Simple C9 Game [Day 2]

[Stephan Wayne]

If seirra is telling the truth, then we know for sure who the scum are (simon and steven). Otherwise, stroop or I could have hammered for the win.

On the other hand, if she's scum, her partner is probably stroop. I doubt she would be outing her own partner with her fake cop claim.

Right now, I think I believe sierra, because I've been suspicious of steven all game, and her accusations do indeed make sense. I'll give the whole thread a read and then make my decision.

this is an interesting statement seeing as i suspected you
in all you scenarios you never hypothesized yourself as a rebel

[dunc_2007]

this is an interesting statement seeing as i suspected you
in all you scenarios you never hypothesized yourself as a rebel

Well, there's this:

If seirra is telling the truth, then we know for sure who the scum are (simon and steven). Otherwise, stroop or I could have hammered for the win.

Let's assume sierra is telling the truth. If I was scum, I would have hammered by now, and won the game. Obviously, that's not the case.

If sierra is actually scum, and is lying, then I have no proof I'm not scum. You'll just have to trust me.

As for you, steven, I'd like you to explain this:

vote Sierra_Leon
his words and actions dont mach up if he is in the mafia hes playing his part if hes not then what the hells up with what your doing
his vote has no reason what are you doing if your not a rebal

His vote does indeed have a reason. He investigated simon, simon was scum. What do you mean 'his actions don't match up with his words'?

[Stephan Wayne]

this is an interesting statement seeing as i suspected you
in all you scenarios you never hypothesized yourself as a rebel

Well, there's this:

If seirra is telling the truth, then we know for sure who the scum are (simon and steven). Otherwise, stroop or I could have hammered for the win.

Let's assume sierra is telling the truth. If I was scum, I would have hammered by now, and won the game. Obviously, that's not the case.

If sierra is actually scum, and is lying, then I have no proof I'm not scum. You'll just have to trust me.

As for you, steven, I'd like you to explain this:

vote Sierra_Leon
his words and actions dont mach up if he is in the mafia hes playing his part if hes not then what the hells up with what your doing
his vote has no reason what are you doing if your not a rebal

His vote does indeed have a reason. He investigated simon, simon was scum. What do you mean 'his actions don't match up with his words'?

i mean he said i was mob then voted for someone else

[dunc_2007]

i mean he said i was mob then voted for someone else

Ok, thank you for explaining. But he did also say simon was scum, so I still think his actions made sense.

Stroop, what do you think? 'Cause right now, I'm pretty freaking close to voting simon.

[Stroop]

i mean he said i was mob then voted for someone else

Ok, thank you for explaining. But he did also say simon was scum, so I still think his actions made sense.

Stroop, what do you think? 'Cause right now, I'm pretty freaking close to voting simon.

Sierra's claim is very plausible, especially without the counter-claim. Simon comes up with bullshit about Sierra perhaps being insane or random. Stephen decides to jump in and vote Sierra, without a proper reason, and Simon joins in on the fun, putting Sierra at L-1, which is very dangerous to the town if Sierra is indeed a cop.

It means either one of us is scum together with Sierra, or Simon and Stephen are scum buddies. I'm thinking it's the second option, as I'm pretty convinced you aren't scum, and Stephen has been acting suspicious for a while now.

If Sierra's not scum then the mafia will jump on this, if they don't, Sierra is scum.

I think the mafia were the only ones to jump on it...

vote Simon

[Sierra_Leon]

Dunc and Stroop have proven themselves town in my eyes, by not hammering me and winning the game as scum. This leaves Stephen almost 100% sure as Simon's buddy. I realize that you have to consider the possibility that I'm lying, but if you look back at my day 1 suspicions you will see that I already thought Simon was scummy. It only follows that I investigated him last night. Simon on the other hand has been using terrible arguments for his votes and today he and stephen are just throwing a OMGUS vote out on me.

I think I've said all I can say. I see Stroop has already chosen to believe me over Simon; it's now up to dunc to make his decision.

[dunc_2007]

Vote simon.

Sierra has been much more believable than simon/steven. There's nothing to say that hasn't been said already. Either we've got the game in the bag, or sierra did an excellent job tricking us.

[Sierra_Leon]

Win!

Congratz Stroop, your played a flawless game. GG to the rest of you guys.

Stephen, were you the real cop or was there some other reason you didn't trust me?

[Stroop]

For a moment there I didn't think we could pull it off

Good game everyone

[Stephan Wayne]

Win!

Congratz Stroop, your played a flawless game. GG to the rest of you guys.

Stephen, were you the real cop or was there some other reason you didn't trust me?

is the game over if so yeah i was the cop but i only invesgated chicken lord
i knew it was you becase why would you say what you said if you were town

[Stroop]

Win!

Congratz Stroop, your played a flawless game. GG to the rest of you guys.

Stephen, were you the real cop or was there some other reason you didn't trust me?

is the game over if so yeah i was the cop but i only invesgated chicken lord
i knew it was you becase why would you say what you said if you were town

Yep, game is over. Mafia won.

If you had counterclaimed, I think it'd be more likely that Sierra got lynched, since you only put more suspicion on you and Simon by voting for no specific reason at all

Anyway, I hope you enjoyed playing and that we'll see you here more often

[drake_259]

After the townspeople lynched another townie, the rebels had out numbered the other townies and reviled themselfs and killed the rest off them.

Roles:
Stroop - Mafia
Sierra_Leon - Mafia
Stephen Wayne - Cop
Nickbaldwin - Doctor
Chicken_lord - VT
Simon Viavant - VT
dunc_2007 - VT

[dunc_2007]

Dangit! Nicely done, sierra and stroop.

[drake_259]

i laughed at the 1st lynch, you should have at least let nick role claimed

and as for the second Stephen should have counterclaimed.

[Sierra_Leon]

Win!

Congratz Stroop, your played a flawless game. GG to the rest of you guys.

Stephen, were you the real cop or was there some other reason you didn't trust me?

is the game over if so yeah i was the cop but i only invesgated chicken lord
i knew it was you becase why would you say what you said if you were town

Stroop and I expected that if there was a cop and chicken lord is not it, the cop would most likely investigate chicken lord. That's why we killed him. If Stephen had counterclaimed, I would have said something like "so you investigated a dead guy, how convenient.." But I admit I would've likely gotten lynched, because me and Stroop agreed that he'd bus me (that means vote for your scum partner) if there was a counterclaim.