Conquer Club

Concise description:

• Feedback should be displayed after the game is archived

Specifics:

• As I understand it, feedback cannot be left for games older than one week. I think that feedback should only be displayed after a player who recieves feedback can no longer leave any of their own.

This will improve the following aspects of the site:

• This would make it so that people can not leave feedback for people just to recieve positive feedback themselves as a player would be unaware that they had recieved feedback until they could no longer leave it themselves.
  
  This would make retaliatory feedback impossible unless a player left negative feedback for another game...

Hm... interesting... I like it.

I give this suggestion an A+, (by which I mean I'm bumping it without anything to add.)

This seems like a good idea in principle, but I know many people who leave feedback upon receiving it. I do not mind this at all, for the people do it this way. I do not have to worry about negs. But an idea worth looking into.

Bruceswar wrote:This seems like a good idea in principle, but I know many people who leave feedback upon receiving it. I do not mind this at all, for the people do it this way. I do not have to worry about negs. But an idea worth looking into.

At first I was thinking that this should only be applied to negative feedbacks to make retaliatory feedback impossible but it would also eliminate the practice of fishing for positives. I have seen people leave tons of almost identical feedback which has rightfully been deleted because it was considered fishing for positives.

I do sometimes leave positives for positive (retaliatory positive?) but usualy I play more than one game with the people I like anyhow. This means that I would have the oppurtunity to leave a positive for another game...

I think it would be a big improvement to the feedback system to implement this to either only negative feedback, or even both negative and positive.

I can think of no negative consequences for it, and all in all I think this is a great idea.

It would also mean less work for mods responding to etickets, which could make them much happier. Again, a good thing for us all .

this is on wicked's list of changes to the feedback system thread from a few weeks ago. i am not sure how that is coming along.

Do you have a link to this list? I would like to see what else is on it.

bump

We've actually been considering your suggestion pretty seriously Gabon,

It's an elegant solution to a thorny problem.

We'll let you know if we use it

Twill

Twill wrote:We've actually been considering your suggestion pretty seriously Gabon,

It's an elegant solution to a thorny problem.

We'll let you know if we use it

Twill

hey, that was my suggestion
my idea two weeks earlier