Nerds Mafia 4 Deaths Nerds Win

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 11:58 am

i agree reading back over yesterday i sounded scummy but I can assure you I'm not I have a town role and I used that power yesterday based on the information presented. Without spelling it out, I'm sure people can figure out what I mean by that, but if necessary I will role claim although if I do I will be looking for night protection please.

cena-rules · Post by **cena-rules** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 12:00 pm

iM HUNGOVER

SPELL IT OUT

firth4eva · Post by **firth4eva** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 12:03 pm

I have no idea either

CrabNebula · Post by **CrabNebula** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 12:09 pm

rebelman wrote:i agree reading back over yesterday i sounded scummy but I can assure you I'm not I have a town role and I used that power yesterday based on the information presented. Without spelling it out, I'm sure people can figure out what I mean by that, but if necessary I will role claim although if I do I will be looking for night protection please.

Get to the point, thanks.

Oh and you have been scummy the entire, NOT just yesterday. I could find a dozen posts where MM, you and diddle defend each other, but I am lazy and will do tomorrow.

And iirc Mayor cannot prevent a lynch twice, so it might be better to lynch diddle again anyway.

The 4th scum most probably is fireedud who has conveniently submarined till now and since he wasn't modkilled he is active at night. LSU can we get him prodded? Thanks!

firth4eva · Post by **firth4eva** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 12:13 pm

Yes. It is quite conveniant for diddle to keep saying "I got town"

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:20 pm

i am mayor and yes i saved diddle yesterday as it seemed clear from his posts he was town and he actually lynched himself with the final vote there is no way scum would do that

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:22 pm

rebelman wrote:i am Dean Ulich - mayor and yes i saved diddle yesterday as it seemed clear from his posts he was town and he actually lynched himself with the final vote there is no way scum would do that

edited to include character name

browng-08 · Post by **browng-08** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:24 pm

rebelman wrote:i am mayor and yes i saved diddle yesterday as it seemed clear from his posts he was town and he actually lynched himself with the final vote there is no way scum would do that

true. Any counter-claims? If not, I believe you. I already believe diddle. That makes two probable townies. a good start. Well. I suspect CN.
vote CN
Can't back it up, yet. I just have this feeling...

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:28 pm

browng-08 wrote: vote CN
Can't back it up, yet. I just have this feeling...

votes need to be in red

CrabNebula · Post by **CrabNebula** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:33 pm

browng-08 wrote:
rebelman wrote:i am mayor and yes i saved diddle yesterday as it seemed clear from his posts he was town and he actually lynched himself with the final vote there is no way scum would do that
true. Any counter-claims? If not, I believe you. I already believe diddle. That makes two probable townies. a good start. Well. I suspect CN.
vote CN
Can't back it up, yet. I just have this feeling...

We probably will need to wait a while until LSU has prodded everyone.

And if you are telling the truth, then it was a wasted action. diddle lynch would have given his sanity and helped quite since he had already revealed his investigations. And in the other case we would have lynched a scum.

browng-08 · Post by **browng-08** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 2:18 pm

rebelman wrote:
browng-08 wrote: vote CN
Can't back it up, yet. I just have this feeling...
votes need to be in red

dustn64 · Post by **dustn64** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 5:41 pm

fireedud · Post by **fireedud** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 8:33 pm

CrabNebula wrote:
The 4th scum most probably is fireedud who has conveniently submarined till now and since he wasn't modkilled he is active at night. LSU can we get him prodded? Thanks!

I have been doing a lot of things in rl, and probably for the next two weeks, I will only be popping in and out, but I try to go on for at least a few minutes everyday. I'm not contributing anything because I really can't do it that much, I'm not very good at playing mafia. YOu can check some of my other games if you don't beleive me.

Also, does any Nerds geek (lol) know if rebelman's character name is credible.

fireedud · Post by **fireedud** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 8:33 pm

CrabNebula wrote:
The 4th scum most probably is fireedud who has conveniently submarined till now and since he wasn't modkilled he is active at night. LSU can we get him prodded? Thanks!

I have been doing a lot of things in rl, and probably for the next two weeks, I will only be popping in and out, but I try to go on for at least a few minutes everyday. I'm not contributing anything because I really can't do it that much, I'm not very good at playing mafia. YOu can check some of my other games if you don't beleive me.

Also, does any Nerds geek (lol) know if rebelman's character name is credible.

fireedud · Post by **fireedud** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 8:34 pm

CrabNebula wrote:
The 4th scum most probably is fireedud who has conveniently submarined till now and since he wasn't modkilled he is active at night. LSU can we get him prodded? Thanks!

I have been doing a lot of things in rl, and probably for the next two weeks, I will only be popping in and out, but I try to go on for at least a few minutes everyday. I'm not contributing anything because I really can't do it that much, I'm not very good at playing mafia. YOu can check some of my other games if you don't beleive me.

Also, does any Nerds geek (lol) know if rebelman's character name is credible.

lalaland · Post by **lalaland** » Mon Mar 03, 2008 8:46 pm

even if your post seems like it is taking forever to load, it will show up 99% of the time even if it keeps you on the 'post a reply' page. so no need to say the same thing 3 times.

CrabNebula · Post by **CrabNebula** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 5:08 am

lalaland wrote:even if your post seems like it is taking forever to load, it will show up 99% of the time even if it keeps you on the 'post a reply' page. so no need to say the same thing 3 times.

Now, say anything about the game?

LSU have you prodded everyone?

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 5:41 am

ok this is who is still alive:

Players Living
1. Firedud
4. GA7 replaced Cena-rules back to cena
8. Crabnebula
10. Firth4eva
11. Skoffin
14. Neutrino
15. rebelman
18. Diddle
19. Lala
20. BrownG-08

i just reread the first 30 pages or so to see could i get clearer indication who was / was not scum, I paid special attention to the posts of lovo and mm our 2 confirmed cum and I reached the following conclusion.

skoffin, me and diddle are definitely town as for the other 7 any could be scum and its safe to assume at least 3 are, however the one that seems to be really targeting players that are obviously town the most is crab. So unvote vote crab

LSU Tiger Josh · Post by **LSU Tiger Josh** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 6:12 am

I won't do a general prod for "everyone" until it's been 48 hours as the title was changed so people can see that it is day.

lalaland · Post by **lalaland** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 6:32 am

I was rereading, and what rebel says seems pretty much right... Crab has been the one pointing the finger at most 80% sure townies.
for that reasoning, vote crab

CrabNebula · Post by **CrabNebula** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 6:34 am

rebel, mind pointing how diddle is "obviously town"?

lalaland, thanks for the statistics. I guess you cannot argue with it

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 7:27 am

CrabNebula wrote:rebel, mind pointing how diddle is "obviously town"?

grrr will do properly in a while but here is the quick version was targeted by both mm and lovo both of whom turned out to be scum also hammered himself yesterday - im new to mafia but i cant think of a single reason why scum would hammer themselves. I know he is still alive but that's because i saved him but I'm certain only a fellow townie would be willing to suicide like that so that we could find out what type of cop he was.

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 7:39 am

Minister Masket wrote:VOTE DIDDLE
There's always something to discuss! Like how you are trying to waste time!

an example of what im talking about

rebelman · Post by **rebelman** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 7:52 am

after another review im now adding BrownG to those I believe to be town - so IMHO me, diddle, skoffin and brown are town - which leaves 6 possible scum targets that i have arranged in order from most scummy to least scummy.

8. Crabnebula -definite scum
10. Firth4eva - almost definitly scum as well
1. Firedud -seems scummy but im not sure
14. Neutrino - lots of submarining seems like scum but im not certain
4. GA7 replaced Cena-rules back to cena -also seems somewhat scummy
19. Lala - submarined a bit and makes off topic posts eg whats a day cop , lease dont post multiple times (i think she could be town too but im not certain)

CrabNebula · Post by **CrabNebula** » Tue Mar 04, 2008 8:40 am

As I had said I would posting something very relevant info today...

lalaland wrote:i'm going to Vote SL

Votes comes after TWOs, clearly submariner or scum.
Jumping on the bandwagon, no reason provided.

Sierra_Leon wrote:TWO and lala are much higher on my scum-list, because of the posts they made today. Both of them voted me when I was already cleared by kiwi's death. Lala didn't even bother explaining her vote; TWO tried but failed utterly. Furthermore, I know lala has played in games before, so I'm getting the feeling that her asking what a day cop was is an act to appear newbish and innocent in some way.

QFE.

fireedud wrote:Anyway on a more serious note, I'd rather no have a no lynch, and browng is looking pretty scummy, so Vote Browng

Sierra made an excellent point on why browng couldn't be scum and you voted him?

Minister Masket wrote:
diddle wrote:
Minister Masket wrote:VOTE DIDDLE
There's always something to discuss! Like how you are trying to waste time!
Find me something worth debating, and I'll unvote you. Your reasons for voting me are pointless, this isn't day 1 any more....

Vote MM
Well done. Actually I'm trying to generate discussion here. Unvote
It got you talking, yes?
Any point in re-reading? Or is it just garbage?

A little bit of OMGUS voting your scum-buddies never hurts, eh? And that too with few hours to deadline when a lynch was absolutely essential.

rebelman wrote:ok just finished reading all 30 pages and not much the wiser, based on lovo's defense of him I think BrownG-08 is a scum cop, which would also explain all those confusing / conflicting results.

unvote vote BrownG-08

im also putting a big FOS on TWO his posts stink of scum.

Skimmed the hell out of Sierra's points on why browng cannot be scum.

diddle wrote:
Sierra_Leon wrote:I disagree with this. I believe there not being an adjective to kiwi's role implies he was sane.
We could argue about it all day, and it'll get us nowhere. Lets try and focus on something a little more recent.

Tries to get the pressure off himself by when his argument was proved to be pointless.

lalaland wrote:honestly, in this game at this point all that is happening is bandwagons. there are really no new leads, and nothing else to go on.

Thanks for continuously submarining!

Minister Masket wrote:UNVOTE
Looks like rebelman was just being desperate rather than scummy. In any case, best to keep an eye on him.

Also, I'm fish-slapping an FOS on Skoffin because she's blatently using personal prejudices to try and get poor old diddle lynched.

Not only does he remove pressure off rebel completely but also defends diddle at the same time.

Minister Masket wrote:
CrabNebula wrote:This will be going nowhere if we keep stalling like this. So lets get on with the diddle lynch, mmkay?
What the hell is this? C'mon, at least try and hide the fact that you are trying to kill random townies.
VOTE CRAB

And again trying to protect diddle.

diddle wrote:I'm going to Vote Browng. I know that I am a cop, Kiwi was a cop, and Danix was a cop. That investigation of a corpse is looking a lot more scummy right now if you ask me.

Instead of answering the question put forward to him, he tries to start a bandwagon?! This has been the most scummiest of his posts. His reasoning was flawed and was pointed out to him but he still chooses to not drop it. Not to mention I had said I had reasonable proof that browng wasn't scum.

Minister Masket wrote:
firth4eva wrote:unvote vote diddle Crab's got you and you have only dug yourself deeper into a hole.
Methinks you hammered him. Although it t'is late and I'm probably only half-awake...

Ok lets assume diddle is town. MM then surely would have voted him at the height of the bandwagon, but he didn't. Why? diddle would have been lynched faster which a scum would definitely prefer. This means MM didn't want to vote his scum buddy, knowing the fact that it would be very hard to get majority of votes since many were submarining.

This is why I believe diddle is lying. And rebel assuming you are the mayor (a town one at that), you wasted a day by stopping diddle's lynch. If he was scum, then his lynch would have been good. If he was Naive cop as claims, then he would have been useless. If he was Sane cop then that would have cleared TWO and me. But stopping his lynch we gave the scum a free night to kill and without any day info.

Oh and FOS lalaland, always ready to jump on bandwagons, are we now?