Conquer Club

spiesr wrote:

strike wolf wrote:I also wouldn't put it past the mod to have a Poisoner in this game and my experience is that most good vigs and JOATS won't attempt to kill anyone until they have a good sense of who's mafia.

Depending on the mechanics of the arsonist role, it would seem redundant for the scum group to have two delayed killing roles?

No I didn't mean to imply two delayed killing roles. I mentioned it to imply simply there could be a delayed kill.

As far as the herk as saxlad mentioned. Much better organized comment and yes id like to figure out moere about him too however I'd rather hear from Jace first right now. It's nothing set in stone but I feel this a possibility of a mafia member and should be investigated.

spiesr wrote:

strike wolf wrote:I also wouldn't put it past the mod to have a Poisoner in this game and my experience is that most good vigs and JOATS won't attempt to kill anyone until they have a good sense of who's mafia.

Depending on the mechanics of the arsonist role, it would seem redundant for the scum group to have two delayed killing roles?

Not all, slows down the N1 deaths, giving the town a chance to get a feel for who the scum are, before all hell breaks loose.

Niiiice! Wow, despite a town lynch, a scum NK? Very nice. Considering there's only one kill tonight, you think it's possible a mafia member was busdriven? Thus the town busdriver would be taking "revenge"? Idk, just a theory. Not sure about Jace and theherkman; it would be nice to hear from them, though (omg did I really just say I want herk to say something?). I'll look into things more later, as my time right now is limited (have to get grades in for interims).

-Sully

Yes, Jace is suspicious, but for now i will still urge you all to vote theherkman. This dude has been referring to having night kill actions ALL NIGHT, not to mention his pretty. odd behavior yesterday (as in, during D1). If he's the vig, we're better off without him. If he's some other killing role, he should die. Now.

vote theherkman btw.

Eh? WTF are you saying Aage? Town would be better off without a vig that succeeds in killing scum where town has failed?
FOS AAGE

Oh, next to the road, THM's post might also have referred to being a PGO. Which in that case would probably be strange, since no-one else died and at least some people must have targeted THM. And aside of that it might also be a role he got from mafia wiki and thought "oh hey thats an awesome fakeclaim".

vote theherkman btw.


Fastposted by /
Please explain to me how you know that TheHerkMan killed that dead scumguy? Slipup?

If herk did kill blake, why the hell are you going against him so much, aggieboy? Right now I can only agree with Strike Wolf, that jace could be a possible scumbuddy to blake.

And another mafia is MUCH better off than a possible town Vig. Huge fos on AAGE. Am not saying Herk is clean, but right now, nothing points to him beeing scum. Granted, there could be 2 mafia groups, but still.

I'll Follow on Strike's case as it's the most logic one to go with, for now.

Vote: Jace

let's hear something.

aage wrote:Please explain to me how you know that TheHerkMan killed that dead scumguy? Slipup?

You seemed to have implied the idea here that he could be a vig and should be killed if he is:

aage wrote:If he's the vig, we're better off without him.

It looks like / disagreed with that idea.

TheSaxlad wrote:and I keep missing stuff, notice that the title of the thread is TOWN takes revenge on mafia, therefore mafia did not kill mafia and town have a night killer.

I'd say that a PGO seems more likely considering who was killed.

So far today I'd say that strike makes a lot of sense while aage doesn't but I'll hold off on a vote fornow. I'll read/consider/post more when I've had some sleep.

aage wrote:Oh, next to the road, THM's post might also have referred to being a PGO. Which in that case would probably be strange, since no-one else died and at least some people must have targeted THM. And aside of that it might also be a role he got from mafia wiki and thought "oh hey thats an awesome fakeclaim".

vote theherkman btw.


Fastposted by /
Please explain to me how you know that TheHerkMan killed that dead scumguy? Slipup?

This is where you are.


























































































































And this is where the game is. (Along with logic too)

There is no reason to kill Herkyderky, and there is no reason to think of him as scum. If he does have a killing role which I don't remember him saying, he could have killed Blake for us which would have been a great help, and not something worth killing for.

Also to note Blake was not posting much and heavily on the Daze wagon, who was town. It was a good pic for a vig kill. ;3

Thezzaruz wrote:

TheSaxlad wrote:and I keep missing stuff, notice that the title of the thread is TOWN takes revenge on mafia, therefore mafia did not kill mafia and town have a night killer.

I'd say that a PGO seems more likely considering who was killed.

So far today I'd say that strike makes a lot of sense while aage doesn't but I'll hold off on a vote fornow. I'll read/consider/post more when I've had some sleep.

as an avid PGO fan, and someone who has had it in so many games I know patterns of it, I can tell you 100% that Herkyderky is not a PGO.

aage wrote:LMFAO
Scum, you suck

vote theherkman btw

I'm gonna wait for you to explain this one...

TheSaxlad wrote:

freezie wrote:

theherkman wrote:You should be keeping an eye on blakebowling. I say that I am have information about a doc and know who two trusted townies are and he votes me... HELLO? Did anyone miss this?

All I seen was you overreacting ONCE AGAIN calling out a single vote on you. A single vote and you call someone for '' trying to call a lynch on you''.

Dude, you're not at l-1..you're a l-a gazibillion votes.

Found this on page 47.

Herk You need to spill now. HTF did you know what was going on...

I have mentioned he was scum from the beginning. I role-claimed and he voted me right after my claim. Simple as that. Now he is dead. Score!

strike wolf wrote:It seems Blake was trying to throw attention away from a potential scum buddy. Adding that to the fact that Jace and Blake had similar voting patterns through much of the game (both voted Daze at least twice, both voted herk, both voted Lala) I think there is a good chance that Jace and Blake are connected. vote jace

I agree with this reasoning, we will see what Jace has to say about this.

TheSaxlad wrote:For now i have decided to vote theherkman pending his confessional.

Here is my confession. Not confessional.

TheSaxLad wrote:No Im voting herk because, he seems A. too active
B. he seems as though he knows a lot, especially about blakebowling.
C. How?

Those are my main questions/statements, as soon as/ if I get satisfying answers then I will change my vote, maybe it might even bring the scum out.

A. I am active... Not sure how this is a bad thing...
B. He BW where ever he could find one, but his tell was that he voted me AFTER I explained I had something to do with a doctor.
C. Umm... See "B".

aage wrote:Yes, Jace is suspicious, but for now i will still urge you all to vote theherkman. This dude has been referring to having night kill actions ALL NIGHT, not to mention his pretty. odd behavior yesterday (as in, during D1). If he's the vig, we're better off without him. If he's some other killing role, he should die. Now.

vote theherkman btw.

I have NEVER referred to having night actions. EVEN IF I DO, why should I die? If I do, and I did kill Blake, why do you want me to die if I am cleaning up scum? Now I am not sure about voting Jace, but I am pretty damn sure about voting you...

aage wrote:Oh, next to the road, THM's post might also have referred to being a PGO. Which in that case would probably be strange, since no-one else died and at least some people must have targeted THM. And aside of that it might also be a role he got from mafia wiki and thought "oh hey thats an awesome fakeclaim".

vote theherkman btw.


Fastposted by /
Please explain to me how you know that TheHerkMan killed that dead scumguy? Slipup?

Firstly, I don't know what a PGO is. Little help anyone? Secondly, You have now voted me in all 3 of your last posts. We get it. Thirdly, / didn't say I killed Blake, YOU DID!

So, with this information, I am going to VOTE AAGE and hope that people would follow my lead like they should have with Blake. Seriously guys, can you go with me on this one? He has voted me both before and after my claim. He kept his vote on me when everyone else UNVOTED. Now, he thinks I killed scum and wants to kill me. DESPITE my roleclaim on D1. Please, see this as what it is and let's get a solid scum lynch today.

ok. im sorry guys, im being lazy. Why are we (or at least, aage and co.) trying to lynch theherkman?

ebwop fastposted.

As soon as you find out, let me know, sens.

I dont sorry. Why? I'm still squinting at this and wondering, why the heck is herk scummy. No offense aage, i dont disagree with you, but why?

Because I'm not scummy. Aage is any thinks I have something to do with the scumkill last night and wants me dead so he wins...

theherkman wrote:Because I'm not scummy. Aage is any thinks I have something to do with the scumkill last night and wants me dead so he wins...

This guy still makes me laugh

this guy makes me laugh, great description!

ebwop, fast posted again!

I'd like an explanation from aage as well.

The only motivation for the constant votes that i could get from his posts was that joke kill thing herk did in the night. Not really solid evidence ...

Also, good catch strike wolf. A post from Jace would be good as well.

The dead shouldn't be talking now...

blakebowling wrote:

theherkman wrote:Because I'm not scummy. Aage is any thinks I have something to do with the scumkill last night and wants me dead so he wins...

This guy still makes me laugh

Yepp. Byebye now... Hehe... I knew you were scum...

With the way things are turning out, I'm worried that aage is not mafia and that haggis and sensfan are... They seem to be protective of Jace...

aage wrote:Yes, Jace is suspicious, but for now i will still urge you all to vote theherkman. This dude has been referring to having night kill actions ALL NIGHT, not to mention his pretty. odd behavior yesterday (as in, during D1). If he's the vig, we're better off without him. If he's some other killing role, he should die. Now.

How are we better off without someone that seems to know who are scum and who could potentially be killing scum off for us? I think if anything we should be protecting Herk because he seems to somehow know more than we do. (Scary huh?)

strike wolf wrote: It seems Blake was trying to throw attention away from a potential scum buddy. Adding that to the fact that Jace and Blake had similar voting patterns through much of the game (both voted Daze at least twice, both voted herk, both voted Lala) I think there is a good chance that Jace and Blake are connected.

I wish I had enough time to go back and reread all of this stuff =/ Good find, I think that's probably not a bad vote.

Is it possible that it WAS a NK by the mafia but it bounced back somehow? I'm not totally familiar with all the roles but I know stranger things have happened... We don't know for sure that we have someone with NK abilities do we?