Icepeak mafia [Town wins!]

[spaceghst44]

what does OMGUS mean?

[sam_levi_11]

what does OMGUS mean?

OhMiGodUSuck

[spiesr]

It is when you for vote someone for for voting for you.

[spaceghst44]

we haven't heard from a lot of people in a while.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I for one still think that spiesr is quite guilty in his wanting the cop to come out. He may have claimed, but without knowing the actual roles in this game joe blow could claim to be a blue monkey in a space suit if it fit the theme and possibly be correct. Actions wise he definitely seems scummy.

[spiesr]

Do I need to reiterate how I only wanted the cop to cop out if we could catch a scum out if it and that nick recently suggested the cop come out and got no suspicion for it? Or are we just saying that even under that interpretation of events I am scummy.

Also, we don't know nothing about the game. We know it is a mafia and werewolves game. So the is a very high chance of angle being a role.

[pmchugh]

The deadline is today its time to bandwagon people, we can't have two no lynches. I've heard Nate's claim and don't believe it, I think it should be him to go. I doubt we will get a more scummy looking, poorly claimed person by the end of today.

unvote vote nate

[spaceghst44]

VOTE NATE

no f'ing clue cause no one posts.

[pmchugh]

DEADLINE APPROACHING GET VOTING PEOPLE

Current (unofficial) vote count:

spiesr - 3 (LSU Tiger Josh, drake_259, Sierra_Leon)
Natewolfman - 3 (pmchugh, Nickbaldwin,space)
LSU- 1 (farside)
space- 1 (speisr)

7 to lynch which means we need at least 4 to change for a lynch. Speisrs claim seems more legit to me, we must lynch nate.

[Sierra_Leon]

I disagree. Spiesr has been acting way more scummier than Nate. Spiesr has claimed a doc-role, which is the easiest fake-claim in the books. Nate has claimed a cop-role, which might give us results tomorrow. I would rather lynch spiesr over Nate.

I'm already voting spiesr, and I'm keeping my vote there.

[spiesr]

When exactly is the deadline?
I will unvote vote wolfman simply to avoid a no lynch at this point.

[farside22]

I disagree. Spiesr has been acting way more scummier than Nate. Spiesr has claimed a doc-role, which is the easiest fake-claim in the books. Nate has claimed a cop-role, which might give us results tomorrow. I would rather lynch spiesr over Nate.

I'm already voting spiesr, and I'm keeping my vote there.

I agree with this. But I really just dont know about Nate's claim. It's just weird. Then on the other hand Spiesr trying to out the cop was worse.

unvote:
vote: Spiesr

[Stroop]

When exactly is the deadline?

Sorry, been busy. The deadline was exactly about 20 hours ago. I will make an end-of-day scene later today, when I get back from badminton. Votes made after this post will no longer be counted.

[Stroop]

=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=
Vote count

spiesr - 4 (LSU Tiger Josh, drake_259, Sierra_Leon, farside22)
Natewolfman - 4 (pmchugh, Nickbaldwin, spaceghst44, spiesr)

Not voting: sam_levi_11, dunc_2007, cena-rules, Natewolfman

With 12 alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch.

Scene coming up!
=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=*=

[Stroop]

It seemed like such a good idea when the town heard about the threat they were facing. Just get together and then democratically decide who to kill. Sadly, the town couldn't reach a majority of votes yet again. Two people appeared to be a valid lynch, but both of them managed to stay out of trouble, for now.

For the second time, the villagers head home without the comfort of having reduced the threat to their lives.

Night 2 starts now!

Send in your actions.

[pmchugh]

tsk another no lynch.

[Stroop]

Despite the night being quieter than the night before, only ten citizens gathered at the city hall this morning. Nickbaldwin's house was searched, and after finding his gun and badge, it was clear that the town had lost another good-willed individual.

Nickbaldwin - Town Cop has been killed

The town went to the search the house of the other missing citizen. A gun was found, but no proof of his claim as deputy to go along with it. Natewolfman did not appear to be part of the law-enforcement, and when several packets of drugs were found in his basement, the town was sure of his guilt

Natewolfman - Mafia Goon has been killed

Day 3 starts now!

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

[spiesr]

Since I have claimed yesterday, I might as well tell my action. I protected Nickbaldwin last night. Not that it did any good, as the mafia got him not the werewolfs...

So Nickbaldwin was a cop. He could probably have gotten Natewolfman lynched yesterday if he had spoken up about how he was a cop who could use his powers every night, and he would likely be alive today too, as the doctor would know who to protect. But anyway, that idea would be "scummy" so I shall speak no more of it.

[Sierra_Leon]

There were plenty of people protecting Nate yesterday or at least not pursueing his case. I'm sad to realize I was one of them, but I will read back on those posts anyway because there's a good chance the other mafia is among them.

[farside22]

Well I wanted to see if Nate would have info. You got to laugh that the wolf(s) took him down. The question is, is spiers lying. Who else thought nate wasn't lying. Was his partner on the wagon.
I'm still thinking LSU and pmc are together. I need to look at who nate may have had as a buddy. I would be surprised if there was more then 2 of each group.

[pmchugh]

Well I wanted to see if Nate would have info. You got to laugh that the wolf(s) took him down. The question is, is spiers lying. Who else thought nate wasn't lying. Was his partner on the wagon.
I'm still thinking LSU and pmc are together. I need to look at who nate may have had as a buddy. I would be surprised if there was more then 2 of each group.

Speisr, me and lsu? Still? I can't see how you can still suspect speisr, he voted for nate so hes probably on the wolves side if hes scum. Then would he really kill nate? Nate was the joint top suspect with him and by doing that hes eliminating the competition of course this is WIFOM but it doesnt sit right. Plus I think his claim is semi believable, certainly more so than nate's was.

For nate's partner sorry to say but your top of my list, and this isn't just OMGUS before someone says it. From the start of the game youv'e tried to divert attention from him while never coming out and protecting him entirely, so you could help him but without appearing suspicious.

In your very first most you failed to mention nate at all despite him being the biggest suspect at the time.

Second post, mainly bashing me, lsu and speisr (not much has changed) but some comments on nate are made:

Nat's vote on PMC comes off as OMGUS.

Pointing out the obvious, you had to agree with that or else you may as well of claimed nate's scum buddy.

I'm thinking more likely Nat is scum and Pmc is wolf but that is just me right now.

Not sure about Nat's claim. But seriously Spiesr last comment just deserves a vote on principle alone. YUCK!

Both of these say to me, ok nate is scummy but lets look at these other people instead. Both times you start with nate then move onto the one you really want to get lynched.

Then you were prompted for your opinion on nate from various players and heres what you came up with.

Okay since I was asked this by a few people I will start with Nate and then move on to LSU and ace interaction.

I see a pattern emerging here. (Nate first etc.)

Nate: Okay he says he read the game but glossed over the time limit. His unvote for drake was explained because he thought his vote would lynch him. (meh)

ive been watching and reading all this i just havnt had a need to post anything

This isn't helpful at all.
Talks about how it's normal for him not to talk much day 1. Meh I don't believe in meta but if you do it all the time it's a null tell.

2 "meh" s sounds like someone is trying to push nate into the background. The second one you say you don't believe in meta but then declare it a null tell on nate, contradicting yourself.

i unvoted because i had voted for drake (I think?) and it was a random vote, he had like 2 others after me so i took it off since i didnt want to accidently aid in that lynch, simple as that, however I didnt have sufficient evidence to condem ani either, so take that as you may

I really don't like this comment. Scum is more concerned if they vote for a townie because they look scummy.

*sigh* Im the deputy (though i wasnt told who the main investigation role is) It works the same only on an every other day basis, and now if you dont lynch me i will likelly die in the night (unless the Dr. protects me lol, last time i claimed i was the doc so that didnt help me ) of course if you see someone hammer me and my role is proven you will know who your real mafia probably is

Lets mark all the bad things on this quote
1) telling PR's what to do
2) plea to emotion
3) if you look like scum and someone hammers and you are what you say it does not mean auto scum hammered.

Now thats more like it, although you couldn't say all good things now could you

Nates vote on pmc was definately OMGUS vote.

Did you have to say that twice lol.

He needs to state better reasoning. The problem with reading nate for me is I really got very little from him. He doesn't say much and when he talks I feel like this big foot is in his mouth. I do get a sense that Nat's claim is weak, but I will say something that is a bit WIFOM comment. If I was scum forced to claim and wanted to out a PR. I would just claim straight up cop so my scum partner knows who to kill.
Now it's possible there is only one mafia. This was a 14 player game and I'm going on the assumption that there may be 2 mafia and 2 wolfs. Seems a bit high but I think likely.
Based on my full read Nate is up there as scum, but not my number 1 scum suspect.

Everytime you say something bad about nate you immeadiately sa yno wait hang on a minute or you say "get a sense" you rarely commit to saying this is scummy and when you do you always then presesnt him in another light.

I also find it interesting you say there may only be one mafia, how can their be a one man mafia, you cant organise one man lol. This backs up my suspicion that you may be mafia with nate espcially when said when talking about nate.

Ive still got a lot to say on this farside but I will let you read and respond to this and let other people see it before I write so much that no one listens.

for now fos farside

[spiesr]

pmchugh makes a decent case against farside22, but scum may make cases against townies they want lynched. Also, pmchugh could be a werewolf trying to wipe out the mafia. But it still seems like a decent case.

[pmchugh]

Covering your steps much?

pmchugh makes a decent case against farside22, but scum may make cases against townies they want lynched. Also, pmchugh could be a werewolf trying to wipe out the mafia. But it still seems like a decent case.

Read as:

"I agree and disagree with you, whatever makes me look less scummy."

[spiesr]

No, I agree with you but am reminding myself not to fully trust you just yet...

[farside22]

I will have to say that Nate's claim is what through me off of not voting him. I know him coming up scum that sounds bad but I thought angel was a weird claim too.
I seriously get vibes when I read something. Something seems off about what a person said. Something doesn't ring true. The worse I could really say about Nate was his OMGUS vote.
I do think I'm write about PMC being wolf but I'm more willing to investigate into Nates partner as it means one less kill during the night.
Now Pmc if you know for fact mafia has a partner by all means let us know so we can lynch you.