Too many Items Mafia (4/14) Endgame: I Confess

[LSU Tiger Josh]

third party does not equal townie

[LSU Tiger Josh]

to have 5 mafia and 2 third parties town would have only 7 people to start which is unbalanced to begin with if scum and third parties = total amount of townies

[Iron Butterfly]

town is in a great position

unvote vote hippo for obviously not being town. FOS still on Jonty for previous voted reasons

Wow ... just dawned on me. Say obvious tyhings much LSU? Seriously??? Of course I'm not town - I'm third party. I'm also no threat to town. Your almost instantaneous vote on me is incredibly scummy.

Fos LSU

Fastposted by LSU

@ LSU re end game - you need to take that up with the mod after the game ends. My suspicion is that I am necessary for balance.

Your no threat simply for because you say so? I also suspect that if you achieve your win condition Town loses.

You had plenty of time to come forward after the night scene was revealed. You were only discovered when I put 2 and 2 together and called you out and made a case that proved to be completely correct. Lets make a list of everything you have done to help Town today shall we.

1) You tried to make me look like the third party without really accusing me.
2)You make a HUGE case on Zimmah by throwing everything but the kitchen sink at him.
3) You humor my vote on LSU.

Lets count the ways you have been scum.
1) You had every opportunity to come forward. If you had nothing to lose then why not? No you stayed hidden because your not done.

2)LYNCH ALL LIARS A basic tenet of the game. You plainly said you were a VT. You plainly said You had no night action.

You came forward not to help town but to save your ass.

[samgrossy]

There definitely is a reason Hippo is still around. The scene indicates as such and that there is more that he needs to do. The easy target is him now, but does it get the town end any closer to the end, and may it become a waste? Also, I don't think 3rd party players can talk to scum at night, so we also have to assume that his role could be just as equally bad to scum as to town.

All that said, I think his targeting Zimmah out of the blue at the beginning of the day is VERY suspect. And I think that keeping a third party role around for no reason is a little too easy.

I think that hippo just claimed himself out of here in my book.

VOTE HIPPO

Fastposted by just about everyone...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

also he claims that in 17 minutes he was able to communicate with the mod who did not post anywhere. i call hippo a

[crazymilkshake5]

official vote count

zimmah-thehippo8-L3
LSU Tiger Josh- jonty-L3
Jonty125-zimmah, hippo-L2
hippo8-IB, zimmah, LSU, sam-Lynch

[Iron Butterfly]

official vote count

zimmah-thehippo8-L3
LSU Tiger Josh- jonty-L3
Jonty125-zimmah, hippo-L2
hippo8-IB, zimmah, LSU, sam-Lynch

He was hammered by Sam

[crazymilkshake5]

official vote count

zimmah-thehippo8-L3
LSU Tiger Josh- jonty-L3
Jonty125-zimmah, hippo-L2
hippo8-IB, zimmah, LSU, sam-Lynch

He was hammered by Sam

thats what i have. scene sometime tomorrow.

[thehippo8]

So long and thanks for all the fish

[crazymilkshake5]

right. sorry for the delay.



My walkie talkie is gone!

Mine too!

and my revive thingy!

where could they have gone?

my boss needed items... so i found them and gave them to him

hey! not cool.

PLZ DON KILL MEH!

fine. just dont come here again.

Spoiler

Thehippo8-item detector has been lynched!

[pershy]

The only way you would be "necessary" for balance would be if you were scum. In a 14 player game, with 2 3rd parties there should be no more than 4 mafia. With 5 mafia and 2 third parties town would barely have a chance so I am believing you to be against town.

Wow, see I see it the other way around. If there is 5 mafia then one of the third parties would have to be town or there would be no balance. As they said in The Dark Knight Rises ...

One man's tool is another man's weapon

ha ha ha awesome! They lynched you. Bad for them cause it's not a scum lynch. We still win hee hee.
Well played bud

[thehippo8]

Spoiler

Post removed by popular demand ... sleep tight

[pershy]

whooops! That was a faux pas on my end. Sorry I meant to hit PM just as a nudge to a fellow player to say well done and give a pat on the back but accidentally posted in the thread. Luckily it didn't affect the game play at all cause we are both out of the game, but was meant to be a private message. Too late to take it back now so sorry again and gl to the rest of the players and enjoy the rest of the game.

[crazymilkshake5]

.

[pershy]

sorry zzzzzzzzzzz

[zimmah]

how can one sleep with all this noise!

[crazymilkshake5]

"A man was brutally assaulted last night.

luckily he was able to make it to the hospital in time before he bled out." Heard a man watching the news.

Day 6 starts!
Deadline will be in a week.
with 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

[Iron Butterfly]

We are in the home stretch.

Its now obvious we have a doc. I strongly believe we have one mafia left. I say this because there have been a limited number of night kills which would rule out a serial killer AND mafia.

Zimmah what did you get?

[zimmah]

i watched sam, noone visited him.

[samgrossy]

The mafia has got to be either LSU or Jonty. The Lynch all liars case is still good, but I have to really look back in the record to see. For some reason (and I am still on vaca, so I can't support it right now) there were some things that LSU seemed to do that were scummy, too.

I'll go back and look at it in the next few days, but you guys should post your take on it now.

Fastposted by Zim

[/]

With some discretion and thought first, perhaps the doc should claim.

with six alive we should have two lynches left, IF the doc can clear himself and some unknowns (the player saved), we may have the game in the bag.
But only if they player(s) the doc can clear are relative unknowns.

[jonty125]

The mafia has got to be either LSU or Jonty. The Lynch all liars case is still good,

I keep saying I never had the bat.

[zimmah]

The mafia has got to be either LSU or Jonty. The Lynch all liars case is still good,

I keep saying I never had the bat.

well, i'm quite sure everyone agrees it's either you or LSU. the hard part is to figure out which one.

[/]

The mafia has got to be either LSU or Jonty. The Lynch all liars case is still good,

I keep saying I never had the bat.

well, i'm quite sure everyone agrees it's either you or LSU. the hard part is to figure out which one.

I don't get it, spiesr pushed really hard for jonty's lynch, why are you so sure the mafia magician can be trusted as a reliable witness?

[zimmah]

The mafia has got to be either LSU or Jonty. The Lynch all liars case is still good,

I keep saying I never had the bat.

well, i'm quite sure everyone agrees it's either you or LSU. the hard part is to figure out which one.

I don't get it, spiesr pushed really hard for jonty's lynch, why are you so sure the mafia magician can be trusted as a reliable witness?

well, it's not only that jonty is suspicious because of the bat incident (remember i also received the bat and jonty confirmed he did lose at least an item the same day). but also noone can cover for jonty in a positive way.

LSU doesn't really have a case against him as far as i know, but then again, noone covers him either.