hi MIghtyredarmy has won 3 games against gameplayer, 1 game to gameplayer, 1 undecided.

Great tournament!

count me in, please!

=============================================

UPDATE
I'm looking at other suggestions brought up:

* 4 stars (1-Very Bad, 2-Bad, 3-Good, 4-Very Good) with no "average", so people could typically leave 3 with less controversy.
* 3 stars (1-Bad, 2-Good, 3-Very Good) so that "average" would be more ...

Timminz wrote:

im2good4theboard wrote:I want Feedback Back!

I want a boat!

Fine - get us a simple feedback system that doesn't look like the sky at night and I'll buy you a boat.

No - I'm referring to the fact I can't make out the maps I'm playing on thanks to a load of 'white moise' - must be some corruption in the map - been like it for days - is it just me?


great tournament - just wish I could see the maps at the moment

I'm assuming you are referring to the brackets ...

great tournament - just wish I could see the maps at the moment

So I am wrong to presume that since this is a community consultation, the community will be given a chance to vote on the options?

Personally I would vote for some simplification, I don't think we needs loads of categories, with up to 5 stars in each, just keep it simple. 3 star system with one ...

This site has enough people to play on, where you can put people on ignore, and move on!

who cares if someone had a bad experience. Doesn't mean you will. Why can't we all get along, and bitch about each other in Flame Wars.

It's all a matter of opinion. A old lady might not like how a young boy ...

We don't need a 5-point scale. Look at the ratings dished out and you'll see that it's commonplace to rate 1s, 3s and 5s, while the 2s and 4s hardly get used.

We don't need categories. Look at the ratings left and you'll see 1-1-1, 3-3-3, 5-5-5 in the vast majority of cases

All we need to know ...

It's set bependant on the server you connect via. You think you have problems. When I login via work it says i'm German!! :shock:

And I love it that you have put this under cheating and abuse!!! :D

You think YOU have problems,

When I log in from work it says "site blocked, this site has been ...

Is there going to be some kind of vote on this?

If so I vote for rating players as positive, negative or neutral (which was much easier to understand) and dumping the 5 star system.

I think I should have posted this here...

Problem 1 - too much confusion is caused by 5 stars in 4 categories

Problem 2 - we're not gonna get feedback back because of moderation 'problems'.

Easy solution

Award a plus star (equivalent of old positive feedback) for an enjoyable game.
Award a ...

Problem 1 - too much confusion is caused by 5 stars in 4 categories

Problem 2 - we're not gonna get feedback back because of moderation 'problems'.

Easy solution

Award a plus star (equivalent of old positive feedback) for an enjoyable game.
Award a negative star (equivalent of old negative ...

We hear you, we do. We've got some ideas to help craft a better system that serves your wants and our needs. We want to keep everyone happy, so we're focusing extra effort on it all.


--Andy

How about getting these ideas out in the open for community discussion now, then everyone can see where ...

I'm up for it - thanks for the invite

Would we get 5 stars if we apologised in chat for any occasion where we took a few more hours to take a turn?

"Sorry, Soloman, I know it's been 10 hours, I set my alarm for 2AM - a really did, but it didn't go off and then the dog chewed the computer mouse..."

I'd like to see a bit more breakdown on the medals page.

i.e. where it says 6,000-odd medals have been won on standard, how many have achieved bronze, how many silver and how many gold.

Obviously some players (not me ) will already be contributing 3 to the total shown.

also, how bout not only bronze 20, silver, 100, gold 400, but add platinum and diamond

bronze 20 wins
silver 100 wins
gold 300 wins
platinum 500 wins
diamond 1000 wins

I think many would luv diamond status

Blitz, as I mentioned in GD, you're missing out on THE FACT that we need to ...

I posted this in suggestion, but guess could go here too on asking cc community what they think


adding platinum and diamond status


currently bronze is 20 wins, silver 100, gold 400

my suggestion would be this:

bronze 20

silver 100

gold 300

platinum 500

diamond 1000


sound good ...

I dont miss any turns and im already getting dinged with 3's beacuse I dont play real time. This is as bad as receiving a negative feedback. I like the auto idea but your outline is not reasonable.

IF automated it should be:

5 stars for 0 missed turns. You simply can't improve on zero missed ...

...the server goes down

Good professional response guys - inevitably won't please everybody, but hey.

According to the votes in Zimmah's poll, the average rating people are expecting to dish out is 3.8, while the median is 4.

Nothing wrong with Zimmah giving out 3s if she wants, but those who expect (on average 3.8),in reality 4 or 5 will continue to complain to her about it. I'm personally ...

Under 4 hours - rofl - some of us occasionally like to go to sleep for 8 hours at a stretch, or even work!

We get 24 hours to take a turn. Full stop.

Could be automated based on number of missed turns though, with no turns missed = 5 down to full deadbeat = 1

After a little while, all the ratings from people who use 5's as the starting point, and the people who use 3, and the people who give 1's whenever they lose, will all average out, and you will be able to tell by how someone compares to this average quite easily. It may not be the "recommended ...