Top ten bands of all time

btownmeggy · Post by **btownmeggy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 4:57 pm

Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....

Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?

muy_thaiguy · Post by **muy_thaiguy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 5:09 pm

btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?

Least? Twist and Shout.

Most? Strawberry Fields.

Jdogg · Post by **Jdogg** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 6:39 pm

Hendrix, Rolling Stones, Pink Floyd, Led Zeppelin, Beatles, Queen, Allman Brothers/Eric Clapton

no particular order

suggs · Post by **suggs** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:12 pm

We need to clear something up. For starters this thread is top ten bands NOT top ten Rock bands, so pop bands are cool.
More importantly, yes the Beatles are overrated, in the same way that water is overrated-nope, water cant cure cancer but its still the best thing ever to happen to the human race.
My point: the Beatles have been so hyped so much that inevitably a few of their tracks dont stand up to modern day scrutiny.
But they are certainly the most important band of all time (cultural impact, impact on songwriters, EVERY other band that has recorded) and they HAVE to be included in any sane persons top ten.
Which is why I wish I hadnt forgotten to put them in my list

muy_thaiguy · Post by **muy_thaiguy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:18 pm

suggs wrote:We need to clear something up. For starters this thread is top ten bands NOT top ten Rock bands, so pop bands are cool.
More importantly, yes the Beatles are overrated, in the same way that water is overrated-nope, water cant cure cancer but its still the best thing ever to happen to the human race.
My point: the Beatles have been so hyped so much that inevitably a few of their tracks dont stand up to modern day scrutiny.
But they are certainly the most important band of all time (cultural impact, impact on songwriters, EVERY other band that has recorded) and they HAVE to be included in any sane persons top ten.
Which is why I wish I hadnt forgotten to put them in my list

Calling me crazy then? My tastes lay in other genres, thank you very much.

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:18 pm

PEARL JAM

unriggable · Post by **unriggable** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:19 pm

Serbia wrote:PEARL JAM

Somewhat. A little. Maybe.

Anarkistsdream · Post by **Anarkistsdream** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:21 pm

unriggable wrote:
Serbia wrote:PEARL JAM
Somewhat. A little. Maybe.

Fifteen years ago...

unriggable · Post by **unriggable** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 7:55 pm

Anarkistsdream wrote:
unriggable wrote:
Serbia wrote:PEARL JAM
Somewhat. A little. Maybe.
Fifteen years ago...

With LSD and serious mental disorder.

suggs · Post by **suggs** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:03 pm

unriggable wrote: With LSD and serious mental disorder.

Great days.

InkL0sed · Post by **InkL0sed** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:10 pm

Viable opinion:

btownmeggy wrote:Viable opinions in my opinion:

suggs wrote:1) The Smiths
5) The Who
6) The Rolling Stones

heavycola wrote:6. The Flaming Lips
7. The Beatles, natch

Gypsys Kiss wrote:6. Simon and Garfunkel

muy_thaiguy wrote:3. Queen
7. Johnny Cash

darvlay wrote:The Velvet Underground

comic boy wrote:Radiohead

On another note,
OnlyAmbrose wrote:10. Muse
What?!?

Muse surely can't be on a list if Radiohead isn't.

I have too many, so I separated them into upper and lower tiers:
First tier:
Pink Floyd
Led Zeppelin
The Beatles
The Doors
Radiohead
Pearl Jam (they were voted best American band ever on some site, I forgot where...)
U2

Second tier:
Architecture In Helsinki (little known and hard to get used to, but great)
Depeche Mode (if you write them off as emo you're just biased)
Metallica
Nine Inch Nails
The Pixies
The Police
Queen
Red Hot Chili Peppers
Smashing Pumpkins (only those few good albums in the 90s though)
The Smiths

Stymie · Post by **Stymie** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:31 pm

btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?

In my opinion, "Rubber Soul."

btownmeggy · Post by **btownmeggy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:43 pm

muy_thaiguy wrote:
btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?
Least? Twist and Shout.

Most? Strawberry Fields.

Those are songs, not albums. (Strawberry Fields Forever is a song, anyway.)

Heimdall · Post by **Heimdall** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:49 pm

Stymie wrote:
btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?
In my opinion, "Rubber Soul."

Beatles have 4 albums in the Rolling Stones Magazine top 10.

No one has ever had as much impact on music as them. Sure their music isn't much compared to today's standard but you must compare everything relative to their own time. They didn't have the technology we have now.

You're trying to compare The Ford Model T, the first mass produce car with a Porsche 911. Of course the Porsche can beat the Model T in all aspects, but the Model T had a much greater impact on society than the Porsche did when it came out.

See what I'm getting at?

Almost every existing band has been influenced in one way or another by the Beatles.

btownmeggy · Post by **btownmeggy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:51 pm

Heimdall wrote:
Stymie wrote:
btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?
In my opinion, "Rubber Soul."
Beatles have 4 albums in the Rolling Stones Magazine top 10.

No one has ever had as much impact on music as them. Sure their music isn't much compared to today's standard but you must compare everything relative to their own time. They didn't have the technology we have now.

You're trying to compare The Ford Model T, the first mass produce car with a Porsche 911. Of course the Porsche can beat the Model T in all aspects, but the Model T had a much greater impact on society than the Porsche did when it came out.

See what I'm getting at?

Almost every existing band has been influenced in one way or another by the Beatles.

Yeah, but I'm not just talking in temporally relevant terms. Abbey Road is awesome... awesomeawesomeAWESOME.

Snorri1234 · Post by **Snorri1234** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:53 pm

suggs wrote:We need to clear something up. For starters this thread is top ten bands NOT top ten Rock bands, so pop bands are cool.

In that case:

1. Backstreet Boys
2. Spice Girls
3. Westlife
4. Five
5. Sugababes.
6. Boyz2men
7. New kids on the block
8. *NSYNC
9. Take That
10. Red Hot Chilli Peppers.

Heimdall · Post by **Heimdall** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:58 pm

My List

1. Beatles: For their influence on Rock
2. Led Zepplin: For their influence on Hard Rock
3. Pink Floyd
4. Ramones: For their influence on Punk rock
5. Grateful Dead
6. Rolling Stones
7. The Doors
8. Metallica
9. Bob Marley and the Wailers
10. U2

Honorable mention to Motown influence

Heimdall · Post by **Heimdall** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:58 pm

btownmeggy wrote:
Heimdall wrote:
Stymie wrote:
btownmeggy wrote:
Stymie wrote:This is coming from someone who thinks the Beatles are the best band.
Whatever floats your boat... All I got to say about the Beatles is boring, boring.....
Have you ever really listened to the Beatles, beyond the 5 songs that are on every movie soundtrack? What's the least boring of their albums, in your opinion? The most boring?
In my opinion, "Rubber Soul."
Beatles have 4 albums in the Rolling Stones Magazine top 10.

No one has ever had as much impact on music as them. Sure their music isn't much compared to today's standard but you must compare everything relative to their own time. They didn't have the technology we have now.

You're trying to compare The Ford Model T, the first mass produce car with a Porsche 911. Of course the Porsche can beat the Model T in all aspects, but the Model T had a much greater impact on society than the Porsche did when it came out.

See what I'm getting at?

Almost every existing band has been influenced in one way or another by the Beatles.
Yeah, but I'm not just talking in temporally relevant terms. Abbey Road is awesome... awesomeawesomeAWESOME.

Agreed

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:59 pm

Snorri1234 wrote:
suggs wrote:We need to clear something up. For starters this thread is top ten bands NOT top ten Rock bands, so pop bands are cool.
In that case:

1. Backstreet Boys
2. Spice Girls
3. Westlife
4. Five
5. Sugababes.
6. Boyz2men
7. New kids on the block
8. *NSYNC
9. Take That
10. Red Hot Chilli Peppers.

RHCP doesn't belong on this list.

EDIT: doesn't belong on Snorri's list of lousy pop bands.

btownmeggy · Post by **btownmeggy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 8:59 pm

I'd like to proffer up a new one, great not for their influence but for their incredible genius, daring, and grandeur: The Magnetic Fields.

radiojake · Post by **radiojake** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 9:02 pm

you all have terrible music taste.

Nickelback??? Jet?? Ewww..

A general rule for myself is if it's on the radio, it's probably shit

EDIT

Guiscard wrote:The Clash
Operation Ivy
The Smiths
Youngblood Brass Band
The Pogues
Skatalites
Toots and the Maytals
Jimi Hendrix Experience
The Beatles
Bob Marley and the Wailers

some of those are good, didn't see them first time

Arbustos · Post by **Arbustos** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 9:03 pm

radiojake wrote:you all have terrible music taste.

Nickelback??? Jet?? Ewww..

A general rule for myself is if it's on the radio, it's probably shit

Pretentious bs.

muy_thaiguy · Post by **muy_thaiguy** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 9:04 pm

radiojake wrote:you all have terrible music taste.

Nickelback??? Jet?? Ewww..

A general rule for myself is if it's on the radio, it's probably shit

That's one person's opinion. But if it's on the radio and lots of people are listening to it, it must mean that those bands are doing something right.

radiojake · Post by **radiojake** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 9:07 pm

muy_thaiguy wrote: That's one person's opinion. But if it's on the radio and lots of people are listening to it, it must mean that those bands are doing something right.

If it's on the radio it means they had the right managers and sucked the right cock. People listen to it because it is on the radio, not because it is any good

EDIT:
And yes, if you like those bands, then fair enough, but i still think they're shit (which is my opinion)

kingprawn · Post by **kingprawn** » Mon Jan 21, 2008 9:09 pm

The Beatles
PinkFloyd
The Pogues
The Smiths
New Order
Johnny Cash
The Wedding Present
Stone Roses
Happy Mondays
Macc Lads

In any order.