Strikewolf, IB (barely but I do), Mets, virus and rishead.
persianempire wrote:its when ur food goes bad... you get spoils
StorrZerg wrote:how is it that i think no one is defending or town reading AoG
And more than half the players in the game scum read him, yet i hold the only vote on him.
I think mtamb' claim would be more of a discussion maker. Game's been getting pretty dead. I'd be ok with an AoG lynch but I think mtamb needs to claim, then we see if he is worth lynching. AoG is plan B in my mind.
persianempire wrote:its when ur food goes bad... you get spoils
StorrZerg wrote:how is it that i think no one is defending or town reading AoG
And more than half the players in the game scum read him, yet i hold the only vote on him.
I think mtamb' claim would be more of a discussion maker. Game's been getting pretty dead. I'd be ok with an AoG lynch but I think mtamb needs to claim, then we see if he is worth lynching. AoG is plan B in my mind.
Then all you are doing is rolefishing and just basing your read on whether or not you like my role which is honestly retarded
MY suspicions of an assasin being in the game are considerably low right now since the start of the day, Im more inclined to see 2 scum teams so they will have to kill eachother in the night for any of them to survive.
Im almost comfortable claiming as it will explain why I wanted hotshot dead even more so after he claimed and why I wanted to lynch NOS very early in the day but then backed off.
Having this information is how i concluded that If i can personally roleblock/save someone then there had to be an SK in the game based on the fact I could roleblock their ability to kill and also made me think that there could be 2 scum teams and 1 person from each team could be sending someone to make the kills.
Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
strike wolf wrote:Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Strike could you please link that or let us know what page Mtam made that statement about third party.
I have played in games with jailkeeper, doc and blocker so not impossible.
strike wolf wrote:Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Strike could you please link that or let us know what page Mtam made that statement about third party.
I have played in games with jailkeeper, doc and blocker so not impossible.
Mtam who did you jail keep night one and why??
Really? I put my action on NoS because I thought he was scum. At the time I would hope to catch him in a slip up but after some questions were answered about game semantics i immediately backed off.
strike wolf wrote:Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Strike could you please link that or let us know what page Mtam made that statement about third party.
I have played in games with jailkeeper, doc and blocker so not impossible.
Mtam who did you jail keep night one and why??
Really? I put my action on NoS because I thought he was scum. At the time I would hope to catch him in a slip up but after some questions were answered about game semantics i immediately backed off.
How convenient that you blocked the person who we already know tried to save someone that wasn't going to die.
strike wolf wrote:Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Strike could you please link that or let us know what page Mtam made that statement about third party.
I have played in games with jailkeeper, doc and blocker so not impossible.
Mtam who did you jail keep night one and why??
Really? I put my action on NoS because I thought he was scum. At the time I would hope to catch him in a slip up but after some questions were answered about game semantics i immediately backed off.
How convenient that you blocked the person who we already know tried to save someone that wasn't going to die.