Revamp

[multiplayertim]

With the huge interest in the Brazil Revamp who does everyone think the next map to go under the knife should be.

[gimil]

With the huge interest in the Brazil Revamp who does everyone think the next map to go under the knife should be.

There is a revamp proposal thread already open. Ill dig it out in a bit and see where were going next. However you wont know where or when the next revamp will be!

I like suprises

[oaktown]

revamps, revamps... I think competitions are great, but we can more creative than just doing revamps over and over again.

anyway, you left off North America, which would've been my top choice.

[edbeard]

four of your choices shouldn't be on there

classic: people will never let this happen. changing circle opacity was bad enough. only way possible is if people have the option to choose which lack doesn't want to do for whatever reason (maybe it opens up too many unknowns?)

South America, Middle Earth, Extreme Global Warming, and SOUTH AMERICA all have fine graphics. nothing world obliterating but good enough for the current guidelines and there are much worse maps out there.




Africa would be my choice for the next competition

[Qwert]

europe-wrong names on map,all ready discused

[t-o-m]

Africa for me.

[multiplayertim]

Which map needs a revamp?

Poll runs till Sat Sep 06, 2008 7:32 pm
You may select 1 option

Africa 2 15%

Ancient Greece 0 No votes

Asia 3 23%

Classic 1 7%

Europe 2 15%

Extreme Global Warming 0 No votes

Hong Kong 2 15%

Middle Earth 1 7%

South America 1 7%

North America 1 7%

[multiplayertim]

four of your choices shouldn't be on there

classic: people will never let this happen. changing circle opacity was bad enough. only way possible is if people have the option to choose which lack doesn't want to do for whatever reason (maybe it opens up too many unknowns?)

South America, Middle Earth, Extreme Global Warming, and SOUTH AMERICA all have fine graphics. nothing world obliterating but good enough for the current guidelines and there are much worse maps out there.




Africa would be my choice for the next competition

i was trying to give a lot of options South America least deserves to be on the list but i think Middle Earth could do with better clarity and Extreme Global Warming doesn't look great really could be better for such a good map gameplay wise

[TaCktiX]

Middle Earth could do with some proper spelling. There's at least half a dozen naming errors on that map.

[multiplayertim]

Middle Earth could do with some proper spelling. There's at least half a dozen naming errors on that map.

Or course a lot of these maps got through when the foundry process was just beginning and not as strict. By the way i don't intend this thread as an insult to any mapmaker on the list I recently drew a map on my computer and its tough to even reach poor graphics standerd when its held up next to some of the wonders that have been quenched recently i have resigned myself to months of tutorials

[pepperonibread]

I'd say that Tamriel and N. America should be at the top of the list.
And someone mentioned Global Warming, I was planning to touch that up at some point (I'm the creator).

[lanyards]

All of those except Extreme Global Warming and Middle Earth need a revamp. Middle Earth looks fine, but I think someone could make that map look really cool. Extreme Global Warming and South America should never get revamp.

--lanyards

[dittoeevee8888]

North America.

It bugged me a lot when I was playing on that map that the tropics have two different colours.

[King Dain II]

Even though it is my favorite map, a Siege! revamp is needed. Not that it is as horrific as Brazil was when it got its revamp, but Siege! has far greater potential.

[Androidz]

Conquerman And Malta...

They need a revamp:/

[ZeakCytho]

Siege and Malta are absolutely fine as is. I've always found ConquerMan visually unpleasing, but it's impossible to make it look good and keep the retro theme. There are many maps in much more need of a revamp than those three.

[RjBeals]

Conquerman And Malta...

They need a revamp:/

What? How would/could you revamp Conquerman - and Malta is a great map!

[King Dain II]

I just looked at Malta and it is perfectly fine. What are you talking about? ConquerMan Seriously needs an update, but how would you do it? Whatever you change detracts from the theme.

[Androidz]

Conquerman And Malta...

They need a revamp:/

What? How would/could you revamp Conquerman - and Malta is a great map!

Well i get conquerman is based on GameGraphics/Retro. But it really hurt my eyes and must be other way makeing it Retro and not be so Dark, and hurtfull lol. So with a revamp people will give tons of suggestions how to fix that so im sure some1 would make it better.


Malta looks like brazil graphics. (not your brazil but the first). Its a good map and all but there its just something there i think its unpleasant..wellwell thats just me=)

[ZeakCytho]

The old Brazil is nowhere near the quality of the Malta map. Sure, it's not the prettiest map on CC, but at least it wasn't made in paint.

[Androidz]

The old Brazil is nowhere near the quality of the Malta map. Sure, it's not the prettiest map on CC, but at least it wasn't made in paint.

true...and i might have stretched it a bit far calling it Brazil graphic:D sorry.

[WidowMakers]

I've always found ConquerMan visually unpleasing, but it's impossible to make it look good and keep the retro theme. There are many maps in much more need of a revamp than those three.

It is suposed to be an 8 bit retro game. It actually has better resolution that the actual game. I am sorry if you do not like it but it is designed to look this way, not due to lack of talent or error but due to purposeful design.

No revamp.

I think the revamps are getting a bit carried away with. I personally think we are nearing the end of them. With Brazil and Germany getting worked on, I really only think NA is left.

WM

[ZeakCytho]

I've always found ConquerMan visually unpleasing, but it's impossible to make it look good and keep the retro theme. There are many maps in much more need of a revamp than those three.

It is suposed to be an 8 bit retro game. It actually has better resolution that the actual game. I am sorry if you do not like it but it is designed to look this way, not due to lack of talent or error but due to purposeful design.

I know, I said that. Not trying to bash you. Your other maps are all amazing

[InkL0sed]

I agree revamps need to be kept to a minimum. Some maps may need touch-ups, but really none but North America need a full-blown revamp...

[pepperonibread]

I've always found ConquerMan visually unpleasing, but it's impossible to make it look good and keep the retro theme. There are many maps in much more need of a revamp than those three.

It is suposed to be an 8 bit retro game. It actually has better resolution that the actual game. I am sorry if you do not like it but it is designed to look this way, not due to lack of talent or error but due to purposeful design.

No revamp.

I think the revamps are getting a bit carried away with. I personally think we are nearing the end of them. With Brazil and Germany getting worked on, I really only think NA is left.

WM

I agree revamps need to be kept to a minimum. Some maps may need touch-ups, but really none but North America need a full-blown revamp...

I'd say Tamriel needs one as well. Does everyone just forget about that map, or am I in the minority here?