Fircoal wrote:Vote: Militant for some reason you questioned Clive. While it seems like a bit of an effort to get something out of him. I don't think there is any need to disbelieve his claim. Unless he planned to kill himself and frame it on someone else, Which we could tell by his role unless a janitor, there would be a slim chance of it working in scums favor.
I was thinking aloud, there were no other intentions
Guys I am intentionally lurking. Discuss; Play mafia, it is good.
Oderint Dum Metuant says: Don't confuse the easily confused!
Clive wrote:GT is being pretty inactive, in my other game with him he was very active day 1, I think he might be being inactive cos he's scum, which he doesn't like. unvote vote GT
Clive wrote:GT is being pretty inactive, in my other game with him he was very active day 1, I think he might be being inactive cos he's scum, which he doesn't like. unvote vote GT
Metagaming isn't the greatest strategy.
Well I was right about you in the stargate game.
Your argument was that I was scum because I was posting and supposedly submarined as town in other game where I was roleblocker, which was a completely unfounded accusation as in seinfeld mafia I was roleblocker and posted constantly. Metagaming does not pay off I guarantee, unless you have vast experience as to what a player is always like. You suggest tonka is too quiet to be pro-town well people thought that in NJO where he barely posted and he was town there. Metagaming logic is very inconsistent.
Clive wrote:GT is being pretty inactive, in my other game with him he was very active day 1, I think he might be being inactive cos he's scum, which he doesn't like. unvote vote GT
Metagaming isn't the greatest strategy.
Well I was right about you in the stargate game.
Your argument was that I was scum because I was posting and supposedly submarined as town in other game where I was roleblocker, which was a completely unfounded accusation as in seinfeld mafia I was roleblocker and posted constantly. Metagaming does not pay off I guarantee, unless you have vast experience as to what a player is always like. You suggest tonka is too quiet to be pro-town well people thought that in NJO where he barely posted and he was town there. Metagaming logic is very inconsistent.
qft metagaming only works when u have vast experience...that or u have modded a few games...and u can see what happens behind the scenes
apologies folks, lost a fair amount of computer access over the last few days....
there really isnt much to go on thus far. I understand why clive might think i was a scum (despite the fact hes obviously wrong because the last time i was scum was in little italy). I dont really think we have anything worth doing but since i havent come across a brillant defense by militant to convince anyone otherwise....
got tonkaed wrote:apologies folks, lost a fair amount of computer access over the last few days....
there really isnt much to go on thus far. I understand why clive might think i was a scum (despite the fact hes obviously wrong because the last time i was scum was in little italy). I dont really think we have anything worth doing but since i havent come across a brillant defense by militant to convince anyone otherwise....
vote militant to move things along.
I'm really getting a town feel from him though...I could be wrong...I just don't want to lynch him today...
to some degree you should have town feelings on just about every player day 1....anyone who claims that have spotted surefire scumtells on day 1 (in the majority of cases) is being an idiot. Seemingly we are a bit of an impass and not knowing a whole lot about militant, im willing to let him die. Frankly its as instructional as anything about what we may be dealing with for those who pushed for the lynch (as opposed to the consentors like myself - who as always is above reproach)
unvote vote clive
he claimed early on day 1 under no pressure for no reason at all. i say he is using it as a tactic to be a known townie throughout the whole game. hes also meta gaming a fair bit. and then the omgus vote on diddle, saying diddle is scum for pointing out clives metagaming. i just cant see past the claim of recruiting mason to be honest. it seems like a role claim without being countered
