Skoffin's Madhouse mafia Day Seven

[Iliad]

Dr jecob we know who he is
Dr fleming-finder of penicillin
I'll see who matel and toree are

EBWOP matel is dr matel dawson
http://www.answers.com/topic/matel-dawson-jr

[Sierra_Leon]

I finally read up. It's too much of a coinicdence for there to be two relatively obscure historians who also happen to be rivals with no link in my opinion. I do find it a bit strange that they would both claim survivor. I think a good bet would be maybe to investiage/vig one of them tonight and see what happens.

Why not lynch one, and vig(SK if there are and they want to help) the other if we got pro town on one?

Because then we are out both of our historians, at least one of which we would surely like to keep.

I agree with Ice, but if we follow that, then who dies?

Kalish's death really gave us nothing.

Why? They're both claiming to be survivors with no useful night action. They're more of a liablitity for town end-game than they are good. And still you wonder why I linked you to Dito..

Lynch Dito please!


About the map: not sure what Skoffin's got planned with that. The infirmary sounds like a place where you would be protected, but I suppose that would be to easy. I might just let random.org decide where I move, since I don't think anything here will be what I would expect it to be.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sierra, I'm sorry, but Dito doesn't seem scummy... Scum would never volunteer so much info to get into a huge debate over...

Unless, that is, he wanted to call someone else out or start this to make him appear more townish, but I highly doubt anyone would think that would work.

As for the map... It's a good way to allow masons through a night cycle. Everybody who ends up in the same room can talk to one another.

[fireedud]

I'm not sure what to think of Dito. He's always changing viewpoints, and sometimes even contradicting himself...

Also, about the map, Do we have to Pm them to you?

[animorpherv1]

I'd still rather go for exile right now.

[ace1217]

Whos jecob? Anyway, i'm gonna go to the laundry room.

[animorpherv1]

And I'm going to the spot where the PA system is

[icedagger]

What happens to a lyncher if his target is NKd? Also if we lynch a lynchee, has the lyncher won the game or does he share the victory with town/mafia?

[animorpherv1]

I think you gave your role away,

unvote vote: ice

[icedagger]

Foiled again! My subtle questions were no match for the investigative prowess of animo

[Sierra_Leon]

lolz

What happens to a lyncher if his target is NKd? Also if we lynch a lynchee, has the lyncher won the game or does he share the victory with town/mafia?

The game will most likely continue on as normal. The lyncher is removed from the game, because he has already won. That doesn't exclude that town/mafia can still also win the game.

No guarantees of course; there exist variations of this role, but this is the most common one.

[mr. incrediball]

What happens to a lyncher if his target is NKd? Also if we lynch a lynchee, has the lyncher won the game or does he share the victory with town/mafia?

last i checked, when a lynchee gets NKed, then the lyncher becomes a townie.

[Anarkistsdream]

What happens to a lyncher if his target is NKd? Also if we lynch a lynchee, has the lyncher won the game or does he share the victory with town/mafia?

last i checked, when a lynchee gets NKed, then the lyncher becomes a townie.

That is what I thought, also.

[mandalorian2298]

I honestly tried to re-read, but there was just too much spam. Luckily, I noticed one of my favorite tells attached to a new player, so I can rest now.

Unvote

Enough of this tomfoolery, let's try and lynch some mafia.

The only people who get this militant and decisive to lynch those bad, bad yet unidentified scum are Scum (and Militant, who is obviously always militant).

Vote Mac

[kwanton]

I call women's bathroom!


Actually I haven't decided if I want to move at all

[sam_levi_11]

ice if you are a lyncher what person are you looking for? And if not why ask so. Also why the Helen of Troy referrence.

[sam_levi_11]

just to clear up i meant why did the scene mention it, not asking ice that last question

[icedagger]

Skim much?

I don't think there's any doubt they're both historians, lyncher/lynchee (possibly both lynchers after eachother) and both survivors seem the most likely alignments. I can't see either of them being mafia now really

And dito's latest "lynch one of us!" post only adds to this. But if what mr inc says is true, I'd rather NK one of them and keep the other as a townie.

I honestly have no idea who else to lynch if not them.. AD has struck me as scummy but he does that in pretty much every game including when he's a protown power role so it doesn't mean that much.

[The Weird One]

Well, since kwan doesn't want 'em, I'm visiting the women's bathroom/showers

[william18]

Skim much?

I don't think there's any doubt they're both historians, lyncher/lynchee (possibly both lynchers after eachother) and both survivors seem the most likely alignments. I can't see either of them being mafia now really

And dito's latest "lynch one of us!" post only adds to this. But if what mr inc says is true, I'd rather NK one of them and keep the other as a townie.

I honestly have no idea who else to lynch if not them.. AD has struck me as scummy but he does that in pretty much every game including when he's a protown power role so it doesn't mean that much.

If so I think we should chose one for nk. I beleive there are more the just 1 vig and if one kills dito then another vig might accdentaly kill exile do to lack of communication. So who should get vigilante's slugs?

[Skoffin]

I'm not sure what to think of Dito. He's always changing viewpoints, and sometimes even contradicting himself...

Also, about the map, Do we have to Pm them to you?

PM them to me.
And guys, by the fact you have to send them in, I assumed you'd think twice before telling all where you're headed. It may or may not be in your best interest to tell everyone where you are going.

[Innervision]

Sierra, I'm sorry, but Dito doesn't seem scummy... Scum would never volunteer so much info to get into a huge debate over...

Unless, that is, he wanted to call someone else out or start this to make him appear more townish, but I highly doubt anyone would think that would work.

As for the map... It's a good way to allow masons through a night cycle. Everybody who ends up in the same room can talk to one another.

I'm sorry, but it seems as if you yourself believe Dito to be townie, if he is scum, his plan seems to have worked.

[Fitzgerald]

I'll replace.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sierra, I'm sorry, but Dito doesn't seem scummy... Scum would never volunteer so much info to get into a huge debate over...

Unless, that is, he wanted to call someone else out or start this to make him appear more townish, but I highly doubt anyone would think that would work.

As for the map... It's a good way to allow masons through a night cycle. Everybody who ends up in the same room can talk to one another.

I'm sorry, but it seems as if you yourself believe Dito to be townie, if he is scum, his plan seems to have worked.

And who are you?

Ahhhh, nobody...

[militant]

I dont see aproblem with hanging Dito, with such a large game like this, the pages stack up quickly so I tend to get behind, but from my understanding, Dito and Exile are rival historians, one scum and the other town, now either Dito is telling the truth and is town, and Exile is scum or the other way round, so we might aswell lynch one and then we have caught ourselves a scumbag, now I would prefer to lynch dito becasue he is struggling with such a big game and would rather be dead in some ways, so Vote Dito