Skoffin's Madhouse mafia Day Seven

[william18]

It's all very odd. I can't see why Neutrino would counterclaim on your action if he knew you were telling the truth. It would be suicide.

Weird roles might play into this situation, but we can't be sure. I say we verify AD and solve this issue by lynching Ani since the original investigation resulted in getting him as scum. Then we'll be able to figure out this whole AD/Ani/Militant/Neutrino business.

Vote Ani

Animorph is dead,and he came up as town.

That's what I get for posting before a thorough rereading.

This is what threw me off though:

As to what William said, I thought AD said he followed Ani the night before last, and now he's saying he tracked Militant last night. But once again, I need to reread.

I did follow Animorph... But neutrino said he tracked me and I visited Militant. So last night I visited Militant and got a MUCH different result than what I got when I followed Animorph...

So, either Neut is lying or I was wrong about Animorph...

You were wrong about Animorph. He turned up town. And what further baffles me so is William. Why are you voting Neutrino if, by all accounts, it appears that he still may not be incorrect about AD having visited Militant instead of Animorph?

I didn't vote Militant because Anark got militant as town.

That's what I'm saying. Anark got Ani as scum, but Ani was not scum. Thus, three options exist:
1. AD gets incorrect investigations: Neutrino lied.
2. AD gets correct investigations, and some role interfered: Neutrino is telling the truth.
3. AD is lying: Neutrino is telling the truth.

Im starting to beleive Neutrino. Why would he risk his own neck if he was scum just to get Militant killed? Because he isn't scum. I highly doubt there is an interferring role.

Unvote

[F1fth]

Fastposted.

William, if AD was scum, he could certainly fake his way through "investigations" since he would know who's scum and who's not. But that said, why would he say Ani was scum? Ani's role turned out to be relatively useless if I recall correctly, so why would AD draw attention to himself like that?

[william18]

Fastposted.

William, if AD was scum, he could certainly fake his way through "investigations" since he would know who's scum and who's not. But that said, why would he say Ani was scum? Ani's role turned out to be relatively useless if I recall correctly, so why would AD draw attention to himself like that?

Not sure. I also don't know why militant got protected but it happened. I guess that Anark thought he could get away with ani getting killed, and just blame it on a bus driver.

[F1fth]

Fastposted.

William, if AD was scum, he could certainly fake his way through "investigations" since he would know who's scum and who's not. But that said, why would he say Ani was scum? Ani's role turned out to be relatively useless if I recall correctly, so why would AD draw attention to himself like that?

Not sure. I also don't know why militant got protected but it happened. I guess that Anark thought he could get away with ani getting killed, and just blame it on a bus driver.

AD's definitely smart enough to throw us a WIFOM like that. He also called his sanity into question when he stated his role name. That would have been another out for him.

Like you said, it is farfetched, but the pieces do seem to fit into place. Militant's claim was pretty solid though: Sherlock Holmes, finds an item that belongs to the investigated person. But if he were faking it, two of his investigations on people he would have known the role of (scum would know Skittles wasn't lying about being a princess and Dito had already died). That leaves ga7's golden fiddle.

(If it sounds like I'm working this out as I go along, it's because I am. I haven't decided what I'm more inclined to believe).

The most conservative course of action would be to wait for another investigative role to look at AD or Mili. If we must lynch someone though, I would recommend Militant. We have the least at stake and the most to gain with that course of action. While his claimed role has its uses, it's still not that helpful because a clever person could explain a incriminating item away.

[Anarkistsdream]

Well, if you kill me or Militant, you are killing investigation roles...

So unless you can find a third investigator, I'd say you are up a creek.

[nagerous]

Militant posted something that he saw on me today by the way and it fits with my role.

[F1fth]

Militant posted something that he saw on me today by the way and it fits with my role.

That's enough in my mind to clear the both of them then. AD being scum wouldn't make sense if Mili wasn't scum.

I'm of the opinion that there was some role interference going on. But I still can't explain how Neutrino found that AD went to Militant and not Animorph, and also why AD got a scum result when he went after Ani. Any ideas?

[mandalorian2298]

I'm totaly lost. I don't know if it's the 2-week-long-Night or Skoffin's mad setup, but I really have no idea what's going on. Tonka, come out and find point me the Scumster, you pro-Town hero you.

[F1fth]

I'm totaly lost. I don't know if it's the 2-week-long-Night or Skoffin's mad setup, but I really have no idea what's going on. Tonka, come out and find point me the Scumster, you pro-Town hero you.

Actually, it was a two-week-long-double-night because of the beloved princess. And I agree, this game is hard to get a grasp on.

[Anarkistsdream]

A BUNCH of non-posters here...

1. Macalester (Replaced by Neutrino)
2. Icedagger
10. Fircoal
12. Kwanton
16. Cmckinney (replaced by Darkwingstalker BACK to Cmc)
17. /
21. mandyb (Replaced by Fireedud)
27. danodukebb
30. Innervision

All of these people need to post more... And without their posting, we don't know if they are submarining or just not around. It makes this game WAY more complicated.

Danodukebb I believe is not really on site anymore. He should be replaced.

Innvervision needs to be replaced or start being active.

Where the hell is that little yellow rat, Fircoal?

Haven't seen icedagger or CMCKinney in quite a while.

Any ideas, folks?

[icedagger]

A few of the people on your list are dead AD.

Gah this has gotten complicated.. I have reason to believe AD isn't mafia or one of the GGs though. Could you give us your full list of results?

[F1fth]

A BUNCH of non-posters here...

1. Macalester (Replaced by Neutrino)
2. Icedagger
10. Fircoal
12. Kwanton
16. Cmckinney (replaced by Darkwingstalker BACK to Cmc)
17. /
21. mandyb (Replaced by Fireedud)
27. danodukebb
30. Innervision

All of these people need to post more... And without their posting, we don't know if they are submarining or just not around. It makes this game WAY more complicated.

Danodukebb I believe is not really on site anymore. He should be replaced.

Innvervision needs to be replaced or start being active.

Where the hell is that little yellow rat, Fircoal?

Haven't seen icedagger or CMCKinney in quite a while.

Any ideas, folks?

Modkill? This game with 20 people in it feels like a 3-4 person conversation.

[Neutrino]

Not wanting to let go of any potential lead, I followed AD both nights and got the same result: militant. AD does claim to have investigated Militant once, but twice? Why'd you waste two on 'im, AD? I think this lends a little credence to William's theory last page about Nark being a mafia doc, or at least something like it. That said, someone could always be misdirecting my investigations to screw around with everyone else (though spending two people's actions on it seems a tad wasteful).

[william18]

So anark visited mili both night.
He neglects to to inform us of night 5 results.
Militant was protected.


Hmm, not looking good for anark.

[Anarkistsdream]

A few of the people on your list are dead AD.

Gah this has gotten complicated.. I have reason to believe AD isn't mafia or one of the GGs though. Could you give us your full list of results?

Blame the mod for not updating...

Not wanting to let go of any potential lead, I followed AD both nights and got the same result: militant. AD does claim to have investigated Militant once, but twice? Why'd you waste two on 'im, AD? I think this lends a little credence to William's theory last page about Nark being a mafia doc, or at least something like it. That said, someone could always be misdirecting my investigations to screw around with everyone else (though spending two people's actions on it seems a tad wasteful).

No shit, Sherlock... I didn't follow Mili both nights, or have you forgotten? I followed Animorph the previous night. Since I was trusting what you said to be accurate, I assumed that if I truly had seen Militant and not Animorph, then the second night I would 'seer' Militant to see if I got the same result, which I didn't...

I am not outing Milis role, either, as it's pretty cool.

So anark visited mili both night.
He neglects to to inform us of night 5 results.
Militant was protected.


Hmm, not looking good for anark.

Jesus, my girlfriend broke up with me, I have been moving. I have missed a lot of shit. I don't have internet at my house... My life is in the shitter. If you want to lynch me because I missed a damn night action, then fine, but that's just dumb.

[william18]

A few of the people on your list are dead AD.

Gah this has gotten complicated.. I have reason to believe AD isn't mafia or one of the GGs though. Could you give us your full list of results?

Blame the mod for not updating...

Not wanting to let go of any potential lead, I followed AD both nights and got the same result: militant. AD does claim to have investigated Militant once, but twice? Why'd you waste two on 'im, AD? I think this lends a little credence to William's theory last page about Nark being a mafia doc, or at least something like it. That said, someone could always be misdirecting my investigations to screw around with everyone else (though spending two people's actions on it seems a tad wasteful).

No shit, Sherlock... I didn't follow Mili both nights, or have you forgotten? I followed Animorph the previous night. Since I was trusting what you said to be accurate, I assumed that if I truly had seen Militant and not Animorph, then the second night I would 'seer' Militant to see if I got the same result, which I didn't...

I am not outing Milis role, either, as it's pretty cool.

So anark visited mili both night.
He neglects to to inform us of night 5 results.
Militant was protected.


Hmm, not looking good for anark.

Jesus, my girlfriend broke up with me, I have been moving. I have missed a lot of shit. I don't have internet at my house... My life is in the shitter. If you want to lynch me because I missed a damn night action, then fine, but that's just dumb.

How did you miss the night 5 action if Neutrino got you visiting militant? Pardon me if this is incorrect but when neutrino meant "both nights" I assume that he means night 5 and 6. So that means you tracked him 3 times and always got militant(please correct me if im wrong).

[Anarkistsdream]

Then what are you talking about me missing a night result? You mean it was incorrect or I didn't do it?

[william18]

Didn't do it.

[Neutrino]

How did you miss the night 5 action if Neutrino got you visiting militant? Pardon me if this is incorrect but when neutrino meant "both nights" I assume that he means night 5 and 6. So that means you tracked him 3 times and always got militant(please correct me if im wrong).

Yeah, that's right. I tracked AD on nights 4, 5 and 6 and followed him to Militant every single time.
We, the people, demand explanation, AD.

[Anarkistsdream]

How did you miss the night 5 action if Neutrino got you visiting militant? Pardon me if this is incorrect but when neutrino meant "both nights" I assume that he means night 5 and 6. So that means you tracked him 3 times and always got militant(please correct me if im wrong).

Yeah, that's right. I tracked AD on nights 4, 5 and 6 and followed him to Militant every single time.
We, the people, demand explanation, AD.

The really messed up part about this is that I have chosen someone different every night... And I keep getting different results.

I honestly have nothing to say about this, but, to show that I must be right at least part of the time, Militant is Sherlock Holmes...

He should have been able to investigate me by now...

Mili, am I scum?

[william18]

We can't really let Militant set a testimony for anark. That's plausibly the same as letting the Godfather testify for his Mafia doc. So my idea is lynch militant. Thus we either:

A) Get the godfather
B) Lynch a somewhat helpful role instead of a extremly powerful role.

Vote Militant

[Anarkistsdream]

We can't really let Militant set a testimony for anark. That's plausibly the same as letting the Godfather testify for his Mafia doc. So my idea is lynch militant. Thus we either:

A) Get the godfather
B) Lynch a somewhat helpful role instead of a extremly powerful role.

Vote Militant

Except that Nagerous also believes me...

There are only two of you who keep thinking I am scum when I am not. And, I have proven myself to several people in as much as I can.

I will not lynch a cop... Have fun doing it yourself.

[william18]

We can't really let Militant set a testimony for anark. That's plausibly the same as letting the Godfather testify for his Mafia doc. So my idea is lynch militant. Thus we either:

A) Get the godfather
B) Lynch a somewhat helpful role instead of a extremly powerful role.

Vote Militant

Except that Nagerous also believes me...

There are only two of you who keep thinking I am scum when I am not. And, I have proven myself to several people in as much as I can.

I will not lynch a cop... Have fun doing it yourself.

I'd expected you wouldn't.

[icedagger]

Wait.. so AD was tracked visiting mili on a night when he said he didn't send in an action?

Vote AD

[Anarkistsdream]

Wait.. so AD was tracked visiting mili on a night when he said he didn't send in an action?

Vote AD

When did I ever say I didn't send in an action?

I said that I have been dealing with a lot of shit in real life, and if I missed one, that's too bad.