Eyewitness Mafia- William and Clive win.

[Clive]

vote Icedagger

[william18]

vote Icedagger

Goodjob, im a witness.

[pmchugh]

Town wins! Icedagger murderer caught red handed!

[icedagger]

gahh what did I do wrong?

[william18]

See. Im a 13 year old master of deduction!

[icedagger]

Does the deulisional one see a random colour, or the other witnesses shirt colour?

[Clive]

Yeh. Now I think about it, I should have voted him earlier. Ice, once Will voted you counter-claiming black shirt was the only way to keep going.

[pmchugh]

Ice was murderer wearing white
Clive was delusional wearing purple told that murderer was wearing black
William was sane wearing black and told murderer was wearing white

[Clive]

Does the deulisional one see a random colour, or the other witnesses shirt colour?

Other witness.

Question - should the colors be public?

[icedagger]

Bollocks. Thought it was a random colour

[william18]

Does the deulisional one see a random colour, or the other witnesses shirt colour?

Other witness. When he said my name then I knew it was you. Since the dilusional witness see's the sane witness, and he saw me, then I new I was sane. But since I knew he was dilusional then you were the only one left.

[pmchugh]

Does the deulisional one see a random colour, or the other witnesses shirt colour?

other witnesses colour, you made a mistake by making up a colour, anyone up for another, if you want i can add a fourth role

Mirror- only sees their own shirt
Delusional may see mirror shirt or sane shirt

[william18]

This deduction is basic compared to some of the stuff I do in whodunit puzzles.

[icedagger]

This deduction is basic compared to some of the stuff I do in whodunit puzzles.

Nah the deduction on your part was quite easy I think.. i just f*cked up by claiming a random colour rather than black.

[Clive]

Does the deulisional one see a random colour, or the other witnesses shirt colour?

other witnesses colour, you made a mistake by making up a colour, anyone up for another, if you want i can add a fourth role

Mirror- only sees their own shirt
Delusional may see mirror shirt or sane shirt

Ok, sure.

[icedagger]

I'm up for another go pmc

[william18]

This deduction is basic compared to some of the stuff I do in whodunit puzzles.

Nah the deduction on your part was quite easy I think.. i just f*cked up by claiming a random colour rather than black.

I knew it was you even before the claim, personally, I think that this setup was a bit too easy.

[icedagger]

This deduction is basic compared to some of the stuff I do in whodunit puzzles.

Nah the deduction on your part was quite easy I think.. i just f*cked up by claiming a random colour rather than black.

I knew it was you even before the claim, personally, I think that this setup was a bit too easy.

but if I'd claimed black, you would have known it was me but Clive would have had to choose between us