Asylum Mafia Game Thread Staff/Patient Town Players/Ga7 Win!

[nagerous]

Calling people abusive bastards isn't really going to help you with your defence sir.

[Suika]

Calling people abusive bastards isn't really going to help you with your defence sir.

I know, I really shouldn't be allowed out of my padded room before someone brings me coffee.

[Sierra_Leon]

Calling people abusive bastards isn't really going to help you with your defence sir.

If you check his posts yesterday, you'll find this is his PR. He'll most likely be posting a poem after this. How do I know this? Because I have reread. And I've found loads of stuff to speculate on.

First interesting post day 1:

FOS:

10.pmchugh*
23.icedagger*
25.ditocoaf
29.suika


Who the hell are you people and how many games have you played?

they're my multis1 so back off! i need advcantage to mafa! haha

and it's purrple dinosaurs and pink eleppants suggsu!

AD does his usual 'flame the newbies' act, but wicked finds it necessary to have him back-off for some reason. 'Some reason' most likely being that one or more of her scum buddies are on that list. They won't all be scum (which is why wicked probably didn't find it too risky to stand up for them like that), but at least one of them is.
Still she couldn't prevent a small bandwagon on suika from starting:

I tend to agree with mr. incrediball. I think our best bet is to lynch someone with a post restriction, preferrably one that doesn't seem friendly or in Suika's case, paranoid.

Vote Suika

Hmm, damn, ML, that actually is a really good point.

So far, I guess voting Neoteny was good, but he does seem harmless... for now.

we'll see what happens when the scum quit getting their meds.

Unvote
Vote: Suika

10 new pages already..

Well, I also wasn't in the last game, but what Mr. I said seems to make sense.

unvote vote Suika

But the bandwagon dies with nag and icedagger making a stand for suika:

I disagree with this bandwagon.... Seems to me Suika is just feeling threatened from messrs incrediball, iliad and pmchugh.

They are the oppressors, I think they should be lynched over Suika... perhaps he knows something about them we don't but is too jittered and knocked out to explain it to us in proper english thanks to the pills the son of a bitches have been putting in his drinks.

Wait aren't all the patinets here insane? Isn't that kinda why they're here? I doubt they're all mafia so FOS that bandwagon

The suika case is left to die until late in the day wicked is getting the bandwagon treatment. My own post summarizes this quite well:

Conveniently enough, my vote was already on wicked. I'm very happy with this lynch.

Personally, I don't see Wicked as having anything suspicious in the least about her at this point in the game. I'd jump on this bandwagon because of the deadline, but there are still others that haven't been resolved that still have more votes on them.

Kiwiwater still seems suspicious to me--he essentially claimed cop, but decided to take / with him at the same time... having claimed cop, if the mafia doesn't kill him tonight, then we'll know he's one of them. Who claims cop when there isn't even half enough people to lynch yet?

My vote stays.

But most importantly-- we need a lynch. How much time is left?

Your defence of wicked has been noted.

I didn't mean in general, I meant between the twobig games that have a largenumbder of the same peoples.

34 people in this game and maybe 5 really active, 5 more semi-active, some occassional and some not even showing up or paying attention. There's a lot of absentees here.

Ya, I'm doubting we'll get a lynch today unless everyone checks in tomorrow before the deadline. Realistically, I don't see that happening.

Wow, there's been a lot of going round in circles, but not a helluva lot else...
Unvote

That said, wicked is voting for Lion, on the grounds he's happy to vote anyone, but at the same time not wanting to vote someone is jumped on as just as scummy, so what the hell?

Your refusal to vote for wicked has been noted.

wow

You're not in this game, are you?

What I find even more interesting than suika not voting for wicked, is dito defending her when earlier he said he would bandwagon just about anyone:

At this point, I'd be willing to jump on any bandwagon there is, just to ensure that someone gets lynched. We need the info. Unfortunately, in the final stretch, it doesn't seem likely that enough of this large group will be able to come to a consensus.

And what does my eye see? Ditocoaf is also on the list of newbies that wicked was defending! There was already a bandwagon on dito for his bandwagon comment earlier, let's look at that again:

At this point, I'd be willing to jump on any bandwagon there is, just to ensure that someone gets lynched. We need the info. Unfortunately, in the final stretch, it doesn't seem likely that enough of this large group will be able to come to a consensus.

You just admitted you'd jump on ANY bandwagon?!?

Sounds to me like you are not being too cautious as to who gets lynched.

I agree with you there Nark. unvote vote Ditocoaf because I believe him to be the SK.

AD points out how scummy Dito's post is, but fails to vote him for it. Mandy places his first serious vote that day on Dito. This is noteworthy, seeing as how Mandy got killed last night.

Vote Ditocoaf
Since he said he'd jump any bandwagon, this will be easier if he votes for himself with all of us.

Anyway ditocloaf either is an sk or a noob scum so vote ditocloaf

Looks like the inmates are going to be running the asylum if you lynch me. I fail to see why when I submarine I always get voted but when znyone else does they seem to get away with it . I posted that I didn't have anything to say at 8 am in the morning. Can't someone be tired. Anyway that tirade is over. What Ditocoaf said was either scummy or noobish. Vote Ditocoaf

The bandwagon gets snowed under by the one on kiwi though, getting Dito off the hook with relative ease. I found this post, posted by sheep at the peak of the bandwagon, very suspicious:

Yeah, Ditocoaf's made too many newbish mistakes. Enough that if we weren't going after Kiwi he'd be lynched right now.

Just so you know Dito, it's not very smart to out and out deny that your scum. That looks scummy to people and is a sure fire way to get lynched.

Also jumping on bandwagons isn't a very smart this if you can tell. Scum love to try and kill the town as fast as they can and a bandwagon just makes it easier. A good scum player keeps a low profile and only bandwagons on players that look like easy lynches.

This sounds very much like an experienced scum player trying to instruct his newbie scum partner not to bandwagon anymore. An advice that Dito seems to obey when it comes to the bandwagon on wicked.

Two more posts I found interesting enough to note:

It's obvious from the opening of the story that meds are in short supply. I think there are good staff members and bad staff members and then a bunch of crazy people. Obviously the bad staff members probably have the choice to give the wrong drugs to patients here or no drugs at all. So, they will basically use the crazy people here to make them do whatever they want. So, insane people aren't a threat yet, but probably will become one.

How is that obvious, unless you are one of those staff members?

It turns out Talapus was actually a part of the staff, so we should take heed to the warning he gave us here.

Unvote although I don't really understand what a deputy does in this game

I think I know, so I'll PM you.

Maybe suika figured it would be alright for him to PM icedagger, because his role PM told him he could talk with icedagger in private? I know, it's farfetched, but I can't help thinking it could also be true. Icedagger is also on the list of newbies wicked defended.


In the end, it comes down to choosing between Suika and Ditocoaf for me. Personally, I think Ditocoaf stands out more as scum. But then there's the fact that AD hinted that his night-action involved Suika somehow. I honestly don't trust that claim much, seeing as it was totally unnecessary at that time. It looks more like scum seeing that his scumbuddy has a lynch to look forward to, so he decides to use him to establish a fake-claim for himself. Still, even in that scenario Suika is scum, so that's where my vote will go.

Small FOS icedagger.
Big FOS Ditocoaf.
Vote Suika.

I think Suika should roleclaim.

[Anarkistsdream]

EXCELLENT post, sierra! Well done!

[Suika]

Actually, I've already Haiku'd today, whch counts.

Reply to one or two points in your post: The PM thing was me not realising it wasn't allowed. As for AD, I have no idea why he'd make that claim, and will expand on that in the event I need to roleclaim because I've been pushed to a choke point.

I would like to know why so many people don't believe me when I say I made a genuine mistake by not voting yesterday. I'm new, and have seen no lynch days before, with no-one getting jumped on for not voting before, so your vehemance at going after me is puzzling. Yes, I screwed up, put it down to inexperience.
I'm half-wondering if you've all forgotten I'm new to this (this is only my 3rd game, and of the other two, one died after two days, and the second I only joined as a sub), which is at the same time flattering, and a pain in the ass.

Final point: I know the name of one of the Physicians on staff. I'm hesitant to reveal the name, given the death of a Doc, but at the same time I have no clue to their alignment. I'll leave it up to my accusers to decide if I should reveal the name or not.
I'll add that in the (seemingly unlikely) event I survive to tomorrow, I will probably have a second name.

[Anarkistsdream]

Actually, I've already Haiku'd today, whch counts.

Reply to one or two points in your post: The PM thing was me not realising it wasn't allowed. As for AD, I have no idea why he'd make that claim, and will expand on that in the event I need to roleclaim because I've been pushed to a choke point.

I would like to know why so many people don't believe me when I say I made a genuine mistake by not voting yesterday. I'm new, and have seen no lynch days before, with no-one getting jumped on for not voting before, so your vehemance at going after me is puzzling. Yes, I screwed up, put it down to inexperience.
I'm half-wondering if you've all forgotten I'm new to this (this is only my 3rd game, and of the other two, one died after two days, and the second I only joined as a sub), which is at the same time flattering, and a pain in the ass.

Final point: I know the name of one of the Physicians on staff. I'm hesitant to reveal the name, given the death of a Doc, but at the same time I have no clue to their alignment. I'll leave it up to my accusers to decide if I should reveal the name or not.
I'll add that in the (seemingly unlikely) event I survive to tomorrow, I will probably have a second name.

Knowing the staff can be beneficial, but only if you know their alignment, as well.

The problem at this point is that two town staff have died, which means that, more than likely, scum staff now outnumber.

The other real problem is that, if scum think that you are getting names, they will most likely kill you. SO, revealing could be a boon, as well as a hindrance.

As to why I voted you... I can't say.

[The1exile]

...

That's actually a lot of sense for an asylum, Sierra. I'm sold.

The "I'm new" defence hasn't worked on me since I played that to avoid being lynched in my first game.

Vote Suika

[Clive]

I think the Sukia wagon is a good way to go.

vote Suika for the moment.

I'm surprised Ga hasn't posted yet, he's usually more active than this.

[MountainLion]

Well done SL. Some of it is reaching, but IMO sometimes that's the best way to find scum.

[Anarkistsdream]

Well done SL. Some of it is reaching, but IMO sometimes that's the best way to find scum.

But you are not sure enough to vote?

[MountainLion]

Also I agree that even if Suika knows who a staff member is, not knowing the alignment is useless because if they were town, we wouldn't want to give it away to scum.

[MountainLion]

Well done SL. Some of it is reaching, but IMO sometimes that's the best way to find scum.

But you are not sure enough to vote?

I've already voted Suika, SKIMMER!

[icedagger]

Wow nice post Sierra. I don't agree with all of it, but some of the evidence against Suika is good.

Vote Suika

[Clive]

The problem at this point is that two town staff have died, which means that, more than likely, scum staff now outnumber.

I'd have thought the town staff outnumber scum staff in the normal kinda ratio.

[pmchugh]

Great post SL, except you forgot to vote in brown. I agree most of it but parts seem like there reading too much into it, my vote stays on suika.

ps this new forum just stopped me from being fastposted.

[Anarkistsdream]

The problem at this point is that two town staff have died, which means that, more than likely, scum staff now outnumber.

I'd have thought the town staff outnumber scum staff in the normal kinda ratio.

Well, there are obviously going to be more patients than staff.

So, if you figure you have about, what, 8 staff members tops, and two of the good ones just died, then that would make it around 3 to 3 or something, I'd think.

[sheepofdumb]

On Suika and Dito. I would rather see Dito lynched after all the posts he has made in defense on Wicked. I thought I'd get some heat for trying to publicly give him advice but he seems to have dug his own grave. All I could think of when I read SL's post was how scummy Dito looked and was kinda surprised when he voted Suika. I'll trust the call on this one but I do it half heartedly.

Vote: Suika

[CrabNebula]

Pooooooooooosting I am, hic, curses!

Nice summary Sierra, hic, thanks for making me nooooooooot reread , and with that vote Suika

Even if yoooooooou are new, hic, others have done given enough defense for you to make me vote you. Oh btw, I think it would be a gooooood idea to give the name of the person you said, hic, you knew before you are lynched. Assuming hicthat bad staff are moooooore, then it may be beneficial.

[icedagger]

Pooooooooooosting I am, hic, curses!

Nice summary Sierra, hic, thanks for making me nooooooooot reread , and with that vote Suika

Even if yoooooooou are new, hic, others have done given enough defense for you to make me vote you. Oh btw, I think it would be a gooooood idea to give the name of the person you said, hic, you knew before you are lynched. Assuming hicthat bad staff are moooooore, then it may be beneficial.

There's no reason scum staff would outnumber town staff at this stage.. giving the name would only give scum a target if suika turns out to be town

[Neoteny]

"But if we hope for that we see not, then do we with patience wait for it."

Philippians 4:6,7

Got a little behind in this one. Will read again... superficially, the Suika bandwagon seems logical to me. A post in all caps is enough to catch my eye.

[william18]

Whhh whats the vote couuu count at?

[Anarkistsdream]

Pooooooooooosting I am, hic, curses!

Nice summary Sierra, hic, thanks for making me nooooooooot reread , and with that vote Suika

Even if yoooooooou are new, hic, others have done given enough defense for you to make me vote you. Oh btw, I think it would be a gooooood idea to give the name of the person you said, hic, you knew before you are lynched. Assuming hicthat bad staff are moooooore, then it may be beneficial.

There's no reason scum staff would outnumber town staff at this stage.. giving the name would only give scum a target if suika turns out to be town

I think there is a decent possibility of that, due to the patient/staff ratio.

[icedagger]

Only 1 more town staff than mafia staff has died.. and there can be scum patients as well as town. I don't think its very likely at all that mafia staff are close in numbers to town staff atm

[Anarkistsdream]

Only 1 more town staff than mafia staff has died.. and there can be scum patients as well as town. I don't think its very likely at all that mafia staff are close in numbers to town staff atm

I hope you are correct.

[Minister Masket]

GAH!
Tons of new stuff. I'll re-read and see if anything crops up.