GODFATHER MAFIA - FINALLY OVER! CORLEONES WIN!!!

[rebelman]

[quote="nagerous"]It is August 1945, the war is over and the Corleone family are at the height of their power. Unfortunately, in doing so they have succeeded in entering a bitter street-war with the Barzini family and have made a number of enemies along the way.

AD this post on page 1 tells us the barzini family are the other scum family, but if you were a member of the barzini family you would wan to hide that

unvote

[Anarkistsdream]

It is August 1945, the war is over and the Corleone family are at the height of their power. Unfortunately, in doing so they have succeeded in entering a bitter street-war with the Barzini family and have made a number of enemies along the way.

AD this post on page 1 tells us the barzini family are the other scum family, but if you were a member of the barzini family you would wan to hide that

unvote

Well, I'm not a member of the Barzini family, which is why I didn't believe they were the enemy of the Corleone's.

And I see you take the last thing I say and post about it, but you have nothing to say about the rest?

This is complete stupidity. I have helped the town, voted where I THOUGHT appropriate for the TOWN to win, not any scum family.

I really hope enuogh of you can see that.

[firth4eva]

Just remember that I have said he was scum before all of this, and if you let him get away with killing me, you will all be screwing yourself over.

This last part here sounded VERY fucking scummy. A lot like wicked's defence actually. unvote vote AD

This is also because Selin makes avery compelling argument. Not because of that part alone.

[Clive]

3) AD: "This is very true. What is also true is that McClusky is the most evil sonofabitch around. Fircoal even admitted that was his name! I can't believe that the town wouldn't vote to lynch the guy who has said he was one of the most corrupt cops in New York!
Unvote
I think Fircoal should be lynched, and we see what comes of it. McClusky was NEVER a pro-town cop in the book or movie."
>> Conclusion: AD gives all the reasons to vote Fircoal, but doesn't vote him. He is trying to get some more votes on Fircoal without bringing himself on the vote list yet.

This is the only one you bring up that makes me doubt AD. But for the moment, it's not enough to outwiegh what i've seen as honest pro-town play.

And I don't see how high activity can be used as a point against him.

Day vigs occur when Nag gets on, not when the killer is online to submit it, so i don't think we can draw any conclusions about that that way. The only case that comes ot mind if is someone's known to be absent for a preiod of time around the kill, it would clear them...

[Clive]

Admittely, I don't like the way he says (something along the lines of) "I think Selin is scum but I won't vote him cos I don't wanna be accused of OMGUS".

I thinks that nonesense, and if thought someone was scum as AD suggests i'd vote them regardless...

[firth4eva]

Admittely, I don't like the way he says (something along the lines of) "I think Selin is scum but I won't vote him cos I don't wanna be accused of OMGUS".

That's because he can't fucking vote.

[kalishnikov]

Selin does make a few good points about AD however I've played a number of games with AD as scum and been scum with AD a few times, and this isn't his style. When he's scum he's a classic submariner, always lurking but never posting. Also I think if AD was scum he would have showed some sort of connection with someone one way or another considering his amount of posts in this game and I don't see that. If anything, I'd say he looks third party but I'm far from convinced that our priority should be lynching miscellaneous unaligned fellows (unless he's an SK, which I also doubt, far to active for that) when we've still got a fully-staffed second scum family about.

Am I defending AD? Not so much, I'm just saying that we really should try and hit one of the aforementioned second family-types today and I don't think he's it. And for the record, I do think AD looks slightly scummy, thus my earlier FOS...

Oh and another reason to not kill him right now is he is by far the most knowledgeable player as far as the storyline is concerned and that could help us a great bit. He can be a fall-back lynch to end the day, thats fine, but I'm not sure he's scum at the moment and I really think we should end this day by hitting someone from that other family.

[Clive]

Admittely, I don't like the way he says (something along the lines of) "I think Selin is scum but I won't vote him cos I don't wanna be accused of OMGUS".

That's because he can't fucking vote.

Lol, i'd completely forgotten.

I retract that statement...

[icedagger]

Nah he can vote now WIcked's dead.. I think

[Clive]

No, apparantly Wicked still controls the vote despite being dead.

[mandalorian2298]

Selin does make a few good points about AD however I've played a number of games with AD as scum and been scum with AD a few times, and this isn't his style. When he's scum he's a classic submariner, always lurking but never posting. Also I think if AD was scum he would have showed some sort of connection with someone one way or another considering his amount of posts in this game and I don't see that. If anything, I'd say he looks third party but I'm far from convinced that our priority should be lynching miscellaneous unaligned fellows (unless he's an SK, which I also doubt, far to active for that) when we've still got a fully-staffed second scum family about.

Am I defending AD? Not so much, I'm just saying that we really should try and hit one of the aforementioned second family-types today and I don't think he's it. And for the record, I do think AD looks slightly scummy, thus my earlier FOS...
Oh and another reason to not kill him right now is he is by far the most knowledgeable player as far as the storyline is concerned and that could help us a great bit. He can be a fall-back lynch to end the day, thats fine, but I'm not sure he's scum at the moment and I really think we should end this day by hitting someone from that other family.

Nark NEVER subamarrines. If he's on-line, he will always write something, no matter his alligance. Also, being a good player, he always come out equaly aggressive.

The reason why I colored your post is to show that you offer 5 separate reasons why Nark shouldn't be lynched. To quote my favorite TV show: "The only reason to provide multiple reasons is that you're fishing for one that will sound plausible." If Nark is a non-Corleone Scum, then I am sure that Kalish is also a member of the non-Corleone Mafia.

SFOS Kalish

[Anarkistsdream]

Just remember that I have said he was scum before all of this, and if you let him get away with killing me, you will all be screwing yourself over.

This last part here sounded VERY fucking scummy. A lot like wicked's defence actually. unvote vote AD

This is also because Selin makes avery compelling argument. Not because of that part alone.

No... Wickeds defense was to bash and attack people and name call.

I don't think anyone here is stupid. I just think there are better targets than a townie that has helped everyone out.

[firth4eva]

But are you just playing the helpful townie role to trick us? I'm unsure but a vote on you now isn't much pressure. If thins get more intense I might take it off.

[Anarkistsdream]

But are you just playing the helpful townie role to trick us? I'm unsure but a vote on you now isn't much pressure. If thins get more intense I might take it off.

If I wanted ANYBODY else but the town to win, why would I out so many scum? Wouldn't it make more sense to go after townies and then let the scum fight it out at the end?

I am NOT, I repeat NOT, trying to cause the town to lose. I have been pulling for this side the whole time, and, obviously, that is because I am town.

I haven't been verbally abusive, which I often am. I am trying to think things through rationally and cool. If I wanted town to lose, I would not be trying to help.

I also would not have done the things I have been accused of by Selin. Of course I post as soon as the day scene goes up. As Mandy just wrote above, I NEVER submarine. I always post.

But if I was a daykiller or member of the scum, I would try and at least lay low.

I'm not that great of a BSer, guys.

[Iliad]

I know that if AD comes up scum I will be eating these words : but I don't think AD is scum, Selin's point isn't that great though I don't think wicked would be dumb enough to out her mafia partner

[Talapus]

In all honesty, if we want to take out scum we need to focus on a few of the players lying low. I know I'm kinda in that caterogory, but because I'm still only good for casting half a vote and don't even know what side I'm on, I'm assuming the other teenagers are in the same boat as me. But, there are a few people in this game that have done a great job of popping in once or twice a game day, casting a vote, then disappearing again. These are the people we need to focus on if we plan on lynching scum. That and the fact that no other mafia family besides the Corleones has suffered a kill yet is not good for the rest of us. I'll look back in a bit and see if I can compile a list. I think it is extremely likely that the person who offed wicked was online at that time but didn't post in the thread, but that's just a though.

[Anarkistsdream]

Because I always do this, even though it apparently makes me look scummy


6. Riggable
13. Teen Skittles!
15. Skoffin
16. Spurgistan
17. CrabNebula
19. Serbia
25. Neutrino x
30. Militant
34. Dustn x



These are the people who posted three times or less...

Riggable is at 3, and so is Militant and Skoffin.

However, THESE are the people that don't talk, don't give reasons why they're voting, or plain just don't participate at all.

Out of these, I do not believe Dustn has posted AT ALL.

Serbia and Spurg each have one or two.

Why?

[Clive]

I'm always happy to pressure a submariner...Dustn hasn't posted at all you say...

vote Dustn

[mandalorian2298]

I'm always happy to pressure a submariner...Dustn hasn't posted at all you say...

vote Dustn

Mod, could you replace Dustn. He always does this.

[rebelman]

seems very unlike skoffin to be submarining

[Talapus]

seems very unlike skoffin to be submarining

Naw, seems just like her . Anyway, I want to pressure spurgistan because I can and I think he is lying lower then normal for such a large game. Therefore, I think he has something to hide. So, Vote - - - spurgistan.. Show yourself scum....

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'm always happy to pressure a submariner...Dustn hasn't posted at all you say...

vote Dustn

Mod, could you replace Dustn. He always does this.

I am also asking that Dustyn to get replaced

[got tonkaed]

Given the fact that kalish according to mando is an AD defensive lawyer at the moment (not really a role, just me having fun with language so dont get your undies all in a bunch) i find it interesting that he also voted riggable without an explanation under some pretense that he knew something but didnt want to divluge what it was.

So ill vote kalish for now until something else comes along

[dustn64]

Because I always do this, even though it apparently makes me look scummy


6. Riggable
13. Teen Skittles!
15. Skoffin
16. Spurgistan
17. CrabNebula
19. Serbia
25. Neutrino x
30. Militant
34. Dustn x



These are the people who posted three times or less...

Riggable is at 3, and so is Militant and Skoffin.

However, THESE are the people that don't talk, don't give reasons why they're voting, or plain just don't participate at all.

Out of these, I do not believe Dustn has posted AT ALL.

Serbia and Spurg each have one or two.

Why?

I've posted. I'm not as active as you, but I posted 3 times in the past 10 pages. 1 of which said "I was out of town for the first 4 days (RL), I told the mod this." Please check before you post such things.

[dustn64]

Also, At selin's big posts. I am thinking that militant should be better than AD. Mostly because AD HAS outed a lot of scum (and I personally think he is town), and militants voting and reasoning shouldn't be ignored.

Vote Militant