Asylum Mafia Game Thread Staff/Patient Town Players/Ga7 Win!

[Ditocoaf]

great game gt; thank you very much for modding. I've enjoyed this more than any of the other games I've joined since. tell me, what was AD's win condition?

[got tonkaed]

I honestly am not sure about the medicine development yet, it probably needed a little more work.

I was telling the apothicary(sheep) that for all I know I was handing out placebos. What meds were they all really? There were only 4 right?

A lot of the assumptions about medications were incorrect, there were simply 4 different strengths, and they rose as the letters rose. You could not do much bad by administering the medication, but you could stop someone from doing their night action (specifically the exile fircoal case) if you administered medication.

AD started and played the majority of the game as staff town, but as part of his choice to not join the staff mafia, he was given the special condition of needing to eliminate the staff mafia in a specific order.

[icedagger]

Nice work people! Now which of you scummy bastards was it that nk'd me?...

EDIT: Great game gt, you must've put a lot of work into it. Was definitly one of the more enjoyable games I've played (before I was so rudely killed)

[InkL0sed]

For the record, I was recruited to patient mafia the night before I was lynched. Very disappointing.

[Anarkistsdream]

I'm actually glad I died... Since I wasn't gonna win anyway, this made me look more like a hero.

[william18]

I honestly am not sure about the medicine development yet, it probably needed a little more work.

I was telling the apothicary(sheep) that for all I know I was handing out placebos. What meds were they all really? There were only 4 right?

A lot of the assumptions about medications were incorrect, there were simply 4 different strengths, and they rose as the letters rose. You could not do much bad by administering the medication, but you could stop someone from doing their night action (specifically the exile fircoal case) if you administered medication.

AD started and played the majority of the game as staff town, but as part of his choice to not join the staff mafia, he was given the special condition of needing to eliminate the staff mafia in a specific order.

I have a question about my cop sanity. If I was medicated, would I hav gotten the right results or was my Anark investigation lucky?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I maintain that it was a load of bullshit that he was given all of our names and roles to just hand over.

[/]

I've got to say, great game, but still it seemed like Scum should have deserved a victory over town, not that I'm complaining over the win, but for town to be dominated for so long just to win like that, very exciting.
Though to be fair to town, that's a heck of a lot of night kills, I don't see how it could be possible any other way to win unless scum kills each other every night..

[Anarkistsdream]

Nice work people! Now which of you scummy bastards was it that nk'd me?...

EDIT: Great game gt, you must've put a lot of work into it. Was definitly one of the more enjoyable games I've played (before I was so rudely killed)

ME, my friend!!!

[Ditocoaf]

I've got to say, great game, but still it seemed like Scum should have deserved a victory over town, not that I'm complaining over the win, but for town to be dominated for so long just to win like that, very exciting.
Though to be fair to town, that's a heck of a lot of night kills, I don't see how it could be possible any other way to win unless scum kills each other every night..

Believe me, as the remaining scum on the patient side, I was concerned foremost with that. Anark's betrayal of them helped me more than it helped town, most likely. I had a much better shot at beating the town than the staff mafia.

[Fircoal]

I honestly am not sure about the medicine development yet, it probably needed a little more work.

I was telling the apothicary(sheep) that for all I know I was handing out placebos. What meds were they all really? There were only 4 right?

A lot of the assumptions about medications were incorrect, there were simply 4 different strengths, and they rose as the letters rose. You could not do much bad by administering the medication, but you could stop someone from doing their night action (specifically the exile fircoal case) if you administered medication.

if I actually used my night action

it seemed like a good game Tonka, maybe I'll re-read it some time, I wish I played more, and actually read the scenes. XD But meh. I won. ^_^ only player to win both Asylum Mafia games. (I think the first was better though for obvious reasons. )

[got tonkaed]

william you were a random cop...so even sometimes random cops get things right.

LSU given the context of the game, your recruit of AD was awful. Your godfather should have known that AD was of no danger. The situation never should have arose.

Having said that, there is no way you should expect someone to do what AD did, i posted in a pm that i hoped he would not do it that way, but that was his choice, and he made it before i could follow it up with other posts.

[ga7]

Weee Thanks for the game GT, it was great. Funniest and most challenging role I ever got, my first WC was to get AD to kill Clive Yep I never was town Unfortunately I never bothered to track Clive cause I didn't think he could be scum, and when I had AD's trust he was making the NKs too freaking quickly for me to step in, so I was forced to come up with made-up investigation results every night
Now to more general comments, did town deserve the win? Prolly not, or only AD But it made sense in the context of the game. Sure, had staff mafia try to recruit someone else they would have won, and either way AD might have been better off not knowing all the members, but you guys were seriously overpowered to begin with. Town killed so many patients that patient mafia seemed pretty hindered in its task, but that caused the staff one to grow peacefully... And low chances of the recruiter hitting scum in so well defined factions. So did you deserve the win? One without challenge, possibly. I was thinking seeing the cults with a godfather and several recruiters that it might have run better with a multiple lynches by day setting. Anyway I hate cults in balance and in general, so I kinda understand AD's feelings after working for town most of the game, could prolly pull the same if I wasn't so liking to win

[militant]

I loved this game, Thanks G_T. I am definatley in for the next game

[nagerous]

Which of you scummy bastards killed me? Doc submarining FTW!

[mandalorian2298]

Yeah! Go Town! After you got rid of me you couldn't lose lol.

Great game Tonka and an extra great role that you gave me. My friends got real laughs out of me getting it.

[Fircoal]

Yeah! Go Town! After you got rid of me you couldn't lose lol.

Great game Tonka and an extra great role that you gave me. My friends got real laughs out of me getting it.

what did you do?

and just think Mandy, at least you won this one.

[sheepofdumb]

My only question is how drastically could I change my win conditions? I kept to the town the entire game but because of the freedom of my role I could have gone mafia or something.

[got tonkaed]

It would have depended a lot on how the system with medication worked. it didnt quite work the way i had entirely imagined it. Had it been a little more developed you would have had a lot more control over some important game elements i imagine. Which consequently would have affected how your alignment worked.

Should i decide to franchise this, and i may should i decide to still be mafiaing this summer...then ill probably have to put in a lot more leg work in the build up in order to really hammer out how thats going to work.

Ideally...

there would be a lot more potential post restrictions that would be less set and more dependent on the medication skills of the physician. However id therefore need to do more with the meds, and would need better involvement (which i think is partly why i didnt put as much into as i could have -its simply too much to ask of most players to be active to the levels that would be required to really flush this out -(not that anyone in this game did badly by any stretch -i didnt develop it enough)) in order to really work. From there, as the doler of the medicine, you could have an impact by deciding who gets the medication or not and whether or not you can tamper with the medication.

If i decide to do another game (and if theres interest) ill spend some time trying to figure out exactly how it would work.

[The1exile]

That would be interesting. It was definitely a good game, though as you say the med stuff was rather confusing.

[sheepofdumb]

Yeah, I would join in a heartbeat if you did it again. I would love a more fleshed out medication design. It felt like a "give the peoples the meds so they don't kill me" kinda feeling. Lol.

[Sierra_Leon]

Can we get a list of all night-actions? I'm curious who killed me. I think I could've been recruited, so why kill me?

[got tonkaed]

Can we get a list of all night-actions? I'm curious who killed me. I think I could've been recruited, so why kill me?

Actually in this case you cannot...unless i can find them from wherever they were. Because i didnt have a normal computer (until i was done with school and am now back home for the short term)...they may be on the schools mainframe somewhere, which i certainly no longer have access to.

So ill let you know if i find it.

[CrabNebula]

I am curious how Dito didn't die night 2. I know my treating doctor (lalaland) didn't medicate me, so there was no way of Dito surviving unless MM had given him something.

And I had no post restriction of posting like a drunkard. When I saw a few people acting like they had PR and were patients, I thought maybe only town patients got it so it would be pretty incriminating for me to not have a PR. Of course it tied well with my role claim. I was first going to roleclaim Agoraphobic patient but thought it would be too good to believeable and dropped it. And in the regards to that, till my death scene was posted I believed I was the Hysterical patient lol. Then I saw it saying "Deranged Patient" and was like .

And I was quite sure Dito was the last patient mafia, and thus was expecting him to support my lynch of AD. But he did the opposite which screwed him over. If he had supported me, then it would have been 3 town to 3 non-town which he had a good chance of winning.

Anyway, great game everyone. Thanks gt for the game

[CrabNebula]

Can we get a list of all night-actions? I'm curious who killed me. I think I could've been recruited, so why kill me?

If I remember correctly I did because you had quite established yourself as pro-town and thus it would have been harder to get you lynched.